What chance Laidler on White?? :))
Hope we put up a good show tonite. :)
I can't believe what Andrew Walker just did.
Seriously.
Bell ran 11 steps
Far out. How one sided is this umpiring.
Mick should keep his mouth shut ;-)
Far out. How one sided is this umpiring.
Mick should keep his mouth shut ;-)
That's like asking me not to post ;) ;) ;D ;D
I want to know when Mick is going to open his mouth and tell those brainless fkn forwards that we don't need all 4 of them to fly for a mark. Just brainless.
I think I've figured out a large part of our problem - we don't know how to CHEAT.
The boys are putting in. Now if those visually challenged morons that can sometimes decide the outcome of a game, actually get their decisions correct and realise that there are two teams playing out there, we might have a little snif of beating this best ever team.
Curnow and Walker, having a competition who can turnover the ball more.
1.27 to go, please don't concede a goal
Thanks for that Levi >:( >:( >:( >:(
Ivan, I've been saying it for years... since the cap penalties we are the cleanest side I have ever seen... zero "gamesmanship", no fudging around the margins... and gees does it show against side like the swines, ducker chuckers and whorks...
Great. Another red time goal. >:(
Going to script so far with soft frees to home side and plenty of gifted turnovers by us.
Red time rubbish... typical of cellar dweller sides.
RIP any sort of positional play tonight
Have to give some credit to MIck Me Mate The Master Farter. His defensive set up to combat Buddy is working an absolute treat! Buddy has two on him every time and is getting pissed.
Two things, firstly a semi-apology to Levi. What he did was stupid, but Murphy's kick to him was disgraceful and gave him no chance to mark.
Secondly, I am sick and tired of Mick not having someone at Full Forward in the last minute of a quarter.
Yes, the Swans got a goal, the ball goes back to the centre. What Mick was saying by putting Hendo down there, was, I have got no confidence in us getting the ball out of the center at the bounce. We did, and it's two against one. Just ridiculous.
Does Mick want to win, or does he want to have another honorable loss, so that at the press conference, he can crap on about how well the boys are playing without winning.
Simmo, really out of form the l;ast few weeks. As he's getting older, the rigors of a full season are becoming much harder.
Stood and watched then.
Weak Everitt >:( >:(
Onya Whitey ;D ;D
To easy
OH FER CRYIN' OUT LOUD - how bad are we at set plays/ball ups?!?
Who are our ruck coaches again?
I like Bell but can he learn to handball. Please.
Mick upset, don't blame him. Sh!!!t handball from Bell, and when you are a struggling side, little things like that, against a top team, kill you.
Now what usually happens,m is that the weaker team, will tend to drop their bundle./
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
Close you eyes and hope. Could go anywhere.
He owed us that one!!
They have got every 50/50 decision.
Proud of them so far. Are really putting in.
Just skill errors are the difference.
Johnson is struggling. Gibbs impressive.
Yarran absolutely carp tonight. Not going in hard enough. Trying to be too pretty.
About 70 % of warnocks winning tap outs are straight to the opposition.
Yarran absolutely carp tonight. Not going in hard enough. Trying to be too pretty.
Mate, Yarran never goes in hard.
Yarran absolutely carp tonight. Not going in hard enough. Trying to be too pretty.
Mate, Yarran never goes in hard.
Good point.
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Great to see a bit of passion and spirit with players getting around Johnson.
If 206 was half a ruckmens arsehole we'd be winning this game!
YAY BLAINE!!!
Great effort that half, juust need to get better at the skills and reduce the mistakes.
If 206 was half a ruckmens arsehole we'd be winning this game!
::)
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Think he's got a contract for next year or two.
If 206 was half a ruckmens arsehole we'd be winning this game!
::)
Half the a holes I've seen ruck better ;D ;D
I'd like to see ch7 get the tape measure out and see how far Bell ran and compare it to Reids allowed goal!!
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Think he's got a contract for next year or two.
Either put him up forward again or package him up for a big fat GWS trade
Great to see Blaino scoring a goal!
Bell looks dangerous definitely gives us more presence at the stoppages.
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Mate you won't find a more dedicated CFC player, he works his guts out and crap comments like this make you seem like a Richmond supporter!
Wtf did BT say about Harry Taylor to have to do that apology?
Contested footy is the theme of this game and we are doing ok with most players putting in.......Josh Kennedy has been hurting as at stoppages along with Parker and if we can nullify these two we can continue to keep pace with the Swans.
