Skip to main content

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all Show Posts made by this member. Note that you can only see Show Posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Thryleon

1
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 17 2025 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Collingwood
Im not sure what people were expecting.  3 senior players are out and 6 players on total.  Some of the guys going out need to have calls made on them.  Some coming in are going to have calls made on them.  Hof, moir, carroll, cowan coming in.  You'd think last chance saloon for Evans, but im going to make a call, reckon motlop will end up the sub and he was thr other one likely to get dropped on his efforts last week.
2
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 17 2025 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Collingwood
It might be as simple as too many younger players and underdone seniors.  Cincotta played poorly last week but he wasn't the lone ranger.
Doc Gov Charlie Acres De Koning to name a few were worse than Cincotta.
8 disposals 2 tackles.  He was rubbish.

The others were too, but he's not a key player and we all know it.  The bloke he was tagging was one of their best and got it 30 times.
3
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: VFL Rd 14 2025 Carlton vs Port Melbourne
We've seen a roll out of a change in tactics, and it's fine, but it's new and we haven't seen it capably implemented yet at AFL level, we are doing it in bursts and as we go we are learning about opposition countertactics.

For a long time we bemoaned the apparent absence of a Plan B, now we have it some fans want it thrown out because we aren't getting an instant result, but it's new and fans need to be patient.

I'm not nearly as upset about the tactics and coaching as I am about the poor implementation, because where it falls down are in the execution of basic skills.

We only need one or two quick players, or one or two quality bilateral players, and time and space opens up for everybody and you'll see the basic errors diminish. This is what the likes of Daicos, Pendelbury and Sidebottom bring to the Filth.

In the past, our slower endurance and strength based list missed a massive trick, they all should have been incessantly training their offside and the lack of leg speed would be a non-issue, like it's a non-issue for Sidebottom and Pendlebury. If our list had developed 80% of Diesel's handball skills and the same percentage of Scotland's kicking they be laughing, but it's too late as 28 year olds!

The idea that someone like Saad can make it through a whole AFL career and still be effectively a unilateral ball user is a condemnation on our club and the AFL system in general. It's a fundamental high level skill that is almost completely absent in our list.
Im not seeing any plan B, just the same old rolling stoppage play, chip it around sideways, backwards then the bombed kick forward or glory pass that gets picked off. Its still that Soviet era stuff that lacks dare, run and any method of longer connection that leaves our forwards manned up and contesting vs multiple players and then when they do get the ball its a 50/50 on the accuracy for goal but thats another story.
plan A is run and gun.  Largely it was using our drive off half back and midfield.  Players like walsh, cotters, newman oh wait....
6
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Our Next Captain
Or there's a lot of hand wringing about what is quoted when potentially he's not talking about anyone in particular.

Quote
“But I feel like we’ve got the right group of people at the club to really band together and stick together.

“And we’ve got your mob this week, mate, so it’s always a big clash, big rivalry, which usually brings out the best in both sides.”

Maybe its just a subtle message for TDK.
7
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 17 2025 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Collingwood

Play the kids who will be hungry, result doesnt matter, lets find some players for 2026 and beyond.
Voss might enjoy the last 8 weeks if we give him some players who want to learn and give effort for 4 quarters, he owes Binns a game too after singling him out.

I know i'm not the only one, but i've been calling for Lemmey for weeks now for the above reason and to spare the injured players we currently have. Not many who haven't been given a crack yet, but he is one.

We have played 39 players this year.

Only players not to play....
Newman - out for year
Smith - out for year
Monaghan - irish rookie
Duffy - irish rookie
Ben Camporeale - should play this week
Lemmey - should play this week
Charleson - showed something in the VFL this week

For the record, only the bombers have used more players than us, 1 more, with 40.
1 other team has used 37
a few other teams have used 36.

Ladder position - team - players used
1st - pies 33
2nd - Lions 33
3rd - Crows 31
4th - Cats 30
...
8th - Suns 32
......
16th - Kangaroos - 33

The rest of the 8, 12th, 14th and last have used 34 players.....everyone else is more.

Shows a very distinct correlation of injuries/players used and ladder position.
Hard for us to make it near the pointy end when year on year, we have to use more players than just about everyone else.

agree.  the other part of the players used, Collingwood rotation policy isnt like ours where pendlebury doesnt play away.  We've had to bring in a player to replace am injury most weeks, and the ones that come back usually go out again.
9
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: VFL Rd 14 2025 Carlton vs Port Melbourne
That said this is the best looking group of juniors we've had for a while, at least they're competitive this year.

