Re: blues played better footy under ratts
Reply #16 –
Dunno about u guys but this boundary footy is crap. We looked much better under ratts taking the game on. Now our brand of footy is crap
You know this amazes me. When MM was a the Filth, we marvelled at what he was able to get out of a bunch of spastics to win a flag. He managed to get a very average list to adhere to instructions and give there all. All of a sudden, the game plan is crap, he can't coach, etc etc. I put the blame square on the useless bunch of soft corks that pull the jumper on every week.
But you don't blame him for not being able to "get a very average list to adhere to instructions and give there all"
Well Roos is doing well with arguably a squad worse than ours. Difference is the players are prepared to work hard and as a unit.
Is it? Or is Roos just a better coach with more innovation and not past his use by date. None of us know.
BANG! and able to get the players "to work hard and as a unit".
Fair point, but a coach can only do so much. Say what you want about MM, the game plan the club whoever but the fact is our players aren't prepared to work. they are lazy. people often bag Rowe and white at times which is understandable but they bloody try their guts out. Obviously trying isn't a substitute for their weaknesses but why can't proven players with ability like Gibbs and Garlett work a little harder? We some how up our ante in the last 5 minutes and become a force. Why not for the whole game? Are we intimated, hurt from a little criticism or just plain soft? seems like issues we have discussed for years.
You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink it.
Any coach can coach a good/great list, and a good/great coach should be able to coach an average list to be good/great. The assumption people make is that MM is a great coach and can coach other average lists to greatness, just not this one. Yet I thought he was hired to do exactly what he did with other average lists??
I don't agree with the title of this thread we didn't play better under Ratts, nothing has changed expect we have a new more experienced super coach and still play the same inconsistent footy.