Rowe and Jamo have not been pretty but have been effective on Buddy and I like Casboults continued good form in the air....
Bell has won the footy well but stuffed up one forward entry when he should have given the ball off....the other eorr he was involved in I blamed on Ellard not Bell....not sure why Ellard was picked in the team..
Juddy has been handy along with Gibbs and Murphy who are getting some footy...
Low scoring but an enjoyable game.....
I'd like to see ch7 get the tape measure out and see how far Bell ran and compare it to Reids allowed goal!!
We counted 12 steps when we rewound it - BS Sydney-based call
I'd like to see ch7 get the tape measure out and see how far Bell ran and compare it to Reids allowed goal!!
We counted 12 steps when we rewound it - BS Sydney-based call
x2...home town call and the umpy should get dropped next week for that error...
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Mate you won't find a more dedicated CFC player, he works his guts out and crap comments like this make you seem like a Richmond supporter!
Wtf did BT say about Harry Taylor to have to do that apology?
O.K. So he works his guts out. I assume you mean that he's dedicated and trains hard, is a great team man etc etc.
BUT, he still can't stick a tackle, and his disposal has always been a major weakness. Yes, he can fly for a mark, big deal.
He has never mastered two of the basic skills that are required to make a top line footballer.
But, heis in a team where we are not exactly over-run with class players. That's why we are where we are, so he gets away with it.
Not saying that he doesn't try, but that alone is not good enough in this day and age.
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Mate you won't find a more dedicated CFC player, he works his guts out and crap comments like this make you seem like a Richmond supporter!
Wtf did BT say about Harry Taylor to have to do that apology?
I DGAF how dedicated he is to be honest.
He struggles
If 206 was half a ruckmens arsehole we'd be winning this game!
::)
Half the a holes I've seen ruck better ;D ;D
You seen many then BN?
BT called Harry Taylor a 'big poofter' for the way he waved at the crowd when chaired off last week. Twitter went into meltdown.
I'd like to see ch7 get the tape measure out and see how far Bell ran and compare it to Reids allowed goal!!
We counted 12 steps when we rewound it - BS Sydney-based call
x2...home town call and the umpy should get dropped next week for that error...
Yep, a disgrace. The instantaneous whistle was dead give-away.
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Mate you won't find a more dedicated CFC player, he works his guts out and crap comments like this make you seem like a Richmond supporter!
Wtf did BT say about Harry Taylor to have to do that apology?
O.K. So he works his guts out. I assume you mean that he's dedicated and trains hard, is a great team man etc etc.
BUT, he still can't stick a tackle, and his disposal has always been a major weakness. Yes, he can fly for a mark, big deal.
He has never mastered two of the basic skills that are required to make a top line footballer.
But, heis in a team where we are not exactly over-run with class players. That's why we are where we are, so he gets away with it.
Not saying that he doesn't try, but that alone is not good enough in this day and age.
The consistent whinge on this forum is that our players stand back and watch play - walker gets in there - he should be in our forward line but he's not he's down back where errors cost goals BUT you see how much he gets it - as Laidler so very well out it in the prerecorded interview prior to the game, he's still mates with the players and they don't know what they should do and have lost confidence in their ability.
what did BT say about Harry taylor
BT called Harry Taylor a 'big poofter' for the way he waved at the crowd when chaired off last week. Twitter went into meltdown.
He also said bitch slap last week - surely this douchebag has gone around a year too long!
Yarran has been poor this game I reckon. Has had a couple of chances to go for a hard ball but chosen to stay out of it.
Rowe has been good spoiling but gee he panics hen in possession.
Curnow has cost us with his turnovers but then done some good things in return.
Ellard....I just dont see the value in him.
McLean has been OK but gee he's slow.
We've has one shining light and thats been Casboult. When the ball in the air near him, he's just clunking everything. great to see.
We have a fair few players down tonight so far so if they can play better.....we're in this!!
I DGAF how dedicated he is to be honest.
He struggles
Zowie!
I reckon Walks has been very good tonight, definitely in our best three or four.
Murphy, Gibbs, McLean, Curnow and Simpson all good as well, if Juddy steps it up a gear we could win this.
Well done yaz, not only won't go in, but absolutely sh@@@@t himself going for the mark, so dropped his head rather than keep eyes on the ball.
I don't think that walker has stuck a tackle all year.
One of our most over rated players.
