Poll
Question:
Who is in our best 22?
Option 1: 1 - Jack Silvagni
votes: 16
Option 2: 2 - Paddy Dow
votes: 0
Option 3: 3 - Jesse Motlop
votes: 11
Option 4: 4 - Lochie O'Brien
votes: 0
Option 5: 5 - Adam Cerra
votes: 16
Option 6: **6 - Zac Williams** Ineligible (out for season)
votes: 0
Option 7: 7 - Matt Kennedy
votes: 15
Option 8: 8 - Lachie Fogarty
votes: 9
Option 9: 9 - Patrick Cripps
votes: 16
Option 10: 10 - Harry McKay
votes: 16
Option 11: 11 - Mitch McGovern
votes: 16
Option 12: 12 - Tom De Koning
votes: 15
Option 13: 13 - Blake Acres
votes: 16
Option 14: 14 - Oliver Hollands
votes: 4
Option 15: 15 - Sam Docherty
votes: 15
Option 16: 16 - Jack Carroll
votes: 0
Option 17: 17 - Brodie Kemp
votes: 16
Option 18: 18 - Sam Walsh
votes: 16
Option 19: 19 - Corey Durdin
votes: 1
Option 20: 20 - Lachie Plowman
votes: 0
Option 21: 21 - Jack Martin
votes: 13
Option 22: 22 - Caleb Marchbank
votes: 0
Option 23: 23 - Jacob Weitering
votes: 16
Option 24: 24 - Nick Newman
votes: 16
Option 25: 25 - Zac Fisher
votes: 0
Option 26: 26 - Lachlan Cowan
votes: 0
Option 27: 27 - Marc Pittonet
votes: 6
Option 28: 28 - David Cuningham
votes: 15
Option 29: 29 - George Hewitt
votes: 14
Option 30: 30 - Charlie Curnow
votes: 16
Option 31: 31 - Harry Lemmey
votes: 0
Option 32: 32 - Jaxon Binns
votes: 0
Option 33: 33 - Lewis Young
votes: 0
Option 34: **34 - Sam Philp** Ineligible (out for season)
votes: 0
Option 35: 35 - Ed Curnow
votes: 0
Option 36: 36 - Josh Honey
votes: 0
Option 37: 37 - Jordan Boyd
votes: 5
Option 38: 38 - Sam Durdin
votes: 0
Option 39: 41 - Dom Akuei
votes: 0
Option 40: 42 - Adam Saad
votes: 16
Option 41: 44 - Matthew Owies
votes: 9
Option 42: 45 - Alex Mirkov
votes: 0
Option 43: 46 - Matthew Cottrell
votes: 12
Option 44: New #39 - Alex Cincotta - Injury replacement player
votes: 14
OK, time to do this one again.
Remember, assume all players are fit and in form (excluding Williams/Philp out for season).
Who do we pick?
Interesting results.
(We probably need a few more to get a better picture and make some before and after comparisons)
Everyone has Silvagni in the best 22, but apparently no contract offer as yet.
Paddy Dow-no takers.
Motlop beats Owies for the small forward spot 4-3, no love for- Durdin-out of sight, out of mind.
Fogarty with 4 votes is a little surprising, but folks are obviously appreciating what he brings at the moment.
McKay’s in everyone’s side-despite ‘outside’ calls to trade him out for his value.
Bit of love for McGovern who has been much maligned in the past.
De Koning wins over Pittonet-7-2, If we go with one ruck it looks like most would prefer DeKoning
Ollie Hollands-2 votes only (one mine). That surprises me, but maybe his injury has impacted on that vote.
Martin’s impact is being noticed, durability remains the issue or he probably would have got more votes.
No love at all for Young, Ed Curnow and Honey even though they’re getting games. Honey mostly because of injury.
A fully fit Marchbank would be in a few folks sides, but fully fit and Marchbank don’t seem to go together too often.
It's interesting to look back on the list at the start of the season and compare.
https://www.carltonsc.com/index.php?topic=6270.0
Players like Kemp have come on while others like Young, Fisher have slipped away.
Players like Kemp have come on while others like Young, Fisher have slipped away.
I'm very pleased Kemp has stepped up - in the first half of the year he looked like he was going through the motions, and he looked like he was out the door, but something has really clicked.
I actually think he will end up as a forward in the long run - learning the craft down back is a common way of building game knowledge for budding forwards. From the brief snippets I have witnessed, he is one of the best kicks for goal at the club and takes a good grab.
Sorry, only read down to see the "assume all players are fit" bit after selecting them. I omitted anyone I thought was injured.
Sorry, only read down to see the "assume all players are fit" bit after selecting them. I omitted anyone I thought was injured.
I've changed it briefly so you can edit your votes.
Do so and let me know when you're done and i'll change it back.
I've changed it briefly so you can edit your votes.
Do so and let me know when you're done and i'll change it back.
Thanks. Fixed.
Vote numbers have doubled since I posted above....and still no love for Young.
He had 32 out of 33 votes at the start of the year, now....zero :(
Vote numbers have doubled since I posted above....and still no love for Young.
He had 32 out of 33 votes at the start of the year, now....zero :(
Fans do not miss it when you fail to bring it!
The odd one for me is Ollie Hollands, I'd say if fit he is already a walk up start!
The odd one for me is Ollie Hollands, I'd say if fit he is already a walk up start!
I voted for him, and it surprised me too.
I put it down to the fact he hadn't been playing due to his injury.
I suspect there may be one or two who want to change their mind after last night's effort...the kid busts a gut. I reckon he'll be a two hundred gamer.
I voted for him, and it surprised me too.
I put it down to the fact he hadn't been playing due to his injury.
I suspect there may be one or two who want to change their mind after last night's effort...the kid busts a gut. I reckon he'll be a two hundred gamer.
I was tossing up between Hollands and Cottrell.....the latter got the nod.
I also, still, can't find a spot for TDK.....efforts like last night are why.
When choosing between a 5 possession game against top of the ladder - TDK
or
A 4 goal game against 2nd on the ladder - Silvagni
....i've gotta go with Silvagni.