Poll
Question:
Who is in our best 22?
Option 1: 1 - Jack Silvagni
votes: 8
Option 2: 2 - Paddy Dow
votes: 2
Option 3: 3 - Jesse Motlop
votes: 11
Option 4: 4 - Lochie O'Brien
votes: 1
Option 5: 5 - Adam Cerra
votes: 13
Option 6: **6 - Zac Williams** Ineligible (out for season)
votes: 0
Option 7: 7 - Matt Kennedy
votes: 10
Option 8: 8 - Lachie Fogarty
votes: 0
Option 9: 9 - Patrick Cripps
votes: 13
Option 10: 10 - Harry McKay
votes: 13
Option 11: 11 - Mitch McGovern
votes: 8
Option 12: 12 - Tom De Koning
votes: 12
Option 13: 13 - Blake Acres
votes: 11
Option 14: 14 - Oliver Hollands
votes: 11
Option 15: 15 - Sam Docherty
votes: 13
Option 16: 16 - Jack Carroll
votes: 0
Option 17: 17 - Brodie Kemp
votes: 10
Option 18: 18 - Sam Walsh
votes: 13
Option 19: 19 - Corey Durdin
votes: 3
Option 20: 20 - Lachie Plowman
votes: 0
Option 21: 21 - Jack Martin
votes: 3
Option 22: 22 - Caleb Marchbank
votes: 1
Option 23: 23 - Jacob Weitering
votes: 13
Option 24: 24 - Nick Newman
votes: 11
Option 25: 25 - Zac Fisher
votes: 6
Option 26: 26 - Lachlan Cowan
votes: 4
Option 27: 27 - Marc Pittonet
votes: 11
Option 28: 28 - David Cuningham
votes: 4
Option 29: 29 - George Hewitt
votes: 12
Option 30: 30 - Charlie Curnow
votes: 13
Option 31: 31 - Harry Lemmey
votes: 0
Option 32: 32 - Jaxon Binns
votes: 2
Option 33: 33 - Lewis Young
votes: 8
Option 34: **34 - Sam Philp** Ineligible (out for season)
votes: 0
Option 35: 35 - Ed Curnow
votes: 0
Option 36: 36 - Josh Honey
votes: 0
Option 37: 37 - Jordan Boyd
votes: 5
Option 38: 38 - Sam Durdin
votes: 0
Option 39: 41 - Dom Akuei
votes: 0
Option 40: 42 - Adam Saad
votes: 12
Option 41: 44 - Matthew Owies
votes: 11
Option 42: 45 - Alex Mirkov
votes: 0
Option 43: 46 - Matthew Cottrell
votes: 11
Option 44: New #39 - Alex Cincotta - Injury replacement player
votes: 5
Well, the last couple of these we have found a relatively stable best 22.
I wonder how this one will go. Could be a bit of licorice all-sorts.
So....choose 22 players no more, no less.
Stay away from Williams and Philp who are ineligible.
Just on Philp he lives around the corner. Seen him eith steel cap boots covered in concrete loading and unloading his Ute. Would say that's curtains for his career unless he's just taking a break.
Just on Philp he lives around the corner. Seen him eith steel cap boots covered in concrete loading and unloading his Ute. Would say that's curtains for his career unless he's just taking a break.
I don't know how/why he was signed up for 2023 personally.
No chance i would sign him for 2024.
It's a little tricky...Marchbank at his best would be in my best 22
On yesterday's efforts probably not...and to be honest I'm not sure we can trust his durability.
Those in my best 22 right now are:
3 - Jesse Motlop
5 - Adam Cerra
7 - Matt Kennedy
13 - Blake Acres
14 - Oliver Hollands
15 - Sam Docherty
18 - Sam Walsh
23 - Jacob Weitering
27 - Marc Pittonet
30 - Charlie Curnow
33 - Lewis Young
42 - Adam Saad
44 - Matthew Owies
46 - Matthew Cottrell
It's a little tricky...Marchbank at his best would be in my best 22
On yesterday's efforts probably not...and to be honest I'm not sure we can trust his durability.
