Carlton Supporters Club

Living proof that the channel 7 commentary team have zero idea.

Watson was bad, but it was his first run since Rd 1... he is a long way off the pace.

Rowe has also been a liability at times this year, but given time he has got better and better.

We lost to a Hawthorn reserves backline.....Litherland, Spangher, Cheney.....very ordinary effort IMO given Hawthorn were at its weakest for years.

Watson...ludicrous performance down back and you can forget trading him he is delist material.. So, so very true.
Armfield....gone..... looking that way
Brock....too slow and doesnt hurt teams enough Yes, but who takes his place?
Warnock ...towelled up by Ceglar who is backup to the backup ruckman.....enough of this numptie who cannot do more than tap the ball... has good trade value

Judd...still a great player..great contested efforts.... I pray he plays on
Rowe.....you win the most improved player... keep
Casboult....took marks and kicked straight...pity we had to ruck you because that stiff Warnock ran out of gas after half time... keep

Doherty...been watchng Jeff Garlett...had the handbrake on when he should have gone for the ball...didnt enjoy the physical Hawks players... this will be a focus in his off-season learning - don't fear hurt.
Gibbs...not bad

Murphy...just went - learn about ruthlessness in the upcoming off-season

Touhy..did his job on Bruest.. he must, must add more to his game

Carrazzo ...good on Lewis but one shocker turnover... sorry, but hang up the boots

Walker....wanst that impressed with him - with better blokes around him will fulfill his role. A better swing man than many realise.

Everitt ok on Smith but the latter worked his way into the game and hurt us late.... Everitt is not quite as good as we may think. However, he is good, very good but needs to be given the challenge to use his offensive abilities/hurts better.

Waite...some good, some ordinary but not too bad.. No more excuses.

Graham...a few cheap kicks but doesnt hurt teams... what do you expect, Stevens loves and recommended him

Menzel...showed some lass and would be a Wingard in a better team - agree

White..workmanlike - agree

Simpson ...brave as usual but a no impact game - agree

They gave Carrots BOG?

WTF??

I mean really, WTAF???

I don't know why I'm confused I mean Harley actually said that the Waite tackle wasn't holding the ball because he(the Hawks player) bounced it amd technically wasn't in possession..

IS THAT OR IS THAT NOT THE WORST PIECE OF COMMENTARY IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND???

They gave Carrots BOG?

WTF??

I mean really, WTAF???

I don't know why I'm confused I mean Harley actually said that the Waite tackle wasn't holding the ball because he(the Hawks player) bounced it amd technically wasn't in possession..

IS THAT OR IS THAT NOT THE WORST PIECE OF COMMENTARY IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND???

Quote from: cimm1979 on June 13, 2014, 11:39:46 pm

They gave Carrots BOG?

WTF??

I mean really, WTAF???

I don't know why I'm confused I mean Harley actually said that the Waite tackle wasn't holding the ball because he(the Hawks player) bounced it amd technically wasn't in possession..

IS THAT OR IS THAT NOT THE WORST PIECE OF COMMENTARY IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND???

I thought when you bounced the ball your were still considered in possession...I didnt know the Kevin Bartlett rule had been invoked again....

Quote from: cimm1979 on June 13, 2014, 11:39:46 pm

They gave Carrots BOG?

WTF??

I mean really, WTAF???

I don't know why I'm confused I mean Harley actually said that the Waite tackle wasn't holding the ball because he(the Hawks player) bounced it amd technically wasn't in possession..

IS THAT OR IS THAT NOT THE WORST PIECE OF COMMENTARY IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND???

I thought when you bounced the ball your were still considered in possession...I didnt know the Kevin Bartlett rule had been invoked again....