Carlton Supporters Club

Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

May 13, 2014, 03:01:25 pm

It may not have been much of a game, but it was a winning game. Do your best. You now the rules.
Vote!

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #1 – May 13, 2014, 04:54:08 pm

Team B

4 - Simpson

3 - Gibbs

2 - Murphy

2 - Yarran

2 - Menzel

1 - Docherty

1 - Rowe

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #2 – May 13, 2014, 10:37:20 pm

Team: B-

3 - Gibbs
3 - Simpson
3 - Menzel
3 - Yarran
2 - Murphy
1 - Rowe

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #3 – May 13, 2014, 11:11:19 pm

Team: C

5 - Gibbs
4 - Murphy
3 - Yarran
2 - Simpson
1 - Rowe

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #4 – May 13, 2014, 11:32:11 pm

Team C

Yarran 4
Gibbs 3
Menzel 3
Murphy 2
Simpson 2
Rowe 1

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #5 – May 13, 2014, 11:55:43 pm

Team B

3 - Simpson

2 - Gibbs

2 - Murphy

2 - Yarran

2 - Menzel

1 - Docherty

1 - Rowe

1 - Armfield

1 -  Warnock

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #6 – May 14, 2014, 09:41:08 am

Team . B

4 . Gibbs
4 . Simpson
3 . Murphy
2 . Yarran
1 . Rowe
1 . Docherty

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #7 – May 14, 2014, 11:39:11 am

Team B-

5. Gibbs
4. Yarran
3. Menzel
2. Simpson
1. Rowe

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #8 – May 14, 2014, 12:06:21 pm

5. Gibbs
4. Yarran
2. Murphy
2. Simpson
2. Menzel

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #9 – May 14, 2014, 02:03:04 pm

Team:   B-
There were some very good moments, especially in the 2nd quarter, but too may when we made almost as many errors as they did.

Votes:
[2]   Gibbs
[2]   Murphy
[2]   Simpson
[1.5]   Yarran
[1.5]   Menzel
[1]   Rowe
[1]   Jamison
[1]   McLean
[1]   Buckley
[0.5]   White
[0.5]   Warnock
[0.5]   Armfield
[0.5]   Docherty

Explanations:
[2]   Gibbs   Fantastic game and 38 possessions.
[2]   Murphy   Gave St. Kilda the complete run around.
[2]   Simpson   Brilliant when the game needed to be won.
[1.5]   Yarran   Spectacular and consistent
[1.5]   Menzel   About 3 good quarters and some lovely snaps.
[1]   Rowe   Great job in defence
[1]   Jamison   Ditto
[1]   McLean   Excellent in the middle.
[1]   Buckley   Loved the drive and run he provided from defence.
[0.5]   White   Kept his opponents very quiet.
[0.5]   Warnock   Did well in the ruck
[0.5]   Armfield   Took out a dangerous opponent who usually runs amok against us. Loved his ace and his tackling.
[0.5]   Docherty   Good effort, good interceptions and nice pace out of defence and in attack.

Honourable Mentions:
Walker   Good, solid effort
Robinson   Somewhat quiet, but had some real Robbo moment.
Casboult   Took some great grabs.

Thomas: I want to mention Thomas. Apparently Malthouse decided to use him knowing he was restricted in pace and endurance, as a decoy to take Dempster out of the game, similarly to how he has used Armfield. He did it pretty well and he did captain the forward 50 very effectively. His endeavour in smothering and chasing was excellent. He succeeded in his job: Dempster was a non-contributor. However, Thomas had only 8 possessions.
I have some questions over playing a guy like Thomas in this regard

Re: Voting for the Jim Park Medal: Rd 8: Carlton vs St. Kilda

Reply #10 – May 17, 2014, 09:50:44 am

Team - C

5 - Gibbs
4 - Yarran
3 - Simpson
2 - Menzel
1 - McLean