This section allows you to view all Show Posts made by this member. Note that you can only see Show Posts made in areas you currently have access to.
They should bring out a commemerative photo frame of tonights team to celebrate the 23 frauds that ran out tonight.
They will go down in the Carlton Teams That Got Their Coach Sacked Hall of Fame.
Every season when the season is on the line we go to water.
Yep, we are all shattered at how the Blues are performing this year, but no point in mass depression or hysteria!
Hopefully Voss & Co will use the rest of season 2025 to get games into the young talent waiting for their chance, incl. Ben Campo., O'Farrell, Moir, Flynn Young etc
Ab
No chance, Voss is coaching for his career.
Its funny right.
We've been here before. https://afltables.com/afl/stats/coaches/carlton.html
If we sack vossy, he'll be the best coach weve sacked since David parkin. His current record is better than Rattens in terms of win percentage.
Are we sure this is the right reign to be pulling?
On the what we have done lately measure maybe, but im not convinced.
It won't matter to the anti Voss brigade. They just keep moving the goalposts, and looking sideways to justify their dogmas : in his 4th year we should be better, the list is better than the results indicate, no plan B, no match day tactical nous, was never a fan from day 1 etc.
The critical questions...
Do we persist with Voss or not? Do we blow it up and start again?
Imagine Wright would be making copious notes this afternoon.Be sharpening the blade and ordering the timber for the gallows, going to be a messy off season clearing out the deadwood.
How many years have we been rebuilding for ?
And this is the group we waited patiently for.
We were dudded.
Said it time and time again but this group of footballers will never get close to the ultimate prize as ability wise they are mid table and mentally are as weak as any team.
issue is I have no idea what needs to be done to give this list a shot at snaring a flag and based on my faith of our list management neither do they.
That's fine, but obviously so far this season allowing the coaches to rectify things hasn't been working, I didn't take everything they said literally, I read it as just trying something different, which so far in 25 they really haven't tried to think outside the square, as they believed rightly or wrongly that based on recent history our existing available squad has the skills, gameplan and experience to get it done. But we all know how that's working out so far. I'm just not sure that current coaches mc or whoever have enough lateral thinking to make something work. It's quickly approaching the point where there's nothing to lose and everything to gain from trying something different - whatever that is.
The only principle the MC should be following is to pick the best 22 to win a game of footy. If your starting point is something else (we need to change things up, we need to think laterally etc) you have already committed yourself to a dogma, which then becomes self realizing.
So you're in favour of keeping things as they are, not changing anything around? Interesting...
I'm in favour of the right thought process leading to the right action. If changes will make things worse, then why bother ? I'm not saying they will, but I cannot see how an approach of "hey what does this button do?" is going to help us. The right action may simply be allowing the players and coaches to rectify the issues.
John Kennedy Sr has, through no fault of his own, ushered in a very questionable policy that doing something is better than doing nothing. Except if you have no clue, then the action can make things worse.
I think it has become a vicious cycle. Instability causes on field inconsistency, the supporters demand success and when it doesn't come, the club reacts, causing more instability, which leads to the cycle staring again. It's no surprise that clubs who struggle to be successful are also the most unstable. Saints, North, Essendon, Carlton.