Re: Rd 11: Pre Game Patter: Carlton vs Brisbane
Reply #55 –
How many ruck contests do you reckon occur during any given game?
Whatever it is, halve it, as he is rucking in tandem with kreuzer.
Halve it again as the opposition will win half anyway.
Of whatever is left, what % of them are there clear hitouts to advantage? maybe 20%.
Given about 80 stoppages a game, thus ruck contests.
Kreuzer takes 40, Gorringe 40.
Opposition win half - leaving gorringe with 20.
Of that 20, 20% go to advantage.....so 4.
Now assume Gorringe only wins 10% of his hitouts, instead of 50%.
Hitouts to advantage drops from 4 to 1.
You want to drop a bloke because over the course of a game he might get you 3 hitouts to advantage less than someone else....say phillips.
What about the rest of the game played outside the ruck? He's kicking 1.5 goals a game at the moment and offering a target around the ground. I'd argue that is far more valuable than 3 hitouts to advantage we might be losing.
People think ruck = hitouts.....and forget that for 95% of the game the ruckman doesn't do any rucking!
Did I say anything about hitouts, or about dropping Gorringe for that matter? Comprehension doesn't seem to be your strength
My point is that Gorringe is too easily brushed aside by opposition ruckmen (and defenders) in contested ball situations and that's part and parcel of a ruckman's workload, regardless of how much time he spends on the ball. Gorringe is actually reasonably effective at centre bounces because he has an unencumbered leap at the ball.
My preferred position for Gorringe is as a tall utility (as discussed below) and Gorringe sees himself as a tall midfielder.
By the way, thanks for the ruck analysis. It is probably the most over-thought, meaningless nonsense I have read on this site and it gave me a very good laugh and, yes, I know small things amuse small minds