Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS (Read 5647 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #45 –
Quote from: PaulP on
Our Contracted / Un contracted thread shows him as "2021+?", so I'm not sure how long his contract is.
I am responsible for updated that thread.

When i write '+?' next to someone it is when  someone comes across from another club but the club doesn't say how long it is for.
So for Fogarty, at a minimum he was contracted for 2021 (obviously, he just came across!) but he could potentially be under contract for longer depending on what his actual contract was.

In short, we don't know.
I've never seen anything to suggest otherwise with him.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #46 –
Quote from: townsendcalling on
So after last weeks absolute sh&tshow, Dow is the one that gets the chop!!! 

Out Murphy Dow
In Cripps Fogarty

I saw Dow being dropped and i was immediately reminded of the 'we have offers unders' for Dow rumours.

Putting 2 and 2 together.....Dow has had enough, wants out, has a suitor and is on the way out the door. Thus, no need for us to play him.

Nothing else makes sense to me.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #47 –
Quote from: kruddler on
I saw Dow being dropped and i was immediately reminded of the 'we have offers unders' for Dow rumours.

Putting 2 and 2 together.....Dow has had enough, wants out, has a suitor and is on the way out the door. Thus, no need for us to play him.

Nothing else makes sense to me.
Tend to agree....you would sign improving talent like Dow by now to keep other clubs away.
Hope we dont want to get a pick in to help pay for Cerra...

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #48 –
Quote from: ElwoodBlues1 on
Tend to agree....you would sign improving talent like Dow by now to keep other clubs away.
Hope we dont want to get a pick in to help pay for Cerra...
Send Paddy Dow to Tigerland to play with his brother.
Take their first pick back.
Use our first 2 picks at the draft (2x top 10's) and take the best players available, specifically the best young pure KPD. Not some hybrid, or some forward who could play there. I was a set and forget Weitering type.

If we must get Cerra, swap for SPS and be done with it.

Dow for Cerra? No way.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #49 –
Quote from: kruddler on
Send Paddy Dow to Tigerland to play with his brother.
Take their first pick back.
Use our first 2 picks at the draft (2x top 10's) and take the best players available, specifically the best young pure KPD. Not some hybrid, or some forward who could play there. I was a set and forget Weitering type.

If we must get Cerra, swap for SPS and be done with it.

Dow for Cerra? No way.
Media rate Cerra as two first rounders...I believe Richmond have two first rounders so they could afford to use one for Dow.
Agree on set and forget KP players, no more he might turn into X Y or Z we want the real deal up front.
IMHO I think it would be SPS and a first rounder for Cerra as the Freo asking price..I also think Fisher will feature in trade talks as well.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #50 –
Quote from: townsendcalling on
So after last weeks absolute sh&tshow, Dow is the one that gets the chop!!! 

Out Murphy Dow
In Cripps Fogarty

If the review is meaningful, it must have addressed our bizarre team selection decisions.
“Why don’t you knock it off with them negative waves? Why don’t you dig how beautiful it is out here? Why don’t you say something righteous and hopeful for a change?”  Oddball

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #51 –
Quote from: ElwoodBlues1 on
Media rate Cerra as two first rounders...I believe Richmond have two first rounders so they could afford to use one for Dow.
Agree on set and forget KP players, no more he might turn into X Y or Z we want the real deal up front.
IMHO I think it would be SPS and a first rounder for Cerra as the Freo asking price..I also think Fisher will feature in trade talks as well.
Media can rate all they want. No chance.

SPS and at most a 2nd rounder.....no more.
I'd rather keep SPS personally, but accept it may be better for all to get Cerra in and SPS out.

I've gone cold on Cerra ever since our game where he couldn't hit the side of a barn....but we seem keen so i've accepted its possible.

Dow out can only be because he is gone though, so tigers is the most logical choice.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #52 –
Samo and a first rounder for Cerra?  Tell him he’s dreaming!
“Why don’t you knock it off with them negative waves? Why don’t you dig how beautiful it is out here? Why don’t you say something righteous and hopeful for a change?”  Oddball

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #53 –
Quote from: Adelaideblue on
Last week's match report
BEST
Port Adelaide: Boak, Aliir, Amon, Wines, Bergman, Byrne-Jones, Rozee
Carlton: Walsh, Kennedy, Murphy, Dow

Ab       
ps: Paddy Dow - 18 possessions 3 marks 2 tackles (doesn't sound too bad)


Once again. Unfathomable. Selection decisions are such a mystery at Carlton.
Coming together is the beginning.
Keeping together is progress.
Working together is success.
Henry Ford.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #54 –
Quote from: DJC on
If the review is meaningful, it must have addressed our bizarre team selection decisions.

While the review may have identified it, doesn't guarantee the exec will implement necessary changes. I know that sounds cynical. However I have little confidence in the club's processes.
Coming together is the beginning.
Keeping together is progress.
Working together is success.
Henry Ford.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #55 –
Quote from: LoveNavy on
While the review may have identified it, doesn't guarantee the exec will implement necessary changes. I know that sounds cynical. However I have little confidence in the club's processes.

I understand your cynicism but, since the new president is behind the review, there must be a decent chance that its recommendations are taken seriously.

I just hope that they’re taken seriously and we no longer see blokes like Dow dropped when they were among our better players.
“Why don’t you knock it off with them negative waves? Why don’t you dig how beautiful it is out here? Why don’t you say something righteous and hopeful for a change?”  Oddball

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #56 –
So is Dow getting the 'Henderson Treatment'??

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #57 –
Hopefully that's not the case with Dow that he wants out.....but wouldn't blame him. I've been critical of him but in the second half of the season he's been given a consistent run and found steady form....plenty to build on IMO. Unfortunately there's no chance Richmond will be giving up their first rounder for Dow....we can hope but we're dreaming. Unless there's some 3 way deal that involves Cerra, Dow, SPS etc.

If he doesn't want out, then it's hard to fathom that O'Brien would hold his spot and Dow doesn't. O'Brien had that one good game about a month ago and done little else since. If anyone comes to us with an offer for him we should take whatever we can get.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #58 –
Dow not strong enough to be a top midfielder which limits where you play him. Fogarty can't kick more than 40 metres. Williams can't kick right foot and not strong enough. Lochie Obrien weak as water. Ploughman is a professional panicker when under pressure and can't read a game. Newnes, got the build to be anything and is really a nothing. Newman no right foot and weak physically, and the list goes on. Whether we see Sam Docherty pull on a Carlton guernsey again, remains to be seen. I know we all wish him the very best with this latest terrible battle.

We have got so many passengers, it's beyond a joke. IF my mail is correct, and Lyon has got the job,  I reckon he knows the weaknesses of the joint, as well as the strengths, and with a change of at least 6 personnel, maybe more, he knows that we have the players in Walsh, Weitering, Mackay,  a fully fit Cripps and a couple of others that he can build a team around to take us at least to the 8.

Re: Pre Game Promise AFL Rd 23: Carlton vs GWS

Reply #59 –
Has anybody listened to the pre game presser ? Bloody hell - 10 minutes of questions about the review, a question about Durdin and Kemp last week, and a bit about Betts at the end. What about the game boys ? Journos ? Hello ?