Carlton Supporters Club

Re: Rd 21: Jim Park medal Voting: Carlton vs Geelong

Reply #15 – August 18, 2014, 10:32:22 am

Team B

5 Gibbs
3 Carrazzo
3 Murphy
2 Yarran
1 Rowe
1 Docherty

Re: Rd 21: Jim Park medal Voting: Carlton vs Geelong

Reply #16 – August 18, 2014, 11:55:11 am

team . B

Carrazzo . 4
Rowe . 3
Murphy . 3
Gibbs . 2
Menzel . 2
Judd . 1

Re: Rd 21: Jim Park medal Voting: Carlton vs Geelong

Reply #17 – August 18, 2014, 01:21:55 pm

Team = C+

5 - Gibbs
4 - Carrazzo
3 - Judd
2 - Rowe
1 - Murphy

Re: Rd 21: Jim Park medal Voting: Carlton vs Geelong

Reply #18 – August 18, 2014, 02:26:36 pm

A

5 Carrazzo
4 Yarran
2 Judd
2 Gibbs
1 Waite
1 Murphy

Re: Rd 21: Jim Park medal Voting: Carlton vs Geelong

Reply #19 – August 18, 2014, 09:47:56 pm

Team:   B
We were really brave, but we still lost. Can’t get better than a B.

Votes:
[3]   Carrazzo
[2.5]   Gibbs
[2]   Judd
[1.5]   Waite
[1.5]   Bell
[1]   Murphy
[1]   Tuohy
[1]   Yarran
[0.5]   Curnow
[0.5]   Rowe
[0.5]   Sheehan

Explanations:
[3]   Carrazzo:   After being obliterated in the 1st quarter, Carrots came back to be the most influential player on the ground, keeping Selwood to 4 possessions in half a game of football, while doing a great job himself.
[2.5]   Gibbs:   Would have been worth more votes had he controlled his direct opponent, Caddy. However, he was instrumental in getting the ball out from stoppages.
[2]   Judd:   Judd will not be at his best until next year, but he was damn good for a guy still not close to 100%.
[1.5]   Waite:   Another good effort from Jarrod
[1.5]   Bell:   For a guy as fit and able to run for so long, Tom Bell never sees out a game. He always runs out of juice in the last quarter. Pity, as he was a fine performer.
[1]   Murphy:   A very different role for Murphy, but one that involved 10 tackles. But missing that goal was unforgiveable.
[1]   Tuohy:   One of his best games for the season, he did well.
[1]   Yarran:   This could have been a 3 vote game bit the mistakes were critical, especially by foot. I just don’t know why his kicking was so off, but it cost us 5 goals at least. His goal was special and he really controlled Motlop.
[0.5]   Curnow:   Didn’t do as well as keeping his man quiet, but he did get a lot of ball himself.
[0.5]   Rowe:   Good job in defence, not so good in attack.
[0.5]   Sheehan:   A good game 2nd up. Looking promising.

Honourable Mentions:
Menzel:   Pretty good until injured. But needed to kick more goals.
Wood: Probably beaten on the day, but rucked his best.
Armfield:   Not on for long, but did a good job when he came on.
Jamison:   Probably beaten by the Fat Man, but worked hard and barely had a goal against him.
Docherty: Too many errors, but he really shows he has a future.