I hope he gets traded at years end, no matter what we get in return. Just save the cash cause it's wasted there
Mate you won't find a more dedicated CFC player, he works his guts out and crap comments like this make you seem like a Richmond supporter!
Wtf did BT say about Harry Taylor to have to do that apology?
O.K. So he works his guts out. I assume you mean that he's dedicated and trains hard, is a great team man etc etc.
BUT, he still can't stick a tackle, and his disposal has always been a major weakness. Yes, he can fly for a mark, big deal.
He has never mastered two of the basic skills that are required to make a top line footballer.
But, heis in a team where we are not exactly over-run with class players. That's why we are where we are, so he gets away with it.
Not saying that he doesn't try, but that alone is not good enough in this day and age.
The consistent whinge on this forum is that our players stand back and watch play - walker gets in there - he should be in our forward line but he's not he's down back where errors cost goals BUT you see how much he gets it - as Laidler so very well out it in the prerecorded interview prior to the game, he's still mates with the players and they don't know what they should do and have lost confidence in their ability.
All of them or just a few?
Has Rowe? Judd? Casboult? Murphy? Gibbs? Curnow?
Walker has had one good year in 10?
Great return
Yeah well we've win 5 games this year, says it all
THat's what I mean about Walker. >:( >:( >:( >:( >:(
Actually i take that back. That was a magnificent pass by walker to the swans player. ::) ::)
Ellard, useless. Not up to it. And can't play out a full game even when he's fully fit.
Why did rowe move around off the mark to give Budddy a betty angle at goal???
I've watched the game for 60 years, and believe it or not NOTHING has changed.
Top teams will always be favoured by the umpires. And I mean always.
Star players will always get the benefit of the doubt. And I mean always.
Walker, Rowe, etc don't have the ability to compete against the top players. So they try to get away with holding.
Walker has been doing it for years. now when it's against Joe blogs, the umps let it go. When it's against Goodes, or Ablett and star players like that, he will get pinged every time. And he has never learnt.
gibbs and murphy wrestling for the same ball - laughable
Why did rowe move around off the mark to give Budddy a betty angle at goal???
Do you or any one else for that matter, really believe that Rowe would get a game at the Swans, geelong, Hawthorn, Port, even the filth? He's in the team because we don't have anyone else. His lack of ability and lack of a football brain, which is why he always panics under pressure, will ensure that if Mick is really going to rebuild, despite the admiration that Mick has for Rowe, he will not be in our best side either next year, or the year after.
This is our cup of tea quarter. We always have one, last week is was the second quarter against the aints.
Better quality list because sydney have kinear beatson and carlton have nothing.....
If Ellard is the 22nd best man currently available, then we are tanking.
Not that hew's had much opportunity, but I reckon Juddy is playing like a man who has got the sh!!ts with what Mick said.
If Ellard is the 22nd best man currently available, then we are tanking.
He hasn't played for 6 weeks, Graham has played every week, yet they make graham the sub.
I smell a ton coming
We are getting slaughtered now......
I heard they are having Twinnings English Breakfast, but I reckon it's Earl Grey.
So pleased MM bought Daisy over what a superstar
its camomile
Can we play Stkilda again next week :-\ :-\ ::) ::) ;D
Exactly... Play a quarter fit struggler and leave a kid on the pine... Tanking.
its camomile
Well picked mate. That always puts me to sleep.
Jamo pulled buddy's pants down in the first half. Hasn't been near him since.
Just for interest, since the game is boring, have any of you noticed how as soon as some players get a bit of publicity in a week after they have played well, they can't get a touch the next week.
A few years ago, Betts, garletrt, and Yarran got the title the three amigos and there was a double page spread about them. They had starred for a few weeks. After that article, they barely got a touch and never really functioned well together.
Eddie copped a lot of publicity last week, after kicking 5 goals. Double page spread in the H. S. etc. This week, when the Crows could have done with 5 goals from him, 3 possessions.
Levi, lots of publicity, greatest mark in the league and so on. Haven't counted and don't know his possys, but he's had no effect on the game, even in the first half when we were putting in. Oh well.
Why ndidnt Thomas try and mark that ball???????
Terrible fkn effort!
Jamo pulled buddy's pants down in the first half. Hasn't been near him since.
They've been rotating the whole game.
Levi has been ok, far from our worst. Only one mark inside 50.
Levi has marked what's come to him.
Daisy is a dud recruit as is Malthouse
Why ndidnt Thomas try and mark that ball???????
Terrible fkn effort!
