Re: 2015 - Is This It For Matthew Watson ??
Reply #12 –
I reckon Watson is a better option as a forward; he just doesn't seem to have the anticipation and reflexes to shut down an opponent. As a forward, he has more say in where the ball will be headed. That's not to say that he won't develop as a defender by playing as a forward.
Based on his form at the end of the season, he and Jones would have to be neck and neck as far as selection goes. Watson probably has a slight edge because he can play as a defender if necessary, and Malthouse prefers versatile players. It will be interesting to watch both of them in the pre-season as at least one career may be hanging on cementing a spot in the 22.
I think that it's good that we have two players competing for a spot, not that I'm convinced that either of them will be entirely successful. Hopefully my doubts will be disproved and at least one of them will go on to have a long and productive career with us.
If Watson can't cement a spot in the 22, his career with us will be over and he may not attract much attention from other clubs. Perhaps a club with a greater focus on development will give him a chance but I can't see a huge trade dividend for us.
Of course, if Watson does become a regular forward, what will that mean for Jones? I don't think he will displace Casboult as he isn't a competent back up ruckman.