Carlton Supporters Club

Around The Grounds => The Sports Desk => Topic started by: LP on January 18, 2024, 01:38:53 pm

Title: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: LP on January 18, 2024, 01:38:53 pm
Interesting Hun post from Craddock, listing his Top Ten Fast bowlers of all time;

Crash's best quicks of all time
(https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/cricket/australia-v-west-indies-day-2-all-the-latest-news-and-highlights-from-adelaide-oval/news-story/b7087c333178b11324553d99bc3bcdfd)
1 Malcolm Marshall (West Indies 81 Tests. 376 wickets at 20.94)
2 Wasim Akram (Pakistan. 104 Tests. 414 wickets at 23.62)
3 Dennis Lillee (Australia 70 Tests. 355 wickets at 23.92)
4 Glenn McGrath (Australia. 124 Tests. 563 wickets at 21.64)
5 Curtly Ambrose (West Indies. 98 Tests. 405 wickets at 20.99)
6 Dale Steyn (South Africa. 93 Tests. 439 wickets at 22.95)
7 Richard Hadlee (New Zealand. 86 Tests. 431 wickets at 22.29)
8 Waqar Younis (Pakistan. 87 Tests. 373 wickets at 23.56)
9 Imran Khan (Pakistan. 88 Tests. 362 wickets at 22.81)
10 Fred Trueman (England. 67 Tests. 307 wickets at 21.57)

I realise these lists are generational and personal, you can really only judge those you have seen, but I think there are a couple of potential omissions. Andy Roberts, Bob Willis, Kapil Dev, Joel Garner, James Anderson to name a few, on the above list I would probably have Hadlee and Khan higher in the list.

Fred Trueman I wouldn't rate above Willis, and having talked to some past test players many would rate John Snow ahead of them all but to be a great you also need longevity I suppose. But the title says best, and best is subjective.

Can't see how Marshall gets in ahead of Roberts or Garner, to me Roberts is the clear leader.

Khan in my eyes was better than Akram and Younis, maybe he gets a kicking for being a politician.

Kapil Dev is mighty unlucky not to be on the list, especially given he spent a career bowling on pitches that were doctored for spinners.

I'd probably have Roberts and Lillee the Top 2 slots in any order, the rest is a coin toss.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Lods on January 18, 2024, 01:43:36 pm
"Best fast bowler ever was a woman..... Lillian Thomson." ;)
Eric Morecombe.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: LP on January 18, 2024, 01:48:59 pm
Just an addendum to this, a lot of those olden days players never got to play many or any tests against Bangladesh, Zimbabwe, Afghanistan or Ireland, they might not contribute much but they do boost some of the modern day players figures a little.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: kruddler on January 18, 2024, 04:06:14 pm
"Best fast bowler ever was a woman..... Lillian Thomson." ;)
Eric Morecombe.
Took me a while.  :D
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: DJC on January 18, 2024, 06:02:21 pm
I agree that you can't leave out Andy Roberts, Bob Willis, Kapil Dev and Joel Garner, and Michael "Whispering Death" Holding has to be included, as does Frank Tyson, the fastest bowler of all time.  Jeff Thomson is another can't be left out.

Mike Procter didn't get to play many Tests but he was an outstanding quick who terrorised Australian batsmen.

Those lists are always fraught; apart from more Test playing nations of variable standards, there's the old timey playing conditions, different balls, bowling combinations, helmets, different rules, better pitches, longevity vs impact, and countless other factors that make it anything but objective.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: ElwoodBlues1 on January 18, 2024, 06:34:17 pm
I'd have Marshall as No 1, Imran was a terrific cricketer given he averaged 38 with the bat and had to captain Pakistan.
Dale Steyns strike rate was excellent but Dennis Lillee though always remained the most exciting quick I have seen...
A little remembered  NZ quick named Shane Bond could have broken a lot of records if he could have stayed on the park, was quick, accurate and had a great strike rate.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Lods on January 18, 2024, 06:36:51 pm
I was a bit of a cricket tragic as a kid but went off it a bit after the World Series cricket.
Nowadays I hardly watch it.
As a youngster I enjoyed watching the 'Demon' Fred Spofforth :D
But the player who had the most impact was Lillee.

John Snow terrorised us in one series early in the 70s and was probably the most impressive opposition player while I was watching.


Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Gointocarlton on January 18, 2024, 07:15:36 pm
I know SFA about Cricket compared to many here. For me there's best (wickets, strike rate etc) and there's scary fast (intimidation, make the batsmen fill their undies). For me when I think of "fast bowlers" I always think scary fast. For mine its Thomo, Holding, Marshall, Ambrose and ol mate Shoaib  "The Rawalpindi Express" Akhtar. I reckon Thomo was the scariest of the lot, Holding was my favourite (smoothest mover and action), Ambrose and Shoaib were the most intimidating/menacing.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: ElwoodBlues1 on January 18, 2024, 08:30:14 pm
I was a bit of a cricket tragic as a kid but went off it a bit after the World Series cricket.
Nowadays I hardly watch it.
As a youngster I enjoyed watching the 'Demon' Fred Spofforth :D
But the player who had the most impact was Lillee.

