http://archive.carltonsc.com/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=19274
Team E:
9: Judd
3: Henderson
1: Lucas
1: Kreuzer
1: McLean
Team F (by far the worst this year)
4: Judd
3: Lucas
3: Simpson
2: Kruezer
2:Jamieson
1: Walker
I am glad someone started this up: I have pretty much finished last round's votes and will post them shortly. This week's voting is NOT going to be pleasant.
Team D
Kreuzer 5
Judd 4
Walker 3
Lucas 2
Tuohy 1
Team: F
5 - Judd
4 - McLean
3 - Walker
2 - Lucas
1 - Kreuzer
Team: F
Apart from the first 20 minutes, we were deplorable. This was by far the worst effort we've seen for some time. Every other game we've lost we've been competitive. Not this time. We lacked desire. We lacked willingness to work for team mates. We didn't play like a team and we were softer than melted butter.
Votes:
[3] Judd
[2.5] Lucas
[2] Cachia
[1.5] Kreuzer
[1.5] Tuohy
[1.5] McLean
[1] Carrazzo
[1] Walker
[1] Simpson
Explanations:
[3] Judd: One of very few who cared enough to put his body on the line. Perhaps not his brilliant best, but our best comfortably.
[2.5] Lucas: Sugar made some shocking errors and his kicking is always questionable, but he did better than almost everyone else in our line-up and actually worked hard.
[2] Cachia: Excellent for 3 quarters in smothering his opponent.
[1.5] Kreuzer: Brilliant early and again, one of the few who tried his guts out. However, when Hudson got on top of Kreuzer in the middle, we were screwed.
[1.5] Tuohy: Kept his man very quiet.
[1.5] McLean: Brilliant early, but faded.
[1] Carrazzo: did a fine job on his opponent for most of the game and managed to get a bit of it himself. Nowehere near his best yet.
[1] Walker: OK.
[1] Simpson: Tried hard.
Honourable Mentions:
Jamison: if he had played poorly, Cloke would have kicked 10. Luckily he wasn't that bad. he just didn't win.
Henderson: Started brilliantly, but then fell into a terrible hole.
McInnes: Good job, especially considering it was his first game back.
Murphy: Considering his injury, he was a contributor.
Team = E
4 Simpson
2 Walker
1 Henderson
1 Lucas
1 Kreuzer
1 Tuohy
1 McInnes
1 McLean
1 Judd
1 Carrazzo
1 Cachia
Team E
Simpson - 5
Kreuzer - 4
Judd - 3
Lucas - 2
McInnes - 1
Anyone else want to put in their 2 cents worth?
I'm updating the spreadsheet as we speak, but I can wait.... O:-)