Carlton Supporters Club

Princes Park => Robert Heatley Stand => Topic started by: Amers on December 18, 2013, 01:13:36 pm

Title: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Amers on December 18, 2013, 01:13:36 pm
Here is another off-season game !!

Name a starting 18 team with only 1 player from each of the 18 AFL teams.

Using 2014 lists.

Have fun !!


(I haven't done mine yet, will get to it later!)
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Gozza on December 18, 2013, 01:26:59 pm
Dangerfield
Rockliff
Henderson
Swan
Stanton
Pavlich
Hawkins
Ablett
Patton
Lake
Jones
Thompson
Boak
Rance
Richards
Kennedy
Daulhaus
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: ItsOurTime on December 18, 2013, 01:40:41 pm
Patfull      Frawley      Laidler ( :P, kidding Richards)
Fyfe         Carlisle       Simpson
Cotchin    Dangerfield Griffen
Ablett      Cloke           Hurn
Wells       Roughhead Cameron
McEvoy    Selwood      Boak


That's a pretty tough exercise (oops, forgot McEvoy is no longer with the saints, will fix later) ... think  I went okay.
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Gozza on December 18, 2013, 01:43:50 pm
Sh1t I forgot a ruckman.
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: nathbear on December 18, 2013, 02:04:47 pm

B:Travis Boak (Port James Frawley (Mel) Matthew Boyd (WB)
HB: Luke Hodge (Haw) Lachie Henderson (Car) Leigh Montagna (StK)
C: Tom Rockliff (Bris) Jobe Watson (Ess) Joel Selwood (Gee)
HF: Nathan Fyfe (Fre) Lance Franklin (Syd) Patrick Dangerfield (Ade)
F: Lindsay Thomas (Nth) Jeremy Cameron (GWS) Trent Cotchin (Ric)

R: Nic Natinui (WCE) Scott Pendlebury (Coll) Gary Ablett Jnr (GC)

That was actually fun and pretty hard to do while still taking into account team balance!
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: DJC on December 18, 2013, 02:10:56 pm
Sh1t I forgot a ruckman.

That's OK Gozza, you could have Grant Thomas as coach.
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: MilkIt on December 18, 2013, 02:14:16 pm
FB:       Patful      Frawley     Enright
HB:   A. Walker    Carlisle    R. Murphy
C:          Jack        Ablett    Bra. Ebert
HF:   Dangerfield Cameron    Steven
FF:      Walters    Roughead   LeCras

Foll:    Goldstein   Cotchin   Pendlebury


I tried to base it around their preferred positions as much as possible, otherwise it'd be all mids.
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Amers on December 18, 2013, 03:35:10 pm
B: Joel Patfull (Bris) , Scott Thompson (NM), Eric McKenzie (WC)

HB: Brenden Goddard (Ess), Harry Taylor (Geel), Andrew Walker (Carl)

C: Nate Fyfe (Freo), Nathan Jones (Melb), Kieren Jack (Syd)

HF: Gary Ablett (GC), Nick Riewoldt (StK), Dustin Martin (Rich)

F: Chad Wingard (PA), Jarryd Roughead (Haw), Jeremy Cameron (GWS)

FOLL: Will Minson (WB), Scott Pendlebury (Coll), Patrick Dangerfield (Adel)


All players finished top 3 in their respective club B&F in 2013.

Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: kruddler on December 19, 2013, 06:37:23 pm
FB  Frawley    Lake       Enright
HB Goddard Henderson Deledio
C   Griffen    Ablett        Wells
HF   Boak  N. Riewoldt    Fyfe
FF   Betts    Cameron    Rockliff
R    Cox    Pendlebury  J.Kennedy

I tried picking this almost on reverse ladder order.

Pick the best players from the crap teams, and then fill the blanks with the best teams. Seems to have worked well.

Here is the order i worked with, and associated player.
GWS - Cameron
GC - Ablett
STK - Riewoldt
MELB - Frawley
WB - Griffen
NM - Wells
PA - Boak
ADE - Betts
BRIS - Rockliff
WC - Cox
FREO - Fyfe
SYD - J.Kennedy
RICH - Deledio
ESS - Goddard
CARL - Henderson
GEEL - Enright
COLL - Pendlebury
HAW - Lake
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Amers on December 19, 2013, 06:47:06 pm
I was tempted to throw Hendo into my team !
I have found the best way to pick this sort of team is to pick your ruck and KPP's 1st and then work from there. But I'm sure everyone has their own theory !
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Gozza on December 19, 2013, 07:27:15 pm
Sh1t I forgot a ruckman.

