Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday (Read 12654 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Northern Blues vs. Geelong Cats
Sunday 29th June
Preston City Oval at 1:00pm

Northern Blues
B:  Tuohy M. Watson White
HB: McInnes Anthony Sheehan
C: Armfield Graham Lucas
HF: T. Thomas Henderson B. Johnson
F: Wilkinson Waite Wilson
R: Wood Bell Garlett
Int: Dufficy Reynolds Coulson Totevski J. Gleeson Temay Dirago Cattapan McDonald* Byrne Holman D. Watson Bolger

Geelong Cats
B: Bourke Hamling Hunt
HB: Thurlow Sully Smedts
C: Hartman Sheringham Stringer
HF: Hollmer Walker McCarthy
F: Luxford Brown Toohey
R: Banjanin Schroder Gleeson
Int: Gibbs Bensted* Paliouras Sherman Maas Bath McFarlane Tudor Herbison

Couple of interesting names: Byrne was supposed to have an injured knee, yet he is named, as is White. Bell is a much higher probability to play, which is a positive move.
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #1 –
Sandringham vs. Northern Blues
Sunday 29th June
Trevor Barker Beach Oval at 10:00am

Sandringham
B: Plostins Le Grice Beech
HB: Hudghton Harris Daidone
C: Waterman Maitland Hooy
HF: Barnhoorn McTaggart Graham
F: Spencer Dowler Cameron
R: Persson Widdowson Verma
Int: Davis Whitehead B. Coates Pierce Bolger Holmes White Dawes Kelso

Northern Blues
B: D. Watson M. Gleeson Callaway
HB: J. Gleeson Dirago Posar
C: Temay Taglieri H. Curnow
HF: Totevski Murray Cattapan
F: Dorman Walton Dufficy
R: Coulson Tardio McCann
Int: Toman Haynes J. Roberts Yelland Grimes M. Johnson Emley Sutton K. Roberts Bowkett Young
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #2 –
Waite to kick 10.  :(
The only thing in this world worth more than a hill of beans is the Carlton Football Club.

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #4 –
Quote from: JonHenry on
Quote from: blue4life on
Waite to kick 10.  :(

If he was any good and not a sook he wouldn't get dropped

He's no loss, Levi and Lachie will kick a bag each in the seniors.  ::)
The only thing in this world worth more than a hill of beans is the Carlton Football Club.

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #5 –
Quote from: blue4life on
Quote from: JonHenry on
Quote from: blue4life on
Waite to kick 10.  :(

If he was any good and not a sook he wouldn't get dropped

He's no loss, Levi and Lachie will kick a bag each in the seniors.  ::)

He's not going to take us where we need to go. Move him on and find someone who can!

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #6 –
If we cannot get trade value for him (highly unlikely now) then there is no point moving him on. We don't have enough coverage in those areas so we might as well keep him. His 10 years is up this year I think so he won't cost us much to keep and he can play several positions. If nothing else he gives us depth for another year or two.

What's the alternative?

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #7 –
Quote from: spf on
If we cannot get trade value for him (highly unlikely now) then there is no point moving him on. We don't have enough coverage in those areas so we might as well keep him. His 10 years is up this year I think so he won't cost us much to keep and he can play several positions. If nothing else he gives us depth for another year or two.

What's the alternative?

The problem with this group is they were mentored by the likes of Stevens, camporeale, Whitnall, Beaumont, Allen and Thornton.

We don't need sooks like Waite and Walker teaching the kids their bad habits.

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #8 –
Waite must be the new whipping boy because there were others who were worse last week.  Walker for one should consider himself blessed as his form has been worse than awful.
DrE is no more... you ok with that harmonica man?

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #9 –
Let Waite go as FA if he wants to play on and get a compo pick. We'd get more in compo than we'd get in a trade.

He's 31. He is not the future. He cannot be on our list next year. He is a horrible example if we are trying to rebuild.

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #10 –
Quote from: emtwenty on
Let Waite go as FA if he wants to play on and get a compo pick. We'd get more in compo than we'd get in a trade.

He's 31. He is not the future. He cannot be on our list next year. He is a horrible example if we are trying to rebuild.

Don't tell me we're rebuilding again !!!!!!!!!!!!!
How long will it take this time?
The only thing in this world worth more than a hill of beans is the Carlton Football Club.

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #11 –
Quote from: blue4life on
Quote from: emtwenty on
Let Waite go as FA if he wants to play on and get a compo pick. We'd get more in compo than we'd get in a trade.

He's 31. He is not the future. He cannot be on our list next year. He is a horrible example if we are trying to rebuild.

Don't tell me we're rebuilding again !!!!!!!!!!!!!
How long will it take this time?
If we're not rebuilding then we're contending. And we're obviously not going to get anywhere near finals with this list.

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #12 –
Quote from: emtwenty on
Let Waite go as FA if he wants to play on and get a compo pick. We'd get more in compo than we'd get in a trade.

He's 31. He is not the future. He cannot be on our list next year. He is a horrible example if we are trying to rebuild.

Spot on

Win win for all parties
“Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect.”

― Mark Twain

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #13 –
Quote from: Professer E on
Waite must be the new whipping boy because there were others who were worse last week.  Walker for one should consider himself blessed as his form has been worse than awful.

Certainly our only effective tall forward last week.  We must be tanking.
“Why don’t you knock it off with them negative waves? Why don’t you dig how beautiful it is out here? Why don’t you say something righteous and hopeful for a change?”  Oddball

Re: Northern Blues vs. Geelong at Preston on Sunday

Reply #14 –
Quote from: emtwenty on
Let Waite go as FA if he wants to play on and get a compo pick. We'd get more in compo than we'd get in a trade.

He's 31. He is not the future. He cannot be on our list next year. He is a horrible example if we are trying to rebuild.

FA? I didn't know he had suitors. GWS players absolutely, Gold Coast yep - Carlton ?????

The players clubs are interested in are the Yarran, Murphy, Gibbs, Walker types with perhaps a Casboult type but not for anything that would really benefit us.

Waite will either retire or play out his career at Carlton. A couple of years back (27 - 28 years age bracket) yes he had currency but I don't think he does now. Who would take him? Fremantle? Hawks? Can't see it happening nor the Power and the Swans definitely don't need him.