I saw that too, it was perfectly weighted, centimetre perfect. I guess he will collect his 750k regardless so....
Why ndidnt Thomas try and mark that ball???????
Terrible fkn effort!
That chamomile tea will slow down the best of us. ;) ;)
Thinking the players have less interest than we have. Let me guess, the big cull will be the big news item again tomorrow
We are being slaughtered now......
We are light years behind the big clubs now.
Yep folks....all the boards fault.....
Levi has marked what's come to him.
Daisy is a dud recruit as is Malthouse
Hasn't marked like last week. Mind you the opposition is 10 classes above last weeks.
But my point is that it doesn't matter who they are, unless they are an out and out champion, after they get a serve of publicity, they rarely perform as well the next week.
We are light years away from being a competitive top 8 team based on what we are witnessing tonight. :(
Have to say it, Rowe is the ultimate panicker under pressure.
Anyone still want to defend Walker??
We are light years away from being a competitive top 8 team based on what we are witnessing tonight. :(
But we are a very good bottom 8 team.
Hang on, I forgot, Brisbane, Melbourne and GWS beat us.
I take that back. :-[ :-[
Levi has marked what's come to him.
Daisy is a dud recruit as is Malthouse
Hasn't marked like last week. Mind you the opposition is 10 classes above last weeks.
But my point is that it doesn't matter who they are, unless they are an out and out champion, after they get a serve of publicity, they rarely perform as well the next week.
Levi had a decent night, has 7 marks, alot of them good ones. He and Rowe are a couple of our most improved players. Problem is most of the other lazy, disinterested pr1cks that don't like hard work. Go from a half where basically one-sided umpiring stopped us leading at half time, to 13 goals down a qtr and a half later. That's just garbage.
Why ndidnt Thomas try and mark that ball???????
Terrible fkn effort!
I saw that too, it was perfectly weighted, centimetre perfect. I guess he will collect his 750k regardless so....
Laidler's doing pretty well.
MMs even managed to kill Meat's confidence!
Levi has marked what's come to him.
Daisy is a dud recruit as is Malthouse
Hmm, I don't think Levi has marked all that's come to him. ;) ;) ;)
We are light years away from being a competitive top 8 team based on what we are witnessing tonight. :(
But we are a very good bottom 8 team.
Hang on, I forgot, Brisbane, Melbourne and GWS beat us.
I take that back. :-[ :-[
But we did thrash the bottom team last week. ::)
Sick of listening to these C7 spuds say Judd is cooked but Goodes is a spring chicken!
They are fecking nerds with no idea!
Levi has marked what's come to him.
Daisy is a dud recruit as is Malthouse
Hasn't marked like last week. Mind you the opposition is 10 classes above last weeks.
But my point is that it doesn't matter who they are, unless they are an out and out champion, after they get a serve of publicity, they rarely perform as well the next week.
Levi had a decent night, has 7 marks, alot of them good ones. He and Rowe are a couple of our most improved players. Problem is most of the other lazy, disinterested pr1cks that don't like hard work. Go from a half where basically one-sided umpiring stopped us leading at half time, to 13 goals down a qtr and a half later. That's just garbage.
I reckon Levi will be a good player for us when he gets better with his ground skills and does more with his second efforts.
Rowe, hasn't got it. It's as simple as that. Just watched him a minute a go. he had no idea what to do. he can't perform under pressure, and is just not good enough.
If you think that Rowe is a player that is going to help us make the 8, then I believe you are sadly mistaken.
Anyone still want to defend Walker??
Having a shocking year.
We are light years away from being a competitive top 8 team based on what we are witnessing tonight. :(
But we are a very good bottom 8 team.
Hang on, I forgot, Brisbane, Melbourne and GWS beat us.
I take that back. :-[ :-[
But we did thrash the bottom team last week. ::)
Yeah, you are right. Mind you 6 of their players were playing for us. ::) ::)
The sad part is , in the NB team, there is little that hasn't been tried already to come up and make much difference
The sad part is , in the NB team, there is little that hasn't been tried already to come up and make much difference
There will be some sort of clean out, despite the denials, and it will be more of the same next year, unfortunately.
So pleased MM bought Daisy over what a superstar
What the fork does this have to do with tonight's performance? He's done more than most in the side tonight including Judd. You should be forking pleased that MM is gonna cut a third of this team loose at years end. Focusing on Thomas is just opportunistic rubbish.
Everiit, not even sweating, kicks goal and trots off the ground. I still can't work out why that happens.
