Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo (Read 6508 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

We showed so much courage tonight that it pains me to lose, especially as we did. However, I hope the voters were able to get over their grief: I will when we pick up a better kid on Nation Draft Day. But we really showed a lot tonight, so I hope plenty of people feel they saw enough to vote realistically.

Remember:
[1] At least 3 players need to get a mention.
[2] No more than 10 votes for any one player.
[3] Give a rating of team performance
[4] Votes must add up to 15.
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #1 –
Team B+

Judd: 5 (carried the side from the first bounce)
Simpson: 4 (utter class)
Murphy: 3 (some very good passages, hard at the ball)
Yarran: 1 (set up some good portions of play)
Curnow: 1 (kept Hill quiet for 3 1/2 quarters)
Thomas: 0.5 (best game he's played)
Docherty: 0.5 (that out of bounds in the last killed us, but was hard at the contest all night)
Why did the Carlton FC fall? So they could learn to pick themselves up.

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #2 –
Team, B

Judd 5
Simpson 3
Murphy 2
White 2
Curnow 2
yarran 1
"everything you know is wrong"

Paul Hewson

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #3 –
Team B

5 Judd
4 Murphy
3 Simpson
2 Docherty
1 Thomas
IN WADA WE TRUST

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #4 –
Team: B

4 - Simpson
4 - Judd
3 - Murphy
2 - Yarran
1 - Thomas
1 - Waite

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #5 –
[Team:   B
A bitter – sweet result if there ever was one, it makes rating the game problematical. To play so well for so much of the game, but to get so few rewards and a heartbreak to finish….
I look forward to visiting the Undiscovered Country: the Future.

Votes:
[3]   Judd
[2.5]   Simpson
[2]   Waite
[1.5]   Thomas
[1.5]   Gibbs
[1]   Murphy
[1]   Yarran
[1]   Curnow
[0.5]   Carrazzo
[0.5]   Docherty
[0.5]   Rowe

Explanations:
[3]   Judd:   Until Judd got injured, he was so far BOG that it was a reminder of just how much we have missed him this year. Superb. Unfortunately his ankle injury changed the game, as he only managed a couple more possessions for the night.
[2.5]   Simpson:   3.5 brilliant quarters and a goal that should have been match winning. Simmo gave his all.
[2]   Waite:   For the 2nd week in a row Waite really stepped up and took some excellent marks. Our forward structure works so much better with Waite playing well.
[1.5]   Thomas:   Probably his best game for Carlton, even though he did make some ordinary decisions late in the game. He did a good defensive job and his ability to get the ball was excellent.
[1.5]   Gibbs:   Started a bit quietly, but he really lifted his game and managed a lot of clearances. His snap at goal came within inches of winning the game.
[1]   Murphy:   21 possessions was probably his best return against the hard tag all year. The way he stood up to Crowley and the way the other players supported him was pleasing.
[1]   Yarran:   Another strong game from Yazz in defence. His run out of defence was excellent.
[1]   Curnow:   Played on Hill all night and really made him ineffective.
[0.5]   Carrazzo:   Like Curnow, Carrots played an excellent defensive game and helped to totally smother the Freo midfield.
[0.5]   Docherty:   Very good for much of the game. Unfortunately he still makes some terrible errors under pressure.
[0.5]   Rowe:   Took Pavlich apart until Pavlich was injured. After that he no longer had a good match up and ended up forward.

Honourable Mentions:
Jamison:   Took his man to the cleaners, even though he didn’t have huge stats himself.
Tuohy:   3.5 quarters of totally blanketing Ballantyne, who managed only 8 possessions for the night.
Henderson:   Got a fair bit of the ball, but generally too far from goal.
White:   Did a very good negating job.
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #6 –
Team C

4: Simpson
3: Murphy:
3: Judd
1: Waite
1: White
1: Docherty
1: Curnow
1: Thomas

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #7 –
Team; B

5 - Judd
4 - Simpson
2 - Yarran
2 - Thomas
1 - Waite
1 - Curnow
Mens sana in corpore sano - A healthy mind in a healthy body.

Navy, it's not just a color, it's an attitude !!!

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #8 –
Quote from: ElwoodBlues1 on
Team C

4: Simpson
3: Murphy:
3: Judd
1: Waite
1: White
1: Docherty
1: Curnow
1: Thomas
bit harsh E.B a C for the team
TEAM B+
 5 Judd
 4 Simpson
 3 Thomas
 1 Yarran
 1 Waite
.5 Curnow
.5 Docherty

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #9 –
Quote from: hotspur on
Quote from: ElwoodBlues1 on
Team C

4: Simpson
3: Murphy:
3: Judd
1: Waite
1: White
1: Docherty
1: Curnow
1: Thomas
bit harsh E.B a C for the team
TEAM B+
 5 Judd
 4 Simpson
 3 Thomas
 1 Yarran
 1 Waite
.5 Curnow
.5 Docherty

Not really HS...I usually go the E when we lose but felt C was appropriate given the effort minus the mistakes....Ellards misses, Levis dropped marks and Touhys 50metre made  a B into a C.... :(

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #10 –
Team B+

Judd - 5
Simpson - 4
Murphy - 3
Wood - 2
Waite - 1

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #11 –
Team B

5 Judd
4 Thomas
3 Murphy
2 Simpson
1 Waite

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #12 –
Team = B

[5]   Simpson
[3]   Judd
[3]   Waite
[1]   Thomas
[1]   Gibbs
[1]   Murphy
[1]   Yarran


Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #13 –
3 Simpson

3 Judd

3 Murphy

3 Gibbs

3 Carrazzo
Ignorance is bliss.

ONWARDS AND UPWARDS!

Re: Jim Park Medal Voting: Carlton vs Freo

Reply #14 –
Team - B

5 - Judd
4 - Simpson
3 - Murphy
2 - Carrazzo
1 - Thomas