If that is true, it suggests that the gap between the AFL and VFL has widened considerably since David Teague coached the Northern Blues to a couple of VFL finals series.
qualifying statement for a while

Teagues vfl stint with us ended what 14 years ago?

Its been a minute.
10
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 16 2025 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
The thing with Rattens stint at st. Kilda, was that they had a bit of a regime change and then got the st. Kilda band back together again under Simon lethlean. 

His situation there was more political than based on what was going on football wise.

Post Ross they were in the wilderness and chose to go back to what had worked for them in a way that we did when we went back to David parkin.   He was unfairly collateral damage in that. 
11
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 15 2025 Post-Game Prognostications Carlton vs North Melbourne
Im just surprised a guy coming off an ankle reconstruction, and then surgery to remove hardware in his knee is somehow in tip top shape (to go with a team that is playing poor footy).

If gunston was an also ran id say fair enough but he's anything but an also ran.

Meanwhile when Charlie dines out on these types its the only reason he's won a coleman, but when he doesn't all of a sudden its a lack of want. 

Maybe I'm more forgiving than most but when you've got a bloke who's generally been good value for 70% of his career when he goes through a flat patch im not really that keen to string him out to dry.
12
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 16 2025 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
After 9 or 10 separate attempts, the “wrong bloke” ship has well and truly sailed. Are people seriously believing that if McRae was our coach we would be sitting 13-2 on the ladder?
its really hard to mount any argument to the contrary but IMHO, with fly at our club and vossy st their club, my suspicion is that things would be largely the same.
13
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 16 2025 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
For those worried about how we bring the ball into forward 50, we've been here before.  Brendan bokton was the one who was banging on about our midfield to forward connection and that culminated in the game with gws where we were being outrun with them having a man down.

I think this group can go all the way, and I think Voss can take them there, but we are going to need the sort of luck we didnt get last year.

One thing I will say, is that we do appear to be our worst enemy with regards to not giving ourselves our best chance at winning.  Somehow we have to get past this rope a dope situation where we look good for a quarter and then it all breaks down or vice versa.

Thats the challenge for Voss. The fact we look good is the major reason I'm in the lets not make any drastic moves both list and coach wise.
14
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: VFL Rd 14 2025 Carlton vs Port Melbourne
I had people over so was watching it casually in the background rather than with full intent.


Cowan straight back in for mine. Sooner the better.  He's too good for vfl level, and he's a tough competitor.  He'll get beaten a bit at afl level, but he's the type that will put his head where others won't.

Moir i reckon did enough to come in.   Very creative and way more involved with the odd stint on ball.  He can potentially do the Elijah role and probably possesses more of his skillet than others.

M. Carroll was ok.  Im not sure what it is about him i dont like but im not enamoured by him.   I think its because he's not overly physical.

Charleson was interesting.

Its hard to drop anyone on Thursdays effort.  We were so bad you could replace anyone who put their hand up and imho  a few did.



Lemmey is a straight kick, and a strong mark.  He's not a dominant player he's just a key forward.  Is he a good key forward at afl level?  He's not very mobile.  Will compliment Charlie.  I would rather him forward than young but he's a bit of a one trick pony.
15
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 16 2025 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
@cookie2

We are coach killers because we are impatient. 

I cant think of a club thats had as many coaches as we have in such a short period.  Going back to 99.

Parkin
Britain
Pagan
Ratten
Malthouse
Barker
Bolton
Teague
Voss
Hansen *1 game covering voss absence.

10 senior coaches in 25 years.  An average of 2.5 years each.  This is worse, when you consider it's been 4 years of voss, it was 4 years of Bolton and 5 years of Ratten.

Some have churned through a few, but there's a theme.  Who's another basket case for most of this century?

Melbourne.  They've had 7 senior coaches.  Who else?  Freo?  4.

Who else?  Essendon and the saints equal our record.

There's a theme there.  Crap clubs, lots of off field controversy and instability (financial penalties too) and a complete and utter failure to achieve anything since the year 2000 with st.kilda getting an asterisk for a brief period of being a bridesmaid, but more often than not, these clubs miss finals.

Maybe we just keep picking the wrong ones.  If its just the club that is the issue im guessing a lot of the young coaches in that group went on to success.

Not one did. 

We had a choice of Kingsley, McRae and Voss. We picked the biggest name in the pack despite his previous record being average at best.

Word was Pies had Voss ranked last in the process.

The rest is history
  
so you're saying the guys who are correct in sacking coaches cant hire the right one or keep choosing the wrong one?

Maybe the blokes making those decisions should get sacked instead.