Carlton Supporters Club

Princes Park => Robert Heatley Stand => Topic started by: crashlander on June 05, 2021, 11:03:57 am

Title: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: crashlander on June 05, 2021, 11:03:57 am
Voting is as usual: you have 15 votes to award pretty much as you will, with the following provisos:
[1] 15 votes in total, no more, no less.
[2] No more than 10 votes for any one player (even Cripps)
[3] Three players at least must get a mention.
[4] A grade for the game, A+ (what I want to see) to F-.

I always enjoy the analysis of the voting when we win ... Maybe the guys will realize that and produce the result we all want.
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: Blue Moon on June 07, 2021, 12:39:11 pm
What, no one deserves votes?

Team: F

5. Walsh
4. Weitering
3. Saad
2. Williams
1. Owies
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: ElwoodBlues1 on June 07, 2021, 04:54:20 pm

Team E:

5: Weitering
5: Jones
3: Walsh
1: Silvagni
1: TDK
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: RiverRat on June 07, 2021, 06:31:13 pm
Team C:

4: Walsh
4: Jones
3: Weitering
2: Saad
2: Setterfield
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: capcom on June 07, 2021, 06:50:32 pm
Team: F -

4. Walsh
3. Weitering
3. Betts
2. Fisher (showed some real class)
2. Saad
1. TDK

Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: rocky on June 07, 2021, 07:00:02 pm
Team E:

2 Weitering
2 Walsh
2 Saad
1 Silvagni
1 TDK
1 Fisher
1 Eddie
1 Williams
1 Owies
1 Cripps
1 Dow
1 Newman
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: LoveNavy on June 07, 2021, 08:11:13 pm
Team - not observed
Overall performance- D

3 Walsh
2 Jones
2 Weiters
2 Saad
1 TDK
1 Williams
1 Eddie
1 Dow
1 Fisher
1 SOS
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: sandsmere on June 08, 2021, 10:25:47 am
Team.D

4. Walsh
2. Cripps
2. Newman
2. Saad
1. Silvagni
1. Fisher
1. Betts
1. Jones
1. Weitering
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: percy on June 08, 2021, 07:00:53 pm
Team E

5: Walsh
3: Williams
3: Jones
2: Saad
1: Dow
1: Silvagni
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: DJC on June 08, 2021, 07:16:17 pm
Team: D

5 - Walsh
4 - Jones
3 - Weitering
2 - Cripps
1 - Williams

Saad probably deserved votes, as did Newman who was playing consistently well until injured.
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: crashlander on June 09, 2021, 02:42:10 pm
Team:   C-
For much of the game we were competitive. It was only after Eddie kicked that miracle goal that things really fell apart. But our weakness in the ruck was lethal, not to mention our poor kicking.

Votes:
[3.5]   Sam Walsh
[2.5]   Jacob Weitering
[2.5]   Liam Jones
[1]   Adam Saad
[1]   Nick Newman
[1]   Zac Williams
[1]    Patrick Cripps
[0.5]   Will Setterfield
[0.5]   Marc Murphy
[0.5]   Paddy Dow
[0.5]   Matthew Owies
[0.5]   Jack Silvagni
      
Explanations:
[3.5]   Sam Walsh:   What a player!
[2.5]   Jacob Weitering:   Great job in defence. Totally outpointed his opponents.
[2.5]   Liam Jones:   Also, a very solid job in defence.
[1]   Adam Saad:   tried hard, got a fair bit of ball and kept his man quiet.
[1]   Nick Newman:   After a chocking start, Newman really picked up.
[1]   Zac Williams:   Solid in defence
[1]    Patrick Cripps:   Not bad but didn’t have the impact we are used to seeing from him.
[0.5]   Will Setterfield:   Brilliant early but dropped out of the game totally.
[0.5]   Marc Murphy:   After a pretty good start he also drifted out of the game.
[0.5]   Paddy Dow:   Worked his way into the game and provided a few nice clearances.
[0.5]   Matthew Owies:   Like Eddie, Matt Owies did very nicely when he got the ball, but didn’t get it enough.
[0.5]   Jack Silvagni:   Started very well and always put in.

Honourable Mentions:
Tom de Koning:   Had he kicked that goal from 20 m out, then he would have had 3 and deserved a vote. His ruckwork was not up to his normal standard, but he was a long way from our worst.
Jack Newnes: 14 possessions in 2.5 quarters was solid.
Eddie Betts:   Eddie didn’t get enough of the ball, but when it got it, something happened. A few more possessions and he would definitely be vote-worthy.
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: madbluboy on June 11, 2021, 01:44:23 pm
F

5 Walsh
4 Weitering
3 Jones
3 Saad
Title: Re: Jim Park Voting: AFL 2021 Rd 12: Carlton vs West Coast
Post by: LP on June 11, 2021, 02:11:53 pm
Team D

5 Walsh
4 Weitering
3 Cripps
2 Jones
1 Williams

Walsh is an enigma, not sure he deserved 5 for his skills or effectiveness, but for effort and application he deserved 15. No matter what goes right or wrong, he just rolls on to the next contest with the same high level of intensity.

For me much the same applies to Weitering, might have b0rked up a few disposals, but shizen we're forked if these guys don't stick around long term!

Not wanting to disrespect Doc or Cripps, but in Weitering and Walsh I'm seeing Captain and Vice Captain with at best a coin toss between them!