Carlton Supporters Club

Fair point...some players dont bother getting up for 2's footy and maybe if he was in the seniors he might go harder and better.
I like Denis but he hasnt justified a recall based on form...Dylan Buckley is probably next in the que and with his career on the line he probably deserves a couple of games to
show what he has got...

Not sure this is the best thread - apologies if it's not.

Q. I understand Gussy Sheehan has been upgraded - Rookie to seniors. (Courtesy LTI Phillips). What does this mean for wherw ASOS can play future games?

Thx in advance folks.

Denis should be tearing it up in the VFL but he's barely having an impact.  I reckon that's not down to lack of effort, the game has passed him by ... and that happens to most great servants of the club.  It may be a little harsh but, with hindsight, giving Denis another year was perhaps not the best list management decision.  It seems that the club is interested in his coaching potential but that shouldn't mean allowing him to take up a spot on the list that could have gone to someone with potential to crack the AFL side.

Like most supporters, I'd love to see Dylan emulate his old man but I don't think it's going to happen.  He is a great kick but simply doesn't get enough of the ball.  I can't see how he could possibly get a game ahead of blokes who have been playing better footy.

Alex has no problems: he is replacing Rowe. he can play as many as he is fit for and he will probably be available next week.

Denis should be tearing it up in the VFL but he's barely having an impact.  I reckon that's not down to lack of effort, the game has passed him by ... and that happens to most great servants of the club.  It may be a little harsh but, with hindsight, giving Denis another year was perhaps not the best list management decision.

I don't have a problem with his short term deal, he's clearly acting in a mentoring role for the new kids and the AFLW.

As you know he is one of our more vocal players down at VFL level, and while he may no longer have that break-away power or influence he still knows where to be and when.

I suppose this is a difference between Denis and Daisy, Daisy's AFL game never really relied on outside run and pace, so in that respect Denis has a bigger hurdle to overcome to get into the 1s.

Very interesting to see if Harry makes the final cut.
I think this will have a lot of people excited

Last time I tried to guess the final line-up for a Sunday game I got it totally wrong, so, based on that Lamb won't be coming in for Sumner and Macreadie won't be coming in for Marchbank (which is what I would anticipate...)... so, Byrne for Macreadie and Samo for Sumner