Re: Carlton B & F Reply #90 – September 19, 2014, 10:46:49 am Without being privy to the voting criteria I remain a touch sceptical about some of the players that filled out the top 10, but other than Curnow I don't see who really missed out. I reckon Docherty had an encouraging year but top 10 BnF is a stretch, ditto Thomas.
Re: Carlton B & F Reply #91 – September 19, 2014, 10:59:12 am Quote from: Professer E on September 19, 2014, 10:46:49 amWithout being privy to the voting criteria I remain a touch sceptical about some of the players that filled out the top 10, but other than Curnow I don't see who really missed out. I reckon Docherty had an encouraging year but top 10 BnF is a stretch, ditto Thomas.That's the thing, we're not privy to the roles players are given so it's difficult for us to judge whether a player did their job well.
Re: Carlton B & F Reply #92 – September 19, 2014, 11:11:55 am * Being cute, with 18 guys on the paddock, being in the top ten means best half!Still, I loved the results.* Can I dare ask why it took so many years to play BryceG in the midfield? Or did it not make sense to stick SamR down back?Do we take too long to rely on the obvious?*Great move to fit Casboult in as the second ruckman/forward !*Hey our best first year player only got very late games! we wonder why not earlier?
Re: Carlton B & F Reply #93 – September 19, 2014, 11:48:47 am Good to see all three of the players we traded in last summer finishing top 10 in the B&F, we might be finally starting to get things right.Congrats to Bryce Gibbs, he had an outstanding season.
Re: Carlton B & F Reply #94 – September 19, 2014, 03:04:44 pm It's interesting to compare the CSC B&F with CFC's version: CFC CSC1 - Gibbs Gibbs2 - Murphy Murphy3 - Simpson Simpson4 - Yarran Judd5 - Rowe Yarran6 - Jamison Curnow7 - Judd Waite7 - Everitt Henderson9 - Docherty Everitt10 – Thomas MenzelCurnow missing out and Thomas making tenth are the major differences . . . and I reckon our results better reflect reality.
Re: Carlton B & F Reply #95 – September 19, 2014, 04:51:14 pm ^^Rowe and Jamison speak differently.Those two have done their job each week, but the amount of ball coming into defensive fifty too easily meant that we got scored against heavily at times.I cant really think of an individual forward that monstored our defense all season aside from Buddy and Hawkins.
Re: Carlton B & F Reply #96 – September 19, 2014, 06:14:40 pm Good point Thry, and perhaps that's where the CFC B&F process better reflects how well players perform their roles.
Re: Carlton B & F Reply #98 – September 20, 2014, 10:00:29 am Quote from: Thryleon on September 19, 2014, 04:51:14 pm^^Rowe and Jamison speak differently.Those two have done their job each week, but the amount of ball coming into defensive fifty too easily meant that we got scored against heavily at times.I cant really think of an individual forward that monstored our defense all season aside from Buddy and Hawkins.Also clubs go into depth when they review defender's performances. They don't say Buddy kicked 7, Jamison was on him he played crap. They look at how each goal occurred and if Jamison was at fault or not.
Topic: Carlton B & F (Read 30531 times)
previous topic - next topic
Topic: Carlton B & F (Read 30531 times)
previous topic - next topic