Re: NAB Challenge: Carlton vs. Sydney at Etihad
Reply #183 –
Cripps - He's a monster. Ability to get the handball out under pressure is awesome.
JW - has he been playing AFL for the last five years, because it looks like he has
Boekhorst - Best game I've seen him play. Put in four quarters
Nicky G - MM was going to get rid of him. Has gone to the next level.
Kerridge - At the moment we got the better of the Menzel / Kerridge deal.
Thomas - tried hard all night. Can't kick.
Buckley - Looks great. A key player for us.
White - Remains a tried and true Northern Blue.
Rowe - he was OK in the second half but if we had anyone else...
Gorringe - no, doesn't have it.
Phillips - needs to get more of the ball around the ground but he will be 2nd ruck
Krooz - I hope and pray he is injury free
Bolt - needs to do more when he's not clunking them. His body worked dropped off as well
Wright - smart footballer, good pick up
Simo - nothing special. Did his thing.
Gibbs - did the bare minimum.
Curnow - one of the best taggers in the league.
Jamison - happy with his effort
2E - apart from a couple of errors was good
Whiley - takes too long to make decisions.
Everitt - awful
Walker - very rusty.
Lamb - tried hard, had his moments. Would play him Round 1.
Most of it was spot how I saw it but:
Lamb was awful
Gibbs was awful, Im concerned.
2E was ok carrying the footy and kicking, was terrible defending.
Rowe apart from a couple of nice spoils in the second half was terrible.
Levi looked like he was not confident at all.
BB was BOG for us.
As I said during the game, we give away too many frees and turn the ball over too much on our HB line which result in too mangy goals.
We seriously lack fwds who can kick straight.
But overall, the sprouts as BB calls them are there.