Skip to main content

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all Show Posts made by this member. Note that you can only see Show Posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - tonyo

2
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2025 Pre Game Carlton v Adelaide in Adelaide
Rankine plays more midfield and Saad wont play there. Keays dines out on us, pencil him in for 4 goals now irrespective of who plays on him. Thilthorpe is there best and biggest fwd hence Weiters. They were saying on Fox Gov seems to do better agains the taller quicker more mobile fwds, dont know whether you'd call Fogarty to Walker quick and mobile.
I 100% trust Haynes (now) to do a defensive job on either. Young is too flaky to play on Thilthorpe IMO.

Thilthorpe has a hand injury which might negate his marking and help a player like Young who has the height to match him.
First marking contest, the spoiler should be aiming directly for that finger.....
3
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2025 Pre Game Carlton v Adelaide in Adelaide
Just as we match up well on Geelong, Crows match us well - remember Marvel last year?

They have Hinge out courtesy MRO and possibly Tilthorpe with a finger fracture.

If Silvagni lines up on Tilthorpe, it might be a case of who punches who's hand first in the marking contest.

If we snag this, belief will be sky-high.....
4
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Election 2025 (Poll added)
Been getting some very unsavoury material in my letterbox & and it isn't from any party.  Looks like some branch of some right wing fascists....and they clearly don't like Albanese.  Lot of disinformation and BS flying around - more so than usual.
There's a mob called Advance Australia, a rich boys' lobby group, who specialise in spreading disinformation in support of a very conservative agenda.

There was an article about them in the Good Weekend Age last week.  Worth reading. 

We are getting more like the States, where people learn most of their political information from 20 second ads on TV and social media memes.  Both sides are doing it. 
6
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 6 2025 Post game Prognostications Carlton vs North Melbourne
Unfortunately for Matt (and I was really sorry to see him go), he wanted to play midfield, but he was a slightly-less-good clone of Cerra, Hewett and Cripps, and had no x-factor like Elijah.  If you have a midfield that collectively moves as fast as treacle, you may win the contest, but you get chopped up when the ball is on the move.

Jagga Smith was going to change that mix (ffs!), we'll have to wait until 2026 to see how it works.  Meantime, they have thrown Motlop in for the odd centre bounce, and the initial results appear promising.

You can't keep them all.......
7
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 7 2025 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Geelong at the MCG
Do not underestimate the power of belief, which brings confidence, which brings improved performance.

I remember all too well sitting at the 'G in Round 14, 2023,  We were 13th on the ladder with 4 wins, and playing the Suns.  At quarter time, we were 10 points behind and looking as sick as ever.

Then, someone somewhere flicked a switch.  We kicked 9 in the second quarter and had a nice 'flat-track' win. 

Then we pumped the Hawks, which was also a flat-track win in 2023, having kicked the first 8 goals of the game..

We all know what happened from there, with an ounce of luck we could have pinched the flag.

The last two weeks were against lowly opposition, but the manner of the wins was the more important feature.  Foot on the throat, and kept it there.

It is a big game next week, but I have always felt we match up pretty well with the Cats.

I remain highly optimistic about 2025.

8
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 6 2025 Post game Prognostications Carlton vs North Melbourne
Top win, nice to see us put the foot on the throat when we had the chance.

When North kicked the first couple of the last quarter, I thought we were going to coast to a 30-point win in typical style.  

Apparently not.  

That is what ruthless teams do.

I really like Will White.  Works super hard and is no slouch in the one-on-ones.
12
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 4 2025 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Collingwood at MCG
I don't understand why Collingwood dropped Cox. He isn't a great player, but he is a much better 2nd ruck than any alternative.
Nichevo. Let them make a mistake for a change.

Quote of Napoleon: 'Never interrupt an enemy when he'd making a mistake'.
I believe he was seen doing fitness tests earlier in the week, so maybe he is carrying an injury.
Rain predicted tonight.  Cox is about as useful as a light pole in the wet, and they have plenty of size in the front half with McStay, Membrey and Mihochek.  McStay will 2nd ruck.
13
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Things Fall Apart.
I remain upbeat about this season - we have played crap footy so far, should have won 2 of the 3, and even against the Hawks we were stiffed.

Sometimes you learn more from your crap efforts than you do from your good ones.  There is a lot of good footy left in this team.

Just waiting for the rudder to steer us into calmer waters.....
14
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 3 2025 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Western Bulldogs

Moir, Two Camporeales, Billy WIlson, try Lemmey at HF.  Give White a shot in the F50, can't do any worse .....

Can't do any worse? We've been in all 3 games thus far this season.

Worse was Pagan era when we'd be 6 goals down halfway through the first quarter. And 100 by the end.

Certainly can do worse.....a lot worse.
Lost against two sides we should have beaten in a canter and our second halves suggest we are not fit.  Time to mix things up.