Carlton Supporters Club

I think our newer Blues are better kicks than some of the guys who have gone, but we do retain a few guys whose kicking is their Achilles' Heel. Casboult sticks out, but he is not alone. It probably looks worse for the way we aim to move the move the ball. Our forwards don't lead much: we try to kick the ball over their heads so they fall back to take the marks. I would much rather us determine to be always in front and to kick the ball in front of them more. It works for Geelong.

It is amazing how different people see things.

I don't see Casboult's kicking as a problem at all, if he clunks enough marks inside F50 he will kick his 2 to 3 goals a game easily. I don't care too much that he kicks at 50% as long as he has enough shots.

But that bit in bold, you see I don't believe it is a forward not leading problem, in fact in recent years we have had lead up targets like Waite, Betts, Garlett and Walker all who had no trouble getting out in front of their direct opponent. Only to watch the ball sail over their head more often than not. I am not sure that kick is in anyway intentional, in fact I doubt they "try to kick the ball over their heads so they fall back" at all, but they do kick over the leading forwards head with monotonous regularity!

Ironically over the last few years blokes like Casboult, Kreuzer, Waite, Henderson, Everitt and even Warnock and Hampson have had no problem marking the ball from kicks out of our D50, but my conjecture is this is a result of different players are doing the kicking from deep in defense as opposed to our mids entering F50. Our mids are yet to demonstrate to me that they can hit the side of a moving barn let alone a moving forward!

If you want to know why opposition captain's rate us so poorly, our kicking entering F50 holds a massive clue!

Quote from: LP on March 26, 2015, 03:49:11 pm

It is amazing how different people see things.

I don't see Casboult's kicking as a problem at all, if he clunks enough marks inside F50 he will kick his 2 to 3 goals a game easily. I don't care too much that he kicks at 50% as long as he has enough shots.

But that bit in bold, you see I don't believe it is a forward not leading problem, in fact in recent years we have had lead up targets like Waite, Betts, Garlett and Walker all who had no trouble getting out in front of their direct opponent. Only to watch the ball sail over their head more often than not. I am not sure that kick is in anyway intentional, in fact I doubt they "try to kick the ball over their heads so they fall back" at all, but they do kick over the leading forwards head with monotonous regularity!

Ironically over the last few years blokes like Casboult, Kreuzer, Waite, Henderson, Everitt and even Warnock and Hampson have had no problem marking the ball from kicks out of our D50, but my conjecture is this is a result of different players are doing the kicking from deep in defense as opposed to our mids entering F50. Our mids are yet to demonstrate to me that they can hit the side of a moving barn let alone a moving forward!

If you want to know why opposition captain's rate us so poorly, our kicking entering F50 holds a massive clue!

Re the bolded part, hence my interest in the training thread about how well we have been kicking to a lead at training.

It's a skill that seems to have departed the CFC for way too long now.

When I played footy and we did a training drill whereby you kicked to a  leading forward - if you kicked it behind them you dropped and did 50.  You got over that mistake pretty fast...

When I played footy and we did a training drill whereby you kicked to a  leading forward - if you kicked it behind them you dropped and did 50.  You got over that mistake pretty fast...