Carlton Supporters Club

Another round, another set of polls.

Have at it.

Simpson, Murphy and Henderson by a country mile. Only by a short stretch to Buckley, Bell and Daisey who did well with Waite and Yarran, but they had quiet patches for long periods the first 3 didn't have IMO.

Murphy, Yarran and Henderson for mine.

Unlucky, Everitt Buckley and a few others.

WTF someone chose White?

I went for Yarran, Murph and Buckley.

WTF someone chose White?

I went for Yarran, Murph and Buckley.

Coming from a poster who chose Buckley ahead of Simpson, Hendo and others!

Murphy, Yarran and Bell for me....

Murphy, Yazz, Simmo, Hendo and Bucks .

Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on March 27, 2014, 11:14:37 pm

WTF someone chose White?

I went for Yarran, Murph and Buckley.

Coming from a poster who chose Buckley ahead of Simpson, Hendo and others!

Buckley had it 18 times with 6 tackles. He ran with the ball and took the game on.

White had it 9 times.

People can vote for whoever they want, but White is clearly a surprise to me.

9 times, @44.4% Means he turned it over 5 times, or at least went to a short 50-50 which didn't advantage us.

Only reason i didn't vote him in the worst was because it was his first game back after a broken neck

Murphy, Buckley and Warnock for mine. Henderson, Jamison and Yarran were almost equally as good.

As Zach would enquire.."To be sure, we haven't killed off the Jim Park Medal with this voting system laddy??...Well have we?" ;)

Yarran easily for pure effectiveness.
Kicked three himself and set up another three with pin point accuracy, not his fault his mates missed sodas.
Simpson, Bell, Jamison, Murphy, Thomas, Henderson and Buckley also good, Waite and Garlett could and should have been game breakers but forwards need to convert, Warnock good on the ball but two of the worst clangers you will ever see are a big discount.
Curnow and Everitt did jobs but had little impact.
It's tough to win games when you can only name half of the team as playing well.

Curnow and Everitt did jobs but had little impact.
It's tough to win games when you can only name half of the team as playing well.

Here is where stats tell lies, many stats will list Curnow as our best. But nobody with half a football brain will claim Curnow was best or that he had a significant impact on the game.

Nthmond's Martin and Ellis statistically rank lower than Curnow, in fact Curnow was the highest ranked player on the ground in some stat systems using champion data, ahead of blokes like Murphy, Simpson, Yarran and Waite. But it is clear which players had more impact, you wouldn't list Curnow in the top ten let alone the BOG.

How can you win a game a football when virtually all but one of your midfield brigade is tagging? Our MC has lost the plot!

I suspect MM has put a bunch of safe options in positions junior to him, blokes who are way out of their depth in terms of the role they must play. Defenders in charge of forwards, stoppers coaching an attacking midfield and forwards coaching defenders. It is becoming a joke!

Buckley, Yarran, Curnow.

Quote from: blue4life on March 28, 2014, 07:40:47 am

Curnow and Everitt did jobs but had little impact.
It's tough to win games when you can only name half of the team as playing well.

Here is where stats tell lies, many stats will list Curnow as our best. But nobody with half a football brain will claim Curnow was best or that he had a significant impact on the game.

Nthmond's Martin and Ellis statistically rank lower than Curnow, in fact Curnow was the highest ranked player on the ground in some stat systems using champion data, ahead of blokes like Murphy, Simpson, Yarran and Waite. But it is clear which players had more impact, you wouldn't list Curnow in the top ten let alone the BOG.

How can you win a game a football when virtually all but one of your midfield brigade is tagging? Our MC has lost the plot!

I suspect MM has put a bunch of safe options in positions junior to him, blokes who are way out of their depth in terms of the role they must play. Defenders in charge of forwards, stoppers coaching an attacking midfield and forwards coaching defenders. It is becoming a joke!

Curnow did a pretty good job on Cotchin I thought.  He also provided some link up play around the ground.

Probably got increased grades for his match rating for it.

Yarran, Murphy and Curnow just ahead of Bell and Everitt.

Can I redo my votes??

I selected the wrong option for one of mine and would like to change it.

I also think I voted for only one player as WOG in round 1.

Can I redo my votes??

I selected the wrong option for one of mine and would like to change it.

I also think I voted for only one player as WOG in round 1.

Try it now.