Carlton Supporters Club

If it's on the replay I'll try to get some clips up so we can see it.

I recall twice in the space of 5 mins that we kicked the ball over his head when Freo had a run on, both times the ball pitched in between sMurph and Freo opponents.

On the first occasion I think the bounce favoured the Freo player who took the ball and was then tackled front on by sMurph.

The second time I think the bounce went straight up and the Freo opponent was being wrestled by a Carlton player coming the same way(SoJ?) and sMurph tried to tap the ball sideways to nearby team-mate.

I wouldn't call either shirking the contest.

Perhaps the fans have been drinking too much of Malthouse's bathwater after he labelled sMurph soft during the week. All that media commentary proves is Malthouse is weak as piss and doesn't stand by his own words of having the players back!

Wasn't Malthouse instrumental in bringing Liam to PP?

Yes, but as a forward, where he was pretty ordinary. Moving him to the backline is what saved his AFL career. Of course, Jones is a quality character, and he stuck to the task of reinventing himself brilliantly, and for that he deserves considerable credit.

Some dubious types will try and tell you that it wasn't Bolton, but other coaches that suggested the switch of position, but somehow I doubt it lol.

I'd forgotten he'd come on board as a forward.  Now you mention it I seem to remember someone in the recruiting team claiming the suggestion of trying him in defence,  but not really sure now.

Paul Brodie

There were two incidents in the same position where everyone was yelling he crapped himself. The first one was completely justified, the second was an odd bounce and our fans were harsh on him because of what happened prior.

Hi All. Been a while. Thought I’d drop in again and say g’day. Hope you’ve been behaving yourselves.

Was at the game and enjoyed it immensely. 2 1/2 good quarters with lots of positives. A wins a win and I’ll take it 😀

Onto the Ruckless Suns.

Is the one you are referring to at around the 28min  of the 3rd when Saad kicks it towards him?

Just checked, no not the one.

So when is it?

There are two moments being talked about on forums, both happened about 60s apart in the 3rd Qtr.

I'm not watching it again.

Then I have to call bullsh1t!

Then I have to call you a flog.