Skip to main content

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all Show Posts made by this member. Note that you can only see Show Posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - kruddler

1
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
Source: ESPN AU

                                                Under Voss                         Under Fraser

Uncontested Marks:                    13th                                         1st
Long kicks %:                                9th                                        18th
45 degree kicks:                           15th                                        3rd
D50 to i50%:                                13th                                        2nd
Kick i50 Retention %                     6th                                         2nd

Even im surprised with how quickly the old gameplan was changed and match day implemented with the same list.

Assuming this data is correct.....
Can anyone explain the following.....
Carlton 2026 Season Mark Profile: Round-by-Round

RoundOpponentTotal MarksContestedUncontestedMarks inside 50Uncontested %
Opening RoundSwans69861588.4%
Round 1Tigers751065786.7%
Round 2BYE0
Round 3Demons9211811288.0%
Round 4Kangas1148106793.0%
Round 5Crows50743686.0%
Round 6Magpies10111901389.1%
Round 7Dockers8510751288.2%
Round 8Saints11871111594.1%
Round 9Lions9516792083.2%
Round 10Dogs1248116593.5%
Round 11Power10811971889.8%
TOTAL103110792412089.6%
Does that show any significant difference in the way we play?

Thats the only data i can find, the other stats are not available to the public.
2
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Publish the link, I hope it wasn't the article that ranks career stats versus the last 2 games, aka the MAGA of all stats!

btw., Did you read the stats for the last 6 games, or are all stats bogus? :D

As @Thryleon had already linked for the various overnight miracle believers https://x.com/i/status/2059208469161590794

We did it for 4 qtrs the last 2 weeks. Before then, for half a game we were probably last for those measures each week. Fact is we were 1-8, now we are 3-8. That's the one measure that matters and executing those statistical measures much better.

....and if we played Dogs and Port every game we'd be 11-0.
3
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
Source: ESPN AU

                                                Under Voss                         Under Fraser

Uncontested Marks:                    13th                                         1st
Long kicks %:                                9th                                        18th
45 degree kicks:                           15th                                        3rd
D50 to i50%:                                13th                                        2nd
Kick i50 Retention %                     6th                                         2nd

Even im surprised with how quickly the old gameplan was changed and match day implemented with the same list.

Now do one that includes the last 3 games from Voss and compare that to Fraser.
Will be just about identical.....as the previous posts pointed out, that you failed to acknowledge.
4
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
It's pretty despicable by the media to cause trouble by framing a negative narrative around Voss, then once he's gone they pivot and give him considerable credit. Shameful.
I'm expecting the opposite with Hird.
Media pumping up his tyres, largely, then when he gets in the media will turn and say how could essendon bring him back after the heartache he caused......and never admitted fault for mind you!
5
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide


I said similar in that i didnt think anything had changed between our Lions game and dogs game.
Now Jagga backed that up in the post match interview
And
Stats back that up too.

Any people who wanted vossy sacked care to weigh in on these revelations?
Wright wanted him gone, senior players wouldn't play for him....ditto Scott at Essendon ....

Which senior players? The ones that left? The ones that were dropped? The ones he brought back into the 1's?
The ones who almost won us the game against the lions?

They played pretty well for him while he was there at the end, just couldn't get over the line.
6
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
https://x.com/1116sen/status/2059208469161590794?s=20

Over the last 6 weeks, No 1 ball movement team in the competition. No 1 scoring team out of their D50, 3rd most uncontested marks, use the 45 degree kick 3rd most in the competition.

I said similar in that i didnt think anything had changed between our Lions game and dogs game.
Now Jagga backed that up in the post match interview
And
Stats back that up too.

Any people who wanted vossy sacked care to weigh in on these revelations?
7
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: VFL Rd 9 2026 Carlton vs Coburg at Coburg
The commentators were saying that Cody Walker was now on our VFL list and would now be playing in most games.  Is that correct?

He's played....3-4 games now i think.

There was also talk a couple weeks ago that said they will let him go back and play some school and/or U18's games so he can play with some mates, as it'll likely be the last time he gets to do that again.
8
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: VFL Rd 9 2026 Carlton vs Coburg at Coburg
We had Moir, but that was about it. When we don't dominate in the middle, our structural issues become more apparent. And Moir has to up his workrate. God knows he can make a difference when he gets the ball. But he doesn't get the ball enough. Simple as that. We had Warburton at CHF, which shows how devoid of options we were.

