Skip to main content

Messages

This section allows you to view all Messages made by this member. Note that you can only see Messages made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Gointocarlton

31
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Pick our team in parts - Part 1 - Starting Midfielders (inc 1 ruck) - CHOOSE 6
I couldn’t fit Lord into my midfield but he’s a lock for my interchange bench.

Cooper provides a point of difference to our other midfielders with his ability to negate opposition guns and willingness to do the real grunt work.
Agree. Also hard to fit Cripps Hewett and Cerra into the same side from a pace perspective. I have Cerra on the bench and potentially being squeezed out all together.
32
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: List Building - More than one way to skin a cat
He's not the Director of Coaching. He works for Voss (his words not mine) as another set of eyes for the coaches providing feedback.
33
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: List Building - More than one way to skin a cat


We lost an athletic ruckman with potential, a dual Coleman Medalist who was playing like he didn’t give a toss and an injury-prone, slow defender with all of 12 games as a KPD under his belt.  Only Tom was part of our late season return to form.  We’ve more than covered their loss with blokes who want to play for the club and give us greater depth, versatility and goal scoring ability.

We’ve brought in experienced assistants with new ideas, a director of coaching to wrangle the assistants, and Travis Boak to take a dedicated leadership and culture role.  Voss has more support than ever and a better list than he had last season.
I'll disagree on the list coverage for those departed players, the players we have brought in are either throws at the stumps or handy B graders but I dont see any real dial movers that will be keeping other clubs up late with worry.
Director of coaching....not a fan of the position or the incumbent for reasons I have discussed previously and the Assistants cant really be judged until seasons end and we can see what went right or wrong during the season in their areas of responsibility.
Boak hopefully can improve our leadership and find some new leaders for the future....
I also dont see many of the top teams falling away apart from Collingwood, and expect the competition to be even tougher next season making it even harder to make the top 8.
Whos the director of coaching? We dont have one.
34
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: List Building - More than one way to skin a cat
Not sure if you've read these very forums, but i can understand where the pressure is coming from because many around here think we've improved our list in the off-season.

If those same people make enough noise when things go bad, then it gets really bad really quickly.

My issue is not opinions on here. My issue is a certain cadre of individuals in the media who talk sh1t. The default position for any Carlton coach is the rotisserie, even if we recruit a bunch of U10's from around the corner. One hopes the club can adjust expectations accordingly, either up or down, in way that fairly represents our position, not this "no excuses" crap.

Well they proved this year there is change as they didnt listen to the media DHs and sack the coach before his term was up. Having said that, IF we have another poor year and IF they decide not to go fwd with the coach following a thorough review, that's a different story to me. I dont reckon Wright and Co. will be swayed by media, supporters, ex players or current players who aren't prepared to work hard,
35
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: List Building - More than one way to skin a cat
Many seem to be hung up on the height (or lack there of) of our fwd line.
Brisbane Premiership Fwd Line
Charlie Cameron   180cm   Ty Gallop   194cm   Callum Ah Chee 182cm   average height = 186.5cm
Cameron Rayner   187cm   Logan Morris   191cm   Kai Lohmann   185cm      

2026 Potential Fwd Line                     
Hayward   186cm   McKay 204cm   Moir 188cm   average height =190.2cm
Evans 182cm   O'Keeffe   202cm Ainsworth   179cm
Then there is:
Jesse Motlop   180cm               
Talor Byrne 174cm               
Zac Williams 183cm               
Brodie Kemp 192cm      

I see no issue, just saying.         
36
The Sports Desk / Re: Formula 1
On the politics and broadcasting of F1, you have to be very careful what you believe.

Sky are doing a Caro at the moment following reports that Horner could rejoin Newey, this time at Astin Martin. It wasn;t that long ago Sky claimed Newey was so appauled by Horner that they couldn't be in the same room together, blaming Horner for Newey's departure form RBR. Now with Horner tipped to get the prime Aston Martin CEO job, apparently they are all luvy again with the miracle cure claimed to be a shared Oasis concert.

Sky are full of sh1t, they see Horner and Newey as the "dynamic save UK F1 duo", so it has flipped from hangman to talent agent.
Couldnt give a flying toss about Horner or AM. Its pretty obvious all the Sky Mafia are trying to divert attention from McLaren and their appalling treatment of Piastri.
38
The Sports Desk / Re: Formula 1
Perhaps also the political influence of Red Bull, it brings Max back into the game.

There seems to be a lot of people at the top end of F1 very unhappy with the McLaren situation, and perhaps a few who are a bit unhappy with Zak Brown, ultimately F1 is a sport and many people want it to at least retain some semblance of being a competition fair or otherwise. Brown comes across as pure on the Sky broadcast but you have to keep in mind the Sky broadcast is as biased as any broadcasting crew you will ever find, the sophistry knows no limit.

As much as I want Oscar to do well, the situation at McLaren is so distasteful I'll probably end up barracking for Max as to me if he gets across the line at least he has deserved it. When you watch the season considering what happened to Lawson and Tsunoda, it's obvious how far ahead his compatriots Max really is. I really hope Norris' title hopes collapse in the final race.
I have never liked Max the person, however as a driver his talent is unmatched at present. Oscar has crapped the bed or had his bed crapped in by McLaren, either way he is no chance. I just can't stand Norris wining it the way he has but it seems inevitable, however if anyone can pull it off, Red Bull and Max can.
40
The Sports Desk / Re: Formula 1
Both McLarens disqualified from Las Vegas GP, Max and Oscar no on 366, Norris on 390 24 points in front.
Oscar is Gonski IMO, is Norris, or Max, Go Max.
Game on.
41
The Sports Desk / Vale Allan Moffat
Allan Moffat, a giant of Australian motorsport for many decades has left this world. A ferocious competitor but a gentlemen at the same time. The battles with Brocky were legendary.
RIP AM