Carlton Supporters Club

Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

April 26, 2014, 10:26:22 pm

What a game! Amazing result, especially as we looked down and out early in the last.

Hope to see some more votes this week.

Remember:
[1] At least 3 players need to get a mention.
[2] No more than 10 votes for any one player.
[3] Give a rating of team performance
[4] Votes must add up to 15.
Enjoy!

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #1 – April 26, 2014, 10:36:07 pm

TEAM C+


Murphy 3
gibbs 2
Rowe 2
Buckley 2
Thomas 2
Yarran 1
Garlett 1
White 1
Warnock 1

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #2 – April 26, 2014, 10:47:01 pm

Team: B

3 - Murphy
2 - Gibbs
2 - McLean
2 - Warnock
2 - Jamison
1 - Simpson
1 - Waite
1 - Buckley
1 - Garlett

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #3 – April 26, 2014, 10:59:10 pm

Team B+

5 Murphy
4 McLean
3 Garlett
2 Buckley
1 Warnock

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #4 – April 26, 2014, 11:18:53 pm

B

5 Murphy
4 McLean
3 Buckley
2 Lucas
1 Thomas

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #5 – April 27, 2014, 02:14:25 am

Team; B-

5 - Murphy
4 - Gibbs
3 - McLean
1 - Buckley
1 - Rowe
1 - Garlett

Apologies to probably a half dozen other players, I thought it was a pretty even spread in this game.

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #6 – April 27, 2014, 08:30:47 am

Team - B

5 - Murphy
4 - McLean
3 - Garlett
2 - Warnock
1 - Buckley

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #7 – April 27, 2014, 03:39:17 pm

Team:   B
We were somewhat spasmodic last night, we struggled to keep the pressure up for 4 quarters. But we were very brave, especially considering the number of guys we didn't have last night.
I was happy with a lot of aspects, especially the evenness of the performance.

Votes:
[2.5]   McLean
[2.5]   Murphy
[1.5]   Rowe
[1.5]   Simpson
[1.5]   Gibbs
[1.5]   White
[1]   Thomas
[1]   Garlett
[1]   Buckley
[0.5]   Warnock
[0.5]   Waite

Explanations:
[2.5]   McLean      Broke played very well and made the most of the opportunities he had. He was excellent.
[2.5]   Murphy      For the 2nd week in a row Murphy really pulled out a good one. His stats, like Broke's, are hard to go past.
[1.5]   Rowe      Sam actually had less of the ball than any other Carlton player. However, he had probably his most effective game as a defender and totally destroyed a dangerous player in Darling.
[1.5]   Simpson   Spent most of his time in the middle and had an excellent game.
[1.5]   Gibbs      Apart from a period in the 2nd quarter when his kicking and judgement simply fled, Gibbs had a very good game. Kicking for goal: he needs work here!
[1.5]   White      Came back after a poor game last week and really did a job. he played mainly on the resting rucks and kept them almost kickless.
[1]   Thomas   Probably his best game in a Carlton guernsey to date. He simply willed himself to the contest.
[1]   Garlett      His best game for the year by a long margin. The tackling was back, the pressure was back and the smarts were back.
[1]   Buckley      Loved Dylan's run from defence.
[0.5]   Warnock   Toiled against the best ruck combo in the competition and nullified their affect. He also managed to get a number of clearances and was outmarked only once for the night.
[0.5]   Waite      Still not at his best, but he did a lot better for a lot longer and managed at least 10 marks.

Honourable mentions:
Walker      A little loose at times, but he managed to take taller opponents and nullify them while providing drive from defence. Almost vote worthy.
Henderson   Patchy, but made the most of his limited opportunities. 9 marks and a couple of nice goals.
Scotland   Not yet back to his best, but he played more consistently.
Menzel      8 possessions for a quarter was just the start. It was the negative pressure and the sure left foot that made his performance memorable.
Yarran      Until he was hurt (the first half), he was excellent and really hurt the Weagles with his run and rebound.
Casboult   More marks than in any 2 of his earlier game and a lot of pressure. Pity he can't kick, as he wasted too many scoring opportunities.

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #8 – April 27, 2014, 05:22:22 pm

Team A-

6: Murphy...last tow games has led from the front and proved he can captain the team.
2: Garlett...great attack on the footy and showed he has character.
2: Buckley....pace, excitement and will bring Blues fans back to the footy and make them members.
1: Mclean....good return game, steady perfomer
1 :Rowe..spoiler alert...now if he can only mark the footy.
1: Warnock...did well vs the highly rated WC ruck duo.
0.5 Yarran...until injured was great, been one of our best players this season
0.5 Gibbs...soem good some bad but was effective in the main..
0.5 White...like Rowe did his job and deserves some credit.
0.5 Daisy....for that smother.....

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #9 – April 27, 2014, 06:24:01 pm

 B
4.Murphy.Fantastic again
3.Simpson.Most consistant player for the whole match
2. Scotland. General..Was a big reason for the comeback, Lifted.
2.Buckley. The Kid was super..takes it on Luv him.
2.McLean. Credit where its due..great match.
1.Rowe. Workman..Team man..Admire him.Darling was he out there?
1.Garlett.Exciting to see him back in some form.

 Robbo, Jammo.Everitt,Warnock White, Gibbs all did good jobs.

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #10 – April 27, 2014, 11:08:42 pm

Team: A

4 - Murphy
2 - Simpson
2 - Buckley
1 - Gibbs
1 - McLean
1 - Warnock
1 - Waite
1 - Rowe
1 - Garlett
1 - White

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #11 – April 28, 2014, 01:25:34 am

Team: B

5 - Murphy
4 - Waite
3 - Gibbs
2 - Garlett
1 - Simpson

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #12 – April 28, 2014, 02:30:16 pm

Team: B-

5. Murphy
4. Mclean
3. Garlett
2. White
1. Buckley

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #13 – April 28, 2014, 07:27:24 pm

5 murph
4 Gibbs
3 warnock
2 Garlett
1 Jamison

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 6 Carlton d West Coast

Reply #14 – April 28, 2014, 08:42:23 pm

Team B

5 - Murphy
3 - McLean
3 - Warnock
1 - Garlett
1 - Gibbs
1 - Thomas
1 - Yarran