Carlton Supporters Club

How many players would want to come to CFC having watched CFC show zero loyalty to players who have shown loyalty to it including Gibbs who could've gotten a crapload more $ elsewhere last year - I mean really imagine gutting the entire playing list - just bloody stupid.

Here's a thought - get a screwing coach that can get the best out of them!

Having good leadership with little talent is probably going to land us exactly where having good talent with little leadership has.

Add gutting basically the entire club to that, along with our administration basically pushing members away and we may as well shut up shop.

We need to get some tough players throwing their weight around, and they need someone to lead the charge. Guys like Wood, Rowe, Casboult, White & Bell etc need to be enforcers, not only against the opposition but within our club. If team mates don't meet the standards set, let em know.

How many players would want to come to CFC having watched CFC show zero loyalty to players who have shown loyalty to it including Gibbs who could've gotten a crapload more $ elsewhere last year - I mean really imagine gutting the entire playing list - just bloody stupid.

Here's a thought - get a screwing coach that can get the best out of them!

How many players would want to come to CFC having watched CFC show zero loyalty to players who have shown loyalty to it including Gibbs who could've gotten a crapload more $ elsewhere last year - I mean really imagine gutting the entire playing list - just bloody stupid.

Here's a thought - get a screwing coach that can get the best out of them!

So would another coach (say hypothetically Clarkson) turn our current squad into players that are feared and respected by other teams?

So would another coach (say hypothetically Clarkson) turn our current squad into players that are feared and respected by other teams?

So would another coach (say hypothetically Clarkson) turn our current squad into players that are feared and respected by other teams?

Without a shadow of doubt GiC, without a shadow of doubt!

As much as I despise the sniper, he and his assistants have instilled a culture of toughness and ruthlessness into the playing group.  That happened before they enjoyed premiership success and is a significant contributor to their success.

Our list is capable of much more than they are currently delivering and being harder is just one area.

Remember Yarran's comments about the first pre-season under Malthouse; he was pleased that they weren't doing full blown tackling in training because someone might get hurt?

Cannot disagree with you more on this. This group (barring Judd, White, Simpson and some of the newbies I haven't seen play yet) refuses to engage in physical contact and is as soft as butter. Jesus Christ couldn't get them to be tough and ruthless don't care what anyone says. I have seen enough in the last 4-5 years to tell me this mob just doesn't cut it in the hard/ruthless stakes. Middle of the road team at best.

Cannot disagree with you more on this. This group (barring Judd, White, Simpson and some of the newbies I haven't seen play yet) refuses to engage in physical contact and is as soft as butter. Jesus Christ couldn't get them to be tough and ruthless don't care what anyone says. I have seen enough in the last 4-5 years to tell me this mob just doesn't cut it in the hard/ruthless stakes. Middle of the road team at best.

So already we're missing Robbo?

I've seen enough in the last two and a bit years to say that Mick isn't good enough and doesn't have the patience to turn this club around. You can't sack a whole team (albeit that is what Mick has attempted to do). Time to give someone with the patience and passion for turning our once great club around an opportunity and let the grumpy one retire with his millions. No doubt he will be straight back in the media crap canning our club. Have you ever thought of that?