Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all Show Posts made by this member. Note that you can only see Show Posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - LP

1
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
It's interesting to read the national rags, it appears reporting outside of Victoria indicates PHON has changed tactics and is now targeting a balance of power outcome.

To me that's the "Sh1t the bed, did I really want this job" realisation.

The balance of power thing is the "All care and no responsibility" approach, it won't be PHON's fault if it all turns toes up, but I can hang around and make myself a very public pest!
3
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

They got in because the Libs didn't do anything much at all - they were largely inert but didn't stuff the state up.
Hubris got Kennett.

But did nothing wrong is a bit of a stretch. I'd assert many of the very public social behaviour and crime problems we now have in Victoria now are directly linked to Kennett closing so many of the public mental health facilities, forcing the most vulnerable and severe mental health patients into the public hospital system that just is not equipped to deal with them. The high acuity patients consume a huge chunk of the available public resource leaving the vast majority of the remainder of patients under resourced. Kennett liked and still likes to blame the patient, he'll claim that governments have had plenty of time to deal with it, doesn't he mean "reverse his errors"? Fixing his feck ups won't help you when a drug affected bipolar mental health patient stabs you on a city street, they'll still be unwell and you might well be irretrievably dead. There is an asymmetry in the cause and effect and Kennett was the trigger man!
4
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions

Why would you assume I was ignorant of the changing climate & local habitats ?
My comment was a generalisation about the assumptions the public make, people are very very bad at the relative understanding of many things, geologic or universe time frames, planetary or stellar mass, the speed of light, distances or dimensions beyond a few hundred metres or below a millimetre.

When discussing migration patterns, the discussion often proceeds like it's a journey, but it is normally discussing a journey that would typically take many generations. Same applies to talk about migration under climate change.

The other day I listened to an official BBC podcast about the Hubble space telescope that reported 50µm was 1/50th the width of a human hair, it was reporting this while describing the errors "engineers" made in calculating critical units! The correct figure would be 5µm is about 1/50th of the width of an average human hair.
5
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Putting aside my evidence-based archaeological method, I'd like to think that it was curiosity and a sense of adventure, or perhaps even a dash of wanderlust, that motivated those ancient folk to head off into the unknown.
The old sins, greed, gluttony, desire all wrapped in hubris, the tale had to have deep social origins somewhere!

The apples are sweeter over the hill, and there is no more basic craving than to want something somebody else has already got!
9
The Sports Desk / Re: God help me - the Cricket thread
Managing the pill is a big part of cricket, and being able to swing or seam the pill is a big part of cricket.

I'd assert the majority of the cheats aren't people who can and do swing or seam the pill, it's likely the duds who bowl a million miles an hour and barely get it off straight!

As for bowling fast, it's not the thing that determines effectiveness. Terry Aldermann, Max Walker and Gary Gilmore weren't express, Aldermann wasn't particularly quick at all, and they often had batsmen in knots. In his later years, Lillee had lost 10 - 15kph, but was a better bowler because he could do it all. McGrath was a good 15 - 20 kph slower than Starc, and a better bowler in my opinion.

The spuds you hear commenting about conditions not suiting bowlers, most likely batsmen, they have NFI! Blokes like Aldermann and Hadlee could move the ball in any conditions on any surface.
10
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
However, FoI is not a Royal Commission and the diarist can be compelled to explain their diary entries.
And they can explain the contents however they like, you just can't infer meaning outside of a direct interpretation by the author!

In the R&D sector, be it somewhere like CSIRO or commercial, it's very common for researchers to use their own task specific shorthand that is designed to avoid reproduction if the diary is lost or stolen. It's considered a safeguard, and they do it for both communications and math. Equations can look completely wrong or unintelligible.

I tried this myself once, but I could never remember what I was going to write.

PS; I have a mate who is a globally renowned engineer, he has dyslexia and documents everything in minute detail. You can't read a line of it because he's invented his own written language.

I suffer from something I've labelled Scribolepsy, give me a pen and paper and it's like sedative!
11
The Sports Desk / Re: God help me - the Cricket thread
Before HD Video, pretty much every bowler would be running their thumbnail around the seam on the way back the mark, every bowler at every level from every country. I'm sure it was always illegal, any attempt to tamper with the seam of the cricket ball is, but doing so was ubiquitous.

The thought back in the old days was that opening the seams increased both swing and seam, but actually it's since be proven to be bogus with results unable to be reproduced.

Now if it happens, it's more about damaging a dud pill to get it replaced with a new one, and there is one specific country that does this far far more than any other!
13
The Sports Desk / Re: God help me - the Cricket thread
In some ways the truth has already surfaced, there isn't a debate about whether there was or wasn't an issue, that is both settled and admitted.

Now it's more you too, but I'd assert it's pretty much everybody and the allegations are wrongly focussed, people in glass houses should beware!

Rescuers often drown while trying to save the drowning.
14
The Sports Desk / Re: God help me - the Cricket thread
Just an aside a bit of an anecdote.

I had heard about sweets being used before, but as a young cricketer I first overheard about a very particular brand / type of sweet used to varnish the pill from Tony Grieg. We were in the practise nets at VFL park where I had been acting as a net bowler for the WSC players. It wasn't because they were using or discussing the use of the sweets in WSC, but because he was explaining to someone how they did not work for the coating on the white cricket balls of that era.
15
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
I gather the redacted evidence probably means legal contracts, it's likely all sides of this case will do the same when commecial confidentiality and non-disclosure applies, but only the government side will be labeled a cover up.

I believe the commission can go into camera and have those issues address, but then the same critics would claim a cover up by the commission.

In many cases it's not just an arbitrary decision to redact but a legal requirement, but the media never report it that way.