Carlton Supporters Club

Reckon Walsh is half a chance too. Even if he is on crutches, you'd pick him over Dow wouldn't you.

Id be playing Dow and showing some faith in him....put him on a like for like player in Holmes and give him the job of running with him and show he can handle responsibility and be a reliable senior player.

Love to see Dow get a run this week - I will be mostly curious whether he has learnt to chase and tackle after six years.

You know what, I just want him to get a chance and do the role he gets asked to do. If it includes chase and tackle, great. If its to hit the scoreboard, great. If its to run with and negate a player, great. Whatever, use him to his strengths, don't try and make him something he is not. He cannot possibly be a bigger liability that Martin, Owies or Fisher right now.

I think Paddy D needs an extended stay in the 1s - he is fit, he can run, and he just needs the confidence of being selected.  Reminds me a bit of Darcy Parish who went from dud to stud in the space of 12 months.

Totally agree - give the kid a good go!

They are going to name two debutants plus 2 injured players, thats what they think of us.

Hewitt out