That's OK Gozza, you could have Grant Thomas as coach.

 ;D ;D ;D
 
Nearly spat beer all over the computer screen!!  ;D
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Mantis on December 19, 2013, 09:26:02 pm
FB:  Walker (Carl)      Taylor (Geel)        Frawley (Melb)
HB:  Goddard (Ess)    Birchall (Haw)       Fisher (St K)

C:    Griffen (WB)       Ablett (GC)           Cotchin (Rich)

HF:  Fyfe (Freo)         Franklin (Syd)       Dangerfield (Ade)
FF:  Wingard (Port)    Cameron (GWS)    Thomas (NM)

R:   Cox (WC)            Pendlebury (Coll)   Rockliff (Bris)              
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Mantis on December 19, 2013, 09:41:56 pm
Amers you really made this job a difficult one only selecting one player from each club. It made it difficult to find a place for Henderson (Carl), Thomas (Carl), Selwood (Geel), Mitchell (Haw), H. Shaw (GWS), Pavlich (Freo) and the list just keeps going on and on. All players that can have a big impact on a game. Maybe Thomas, Selwood, Shaw and Pavlich can keep the bench warm.  ;D

Now imagine that along with my above side.
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Gozza on December 19, 2013, 09:50:59 pm
FB:
 
Gozza Gozza Gozza
 
HB:
 
Gozza Gozza Gozza 
 
C:
Gozza Gozza Gozza  
 
HF:
 
Gozza Gozza Gozza 
 
FF:
 
Gozza Gozza Gozza 
 
R: 

Gozza Gozza Gozza 
 
All your base are belong to Gozza.
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Bennyboy on December 22, 2013, 01:31:41 pm
B:             Patfull    Thompson      H Shaw   
HB:           Hibberd   Taylor           McVeigh
C:             Jones       Ablett           Steven       
HF:          Wingard   Kennedy       Dangerfield
FF:            Walters   Roughead       Betts
   
Foll: Minson Cotchin Pendlebury
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: kruddler on December 22, 2013, 05:13:55 pm
B:             Patfull    Thompson      H Shaw   
HB:           Hibberd   Taylor           McVeigh
C:             Jones       Ablett           Steven       
HF:          Wingard   Kennedy       Dangerfield
FF:            Walters   Roughead       Betts
   
Foll: Minson Cotchin Pendlebury

I know it's tough to get your head around, but Betts is no longer a Carlton boy...so you've got 2 crows in that side and 0 carlton.
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Bennyboy on December 23, 2013, 04:51:50 am
B:             Patfull    Thompson      H Shaw   
HB:           Hibberd   Taylor           McVeigh
C:             Jones       Ablett           Steven       
HF:          Wingard   Kennedy       Dangerfield
FF:            Walters   Roughead       Betts
   
Foll: Minson Cotchin Pendlebury

I know it's tough to get your head around, but Betts is no longer a Carlton boy...so you've got 2 crows in that side and 0 carlton.

Thanks Kruddler! Henderson in for Taylor and Steve Johnson for Betts:

B:             Hanley    Thompson      H Shaw   
HB:           Goddard  Henderson       McVeigh
C:             Griffen    Ablett           Steven       
HF:          Wingard   Kennedy       Dangerfield
FF:            Howe      Roughead       Johnson

Foll: Sandilands Cotchin Pendlebury
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Navy Maven on December 23, 2013, 01:37:23 pm
B:    A.Carlise (PA)  Frawley (MEL)  HURN (WCE)

HB:  Hanley (BRI)  Henderson (CAR) Reid (COL)

C:   Griffen (WB)  Cotchin (RICH)  Steven (STK)

HF:  Dangerfield (ADE)  Franklin (SYD)  Fyfe (FRE)

F:   Ablett (GC)  Cameron (GWS)  Rioli (HAW)

Ruck: Goldstein (NTH) Watson (ESS) Selwood (GEEL)
Title: Re: Best 18 - AFL
Post by: Juddkreuzer on December 24, 2013, 12:42:50 am
B:  Thompson  Frawley   Hanley

HB: Goddard  Henderson  Griffen 

C:  Selwood   Ablett   Fyfe

HF: Dangerfield  Franklin  Steven 

F: Rioli  Cameron  Wingard

R: Natinui   Pendlebury   Cotchin