Skip to main content

Messages

This section allows you to view all Messages made by this member. Note that you can only see Messages made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - DJC

6992
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Simpson and that 'beard'
Nice work Simmo!

You have to admire Simmo and a lot of the other young men who give their all in our great game, then go that extra yard for people that need a bit of a leg up!
6993
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Yarran to jog in GF Sprint
Yarran clearly tried to set himself up for the final by coasting in to fourth place in the heat.

As soon as he realised that he couldn't match Dangerfield, he backed off and probably as instructed by the fitness staff.
6994
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Yarran to run in GF Sprint
I heard Judd say that Yarran is like other athletes with elite speed in that his aerobic capacity is not great (I suspect it's better than Garlett's).  Yarran should be able to maintain his speed over the distance but the start will be critical.

While he says he will wing it, it wouldn't surprise me if he's working his butt off with the running coach (if we still have one).

6997
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Blues v Swans semi final - pre game thead
A little birdy told me Kreuzer had a screw inserted in his foot on Tuesday.

yeah, that one popped up on BF on tueday.

What we don't know is if he will be right for this week.
I didnt get it from BF for the record, did know it was on there. Doubt very much the person who told me reads or posts on BF.

Someone called SEN this arvo and said that Kreuzer had a screw inserted into his broken big toe.  Now, that could be true but it is highly unlikely, particularly at this time of the year. 

The club doesn't have a great deal of credibility when it comes to reporting on injuries but I think the bruised calf scenario is more likely than the broken toe.
6998
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Duigan's run up
I tend to agree Mantis; the closer to kicking on the run the better.

I guess the Fev slow and steady walk and kick has become the model for many players.
6999
Robert Heatley Stand / Duigan's run up
Sunday is the first time I have really noticed Nick Duigan's run up when kicking for goal.

When he walked back for his first shot I thought that he was going back a long way but that is not unusual among current day players.  When he commenced his run up I was surprised at how quickly he built up speed and he was travelling considerably faster than most players when he kicked.

I watched his other three shots at goal ( note shots at goal, not on goal  ;) ) and his method was consistent and effective.  I noticed that his run up was fluid, relatively straight ( with just a slight movement to the right ) and clearly provided good momentum for his kicking action.  The ball drop was controlled and the kick was well-timed.

At this point I should admit that I was a very average kick for goal and probably one of the last people to critique goal kicking.  However, I would be interested in others' assessment of Duigan's run up.
7000
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Kade Simpson 200 games
A great effort from one of the present day stalwarts of the club.

More than a few were baying for his blood after an average start to this season but he has adjusted to his new role with style and class.

Well done Simmo!!
7001
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: ELIMINATION FINAL : Ninth Beats Ninthmond (Ha Ha Ha Ending)
Murphy's fractured cheekbone was more serious than I thought:

Quote
Murphy and Hodge had their eyes firmly fixed on the ball at Etihad Stadium in round 12 when the heavy clash forced Murphy from the field with concussion and a fractured cheekbone. He was taken to hospital and expected to miss up to a month.

The incident could not have come at a worse time for the tough midfielder, for he had just had 31 disposals against Essendon and rediscovered his groove. This came on top of a restrictive right knee, operated on over summer, which has reduced him to one training session a week.

Surgery to repair the cheekbone meant he was unable to eat properly, living on what he said on Monday was a diet of protein shakes and mushy food.

As the surgery was in a delicate spot, he could not lift weights, for fear it would affect the alignment of his jaw.


Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/murphy-lost-3kg-after-cheek-break-20130909-2tgd2.html#ixzz2eSH9AlAv

He has done exceptionally well to get back into decent form, particularly with his limited training. 
7002
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: ELIMINATION FINAL : Ninth Beats Ninthmond (Ha Ha Ha Ending)
@DU

OK, yes I think MM would be frustrated with Mitch at times, as we all can be and I would think they have probably discussed it between the two of them. I think MM's remarks at the presser would not have come as a great surprise to Mitch and he didn't say anything new about him - my point is that Mitch is a big enough boy to cope with that, which I'm sure he does.

Agree,

I suspect he will be traded though

Why?

Is there someone better able to perform the role that Robbo does?  Is any other team interested enough in Robbo to countenance trading for him?  If so, do they have a player we want?

I suspect that the answer to all three questions is no.

Interestingly, the only other player I can think of who gave away a goal in similar circumstances was Adam Goodes.  I wonder if he thought that he would be traded
7004
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: ELIMINATION FINAL : Ninth Beats Ninthmond (Ha Ha Ha Ending)
I'd prefer to have DOA around than not.  He rarely provides us with too much insight, but the times that he does its worth its weight in gold.

I like Andrew, and love it when he is up and about and is playing well, but the game against Richmond yesterday was not one of his best.

Its fair enough for his dad to get defensive, but Walker has had a very good season, and DOA should be proud of him.   Hopefully he is able to tighten up his defensive play a bit, as I dont see why he should get worse when playing closer to the goal square, but thats another story.  I think our backline as a whole failed to keep the match ups to our advantage by allowing Jamo to run up the ground with Riewoldt.  When he goes, we should be switching opponents accordingly, so Jamo is left on Edwards (win for us) and Walker up the ground with Riewoldt can only help us especially if Walker is able to get to the ball first.

I tend to agree Thry.  However, I have a feeling that Malthouse knows full well that Walker, Simpson, Yarran, Tuohy, Armfield, Gibbs, etc are not dour defenders and will give away goals.  I think it is more a calculated risk that the run they provide out of the backline will provide more scoring opportunities for us and will tempt the opposition to use more defensive forwards.

I also think that Edwards was a particularly difficult match-up for Tuohy, McInnes and Walker, and Simon White would have been better suited to matching his strength and marking.
7005
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: ELIMINATION FINAL : Ninth Beats Ninthmond (Ha Ha Ha Ending)
One of the more interesting moments in the game was the half time walk off.  Robertson REALLY gave Bell a serve, something he richly deserved.  Bell didn't like it and rather than accepting the criticism, stupidly responded.

I suspect more was said in the rooms, but Tom needs to shut up, work on his weaknesses and play with far more awareness of what's around him rather than assuming he has the time on his side when looking for downfield options.

Good way to improve a young player is to berate them at half time coming off the field...not.

Robbo needs to get his own house in order and learn the rules...

I didn't see that at the ground but just watched it on the replay.  Judd had a few quiet words with Bell, then Robbo had a chat with him.  I'm no lip reader but the body language suggested that Bell was asking for advice rather than responding to a bake.  I'm sure Judd would have pulled Robbo up if he was berating Bell.