Moir will be put on the trade table at seasons end.

He has the ability but not the grey matter and clearly doesn't want to work hard enough.

You don't trade Moir types.
You won't get much for him, but if he puts it all together, he can make you look silly for a decade afterwards.

Best we keep him. He'll kick you a goal a game relatively easily, which should not be overlooked, even if his potential is to get you 2 goals a game.
9
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
What has changed since Voss had the reins?

1.  Playing Harry as second ruck/forward.  Coincidentally his best two games this year have been the last two.
2. More on ball time for Smith.
3.  Clear directive to hold the ball until better options emerge. Less hack kicks forward.
4. Selection of kids over veterans. No Saad, Acres, Young. Big roles given to kids like Dean. Clearly some have had their cards marked.
5. Selection of Ison who looks like a very accomplished player.
6. Selection of kids like Billy who kick hard, flat and through the corridor.
7. Timely return to form of senior players and Hewitt back in seniors.
8. Playing struggling sides who we really should be beating regardless of who is coaching.

1. This has occured previously under Voss.  Voss actually started it with making Harry 2nd ruck against the Lions. Harrys 2nd half against the Lions started this return to form. He was BOG against the Lions by fantasy points.
2. Smith has been given more on ball time recently, but also got plenty at the start of the year. I expect him to be in and out simply to manage his minutes and not break him. Can't expect essentially a 1st year player to play a full year on the ball.
3. Hard to quantify. Didn't see much difference between Lions and Dogs efforts
4. Young was dropped by Voss. Acres hasn't been picked all year. Saad has barely played all year.
5. Definitely got his first go under Fraser. Was borderline being picked in the few weeks leading up to it.
6. Vossy picked Wilson against the Lions.
7. Vossy brought Hewett back against the Lions.
8. Almost beat the lions. Played the same way since and have been beating poorer sides as a result.


I've got no issue with what Freser is doing, but he is getting a lot of credit for doing things which were actually done by Vossy first.
Week 1 vs Dogs - 1 forced change
In: Ison
Out: Saad (inj)
Week 2 vs Port - 2.5 forced changes
In: Derkson, Young, Byrne
Out: Weitering (inj), O. Hollands (inj) Williams (managed)

As with what Jagga said after the game, not a whole lot has changed under Fraser. The boys played well against the Lions and have continued playing that way.

I dont think there has been any drastic changes thats occured in the last couple weeks.
10
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide


I'm sure the anti Voss brigade will think it's a load of s h i t.

One of Vossy's first innovations was to give our key forwards licence to help out in the backline whenever they felt it was necessary.  McGovern does just that last night and it's a genius move by Fraser  ::)

The best thing i like about Fraser 'genius move' is how he managed to get Charlie doing it over the last 2 years. Now THAT is genius.

Fraser was coaching the last couple of years yeah?

 ::)  ::)  ::)
11
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Anyhow the one thing beyond dispute is the changes in game plan use of ball going into 50, lowering the eyes, lower kicks kicking to advantage and keeping control of the ball out of defensive 50. the predictable long kicks to the wings are not anywhere near as common as they were.



Agreed

Game plan or ball use?

I commented very early on in the game that we'd sold our soul midweek for the ability to kick. In the first half it was accurately at goal and accurately to the leading forward.

At one stage i think we were going 15% KE ABOVE the norm. Elite of the elite levels. Thats not game plan.

Clearly in the 2nd half all that went out the window. So does that mean the game plan failed in the 2nd half.

Personally i think we just got a bit 'lucky' early on with our kicking and came back to the pack like normal from there.
12
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 11 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Port Adelaide
Commentating - honestly, does the league nor TV stations not care one iota about professionalism? The amount of talent chomping at the bit to be footy commentators and we are left with a parochial Adelaidean and the recent ex coach of our opposition. I heard more about Butters being half back than I did about the entirety of our team and performance.

This is not just bias, it is unprofessional.  Sick
Of these old guys commentating games when there is young talent wanting to do it but get no look in.

The best commentators around today, and yesteryear, and even going bac to the black and white days.....were from NON-footballing commentators.
Yet, currently, there is the least amount of non-football commentators as ever, despite having more commentators than ever.

For mine, Huddo, Howie, Whately and even Brayshaw are among the best current commentators.
Previously, Bruce and Commetti were unparalleled.

Why do we go away from that?