I picked him, its not the first time either.
He might not be as athletic as Gov, nor as penetrating with his kick, but he is more consistent and more reliable.....and largely underrated.
Can he get back to what he was? Thats the million dollar question to which i don't have an answer.....but i'd like to think so.
I picked him, its not the first time either.
He might not be as athletic as Gov, nor as penetrating with his kick, but he is more consistent and more reliable.....and largely underrated.
Can he get back to what he was? Thats the million dollar question to which i don't have an answer.....but i'd like to think so.
I counted them up and had 23...so I looked for one to omit and it was Marchbank.
So with a sub and 23 he probably gets a game. ;) ;D
Do we have a best 22?
I picked him, its not the first time either.
He might not be as athletic as Gov, nor as penetrating with his kick, but he is more consistent and more reliable.....and largely underrated.
Can he get back to what he was? Thats the million dollar question to which i don't have an answer.....but i'd like to think so.
Marchbank needs moving on, way too slow and thats not going to work for a non KP player in the modern game..got a few kicks vs the Swans kids from the burbs team but we are already slow without adding him to what we already have.
We need a Maynard down back not a Marchbank...
I picked him, its not the first time either.
He might not be as athletic as Gov, nor as penetrating with his kick, but he is more consistent and more reliable.....and largely underrated.
Can he get back to what he was? Thats the million dollar question to which i don't have an answer.....but i'd like to think so.
Marchbank and consistent or reliable should never be used together!!!
Should have been delisted 3 years ago. Flogging a dead horse along with Williams Cunningham McGovern and mr consistency himself Martin.
All useless if we want to improve and not deserving of a cent more of our cap.
It's a little tricky...Marchbank at his best would be in my best 22
On yesterday's efforts probably not...and to be honest I'm not sure we can trust his durability.
18 touches, 9 marks in 3 qtrs. Wasn't bad, well, based on that anyway.
18 touches, 9 marks in 3 qtrs. Wasn't bad, well, based on that anyway.
He was OK, but I wouldn't be playing him next week (unless we run out of players).
Needs a few more weeks at the lower level.
He was OK, but I wouldn't be playing him next week (unless we run out of players).
Needs a few more weeks at the lower level.
He looked to have the agility of TV unit. He might do ok in Super Rules.
Not a lot of people voting in this one.
Lets try and get some significant trends going.
Not a lot of people voting in this one.
Lets try and get some significant trends going.
Trends so far...
No love for Ed Curnow
Owie's the pick of the small forwards.
Someone didn't pick Saad
Lots of love for a first yearer in Hollands
McGovern not rated highly...nor is Young..dearth of Key defenders.
Trends so far...
No love for Ed Curnow
Owie's the pick of the small forwards.
Someone didn't pick Saad
Lots of love for a first yearer in Hollands
McGovern not rated highly...nor is Young..dearth of Key defenders.
Where have i heard that before....
It was hard picking 18. let alone 22.
12 people voted so far, and not one of them has chosen current 'best 22' player in Ed Curnow.
Nobody has chosen past 'best 22' player in Lachie Plowman either.
Its highly likely at least 1 will be playing this week.....potentially 2.
12 people voted so far, and not one of them has chosen current 'best 22' player in Ed Curnow.
Nobody has chosen past 'best 22' player in Lachie Plowman either.
Its highly likely at least 1 will be playing this week.....potentially 2.
Probably because they are best 22 for the VFL team......
Players in everyone's best 22....and contracted until
(as at 13 voters)
13 votes
C Curnow-2029
Weitering-2025
Walsh-2026
Docherty-2025
McKay- 2030
Cripps-2027
Cerra -2025
Add the 12 votes
Saad 2025
Hewett 2025
De Koning 2023*
then the elevensies
Motlop 2025
Acres 2025
Hollands 2026
Newman 2023
Pittonet 2027
Owies 2024
Cottrell 2024
2025 looks like the year ( a couple to sign) ;)
Shouldn't it be 23 as it's 22 and a sub?