John Snow terrorised us in one series early in the 70s and was probably the most impressive opposition player while I was watching.



Agree on Snow, I had a copy of his book " The Art of Bowling"  when I was a kid and it was the most practical useful cricket book I ever read in terms of grips on the ball, getting your runup right and having your body in the right position to bowl every type of delivery whether you were a spinner, medium pacer or fast bowler.
He had a deadly bouncer, was hated by Aus crowds with one spectator grabbing Snow on the boundary and then tried to remonstrate with him .He was a nasty bloke with a cricket ball in his hand. I think he hit Terry Jenner in the head from memory and finished Bill Lawry's career. Jimmy Anderson might go down as maybe the greatest English quick in terms of wickets, tests played etc but he wasnt/isnt half as good as Snow was imho.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: DJC on January 18, 2024, 09:15:55 pm
Our fast bowlers, like Connolly, McKenzie and the unfortunate Meckiff, were generally fairly benign until Lillee arrived.  Together with Thomson, Pascoe, Froggy and McDermott, Lillee changed that.

If I was picking the late 20th century, early 21st century fast bowlers who had the most impact on the game, Merv Hughes would be right up there 🙄
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Baggers on January 19, 2024, 08:08:56 am
Wow, so many impressive names; champs.

I confess to having lost a lot of interest in cricket over the past decade, or two. Kind of coincided with the decline of the West Indies.

The fast bowlers I loved watching, not only for talent but also for uniqueness of character: Lillee, Holding, Steyn and Hadlee. I'd give a special mention to Rodney Hogg, he had the knack of holding down an end and frustrating batsmen into taking risks against whoever bowled at the other end!
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: DJC on January 19, 2024, 08:53:45 am
Wow, so many impressive names; champs.

I confess to having lost a lot of interest in cricket over the past decade, or two. Kind of coincided with the decline of the West Indies.

The fast bowlers I loved watching, not only for talent but also for uniqueness of character: Lillee, Holding, Steyn and Hadlee. I'd give a special mention to Rodney Hogg, he had the knack of holding down an end and frustrating batsmen into taking risks against whoever bowled at the other end!

Forgot about Hogg.  If I remember correctly, it was Rodney who screamed as he ran in to bowl to Derek Randall, “I’ll knock your f…..g head off, you f…..g Pommy c..t!”

He certainly had the gift of the gab 🙂
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Lods on January 19, 2024, 09:04:33 am
Just for uniqueness....Alan 'Froggy' Thomson.

Not express pace but...
His windmill type action was quite efffective.
I actually tried to copy it and found it was pretty good for controlling and generating swing.
But I had two paces....slow and none.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iq0yA1xS4-4

Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Baggers on January 19, 2024, 09:22:27 am
Although not express or overly fast, Ian Botham was a terrific bowler and quite a character, oft times, polarising.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Gointocarlton on January 19, 2024, 03:52:54 pm
Forgot about Hogg.  If I remember correctly, it was Rodney who screamed as he ran in to bowl to Derek Randall, “I’ll knock your f…..g head off, you f…..g Pommy c..t!”

He certainly had the gift of the gab 🙂
Good Thornbury High School lad is R Hogg.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: DJC on January 19, 2024, 04:02:57 pm
Good Thornbury High School lad is R Hogg.

One of my mates - sadly killed many years ago now - was charged with assaulting Rodney after allegedly catching him with his missus  ::)
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: Gointocarlton on January 20, 2024, 07:02:22 am
One of my mates - sadly killed many years ago now - was charged with assaulting Rodney after allegedly catching him with his missus  ::)
S h I t bloke is Rodney😒
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: northernblue on January 20, 2024, 03:42:20 pm
S h I t bloke is Rodney😒

What a bizarre comment.
Not that I care but was Rodney married ?
Maybe the ladies husband was too busy down the pub with DJC and not paying attention to his wife ?
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: DJC on January 20, 2024, 04:25:46 pm
What a bizarre comment.
Not that I care but was Rodney married ?
Maybe the ladies husband was too busy down the pub with DJC and not paying attention to his wife ?

My mate's missus was all class ... and very free with her favours  ::)

Maybe I'm old fashioned but if a bloke gets caught and cops a hiding, shoudn't that be the end of it.

My old man was a character witness for my mate and the magistrate must have been sympathetic (or a batsman) and didn't record a conviction.  They divorced, my mate married again and they had two children before he was tragically killed.
Title: Re: Best Fast Bowlers
Post by: northernblue on January 20, 2024, 09:29:59 pm
My mate's missus was all class ... and very free with her favours  ::)

Maybe I'm old fashioned but if a bloke gets caught and cops a hiding, shoudn't that be the end of it.

My old man was a character witness for my mate and the magistrate must have been sympathetic (or a batsman) and didn't record a conviction.  They divorced, my mate married again and they had two children before he was tragically killed.

Always at least three people involved in infidelity and they all have a story.
I don’t think there’s any human relationship story that’s simply black and white, innocent and/or guilty.
I heard one guys telling of a situation similar to Rodney’s, he got out of bed and said “I’m not your partner”… slightly cowardly perhaps, but valid.
Sorry you lost your mate DJC.