For the sake of my health and that of the TV, I can't watch Carlton games live on TV, so my choice of keeping myself updated is via the comments here & the AFL website for the score/stats. I feel ill right about now & am more than happy to never see a single second of this game.....the first half sounded half-decent, but this second half......yikes.
I reckon Thomas will be great next year with a full pre-season under his belt.
The problem is, that we probably won't have a much better side than we have this year.
we are not a good football club, and not well coached.
we don't even have a CEO
There will be some sort of clean out, despite the denials, and it will be more of the same next year, unfortunately.
They should start with the coach, for the very few that have improved far more have gone backwards under MM and faster than any since we appointed Pagan.
Daisy might be nothing more than MMs version of Mick Martyn?
The sad part is , in the NB team, there is little that hasn't been tried already to come up and make much difference
There will be some sort of clean out, despite the denials, and it will be more of the same next year, unfortunately.
yes I think you will be right, the of lack of success in the draft 3-4 years ago have left a hole we have never filled
For the sake of my health and that of the TV, I can't watch Carlton games live on TV, so my choice of keeping myself updated is via the comments here & the AFL website for the score/stats. I feel ill right about now & am more than happy to never see a single second of this game.....the first half sounded half-decent, but this second half......yikes.
I'm a sadist Brettie.
I'm having an orgasm watching this. >:D >:D >:D
On paper we don't look that sh1t. Problem starts when they run onto the ground. It's more the fact they have a poor work ethic, poor culture and a poor attitude. You get the same result as being sh1t. It's more disappointing than being sh1t to be honest.
In the competition between Waite and walker to see who can fall over and lose their footing more during a match, Walker is 36 falling overs' in front.
I heard that Waite is desperate to get back into the team so that he has a chance of catching up. ::) ::)
On paper we don't look that sh1t. Problem starts when they run onto the ground. It's more the fact they have a poor work ethic, poor culture and a poor attitude. You get the same result as being sh1t. It's more disappointing than being sh1t to be honest.
toilet paper?
Well, Waite is a fair chance of playing next week. No matter how he performs, I reckon Hendo will be missing.
Well, Waite is a fair chance of playing next week. No matter how he performs, I reckon Hendo will be missing.
There are 6 players I'd drop before Hendo,.
But they won't.
For the sake of my health and that of the TV, I can't watch Carlton games live on TV, so my choice of keeping myself updated is via the comments here & the AFL website for the score/stats. I feel ill right about now & am more than happy to never see a single second of this game.....the first half sounded half-decent, but this second half......yikes.
I'm a sadist Brettie.
I'm having an orgasm watching this. >:D >:D >:D
You're a sick man bignic.....a sick, sick man :D
I think Bell, Walker and Ellard might be outs.
For the sake of my health and that of the TV, I can't watch Carlton games live on TV, so my choice of keeping myself updated is via the comments here & the AFL website for the score/stats. I feel ill right about now & am more than happy to never see a single second of this game.....the first half sounded half-decent, but this second half......yikes.
I'm a sadist Brettie.
I'm having an orgasm watching this. >:D >:D >:D
You're a sick man bignic.....a sick, sick man :D
;D ;D ;D
Well, Waite is a fair chance of playing next week. No matter how he performs, I reckon Hendo will be missing.
There are 6 players I'd drop before Hendo,.
But they won't.
Got caught by the TV coathanging some Sydney guy in the first quarter. Channel 7 were very happy to show it.
Was really wrapped with Caz in 1st half but gee he sooked it up and just gave up in the 2nd half. Bloody disappointing.
Robert walls once told me that after he had coached Brissy to a 100 point loss one night, on the way home, he went through all the players he decided to drop for the next game. he came up with 16 of them.
he said that he realised that you never make those decisions on the night after a game.
I reckon Mick would drop 10 of them if he could. But he won't.
There will be some sort of clean out, despite the denials, and it will be more of the same next year, unfortunately.
They should start with the coach, for the very few that have improved far more have gone backwards under MM and faster than any since we appointed Pagan.
Daisy might be nothing more than MMs version of Mick Martyn?
X2
This team is not a team. They rarely look like they are enjoying themselves. Lucky they MM told us Syd was the best team going around in the past 40 years.
When is MM going to be held accountable to some of you?
Wrap it up, guys. Time for the Post Match Pain. There will be plenty to go around this week.
We re sloooooooow , outpaced and outrun in second half at almost every contest, we looked old and slow...