Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all Show Posts made by this member. Note that you can only see Show Posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - DJC

1
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
We share our place with a horse and I’ll be doing my best not to see that footage.

According to a news report I heard today, the recommended method for disposing of a euthanised horse carcass is burial in a landfill tip.  This is because of the volume and toxicity of the drugs administered.  I don’t know how accurate that is but, if it is correct, the fault is in not ensuring that the carcass was buried quickly and completely.

Either way, it’s not good enough.

2
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Why did the 'islanders' travel by boat to explore back in the day? Curiosity.
Why is it different on land?

Polynesian colonisation of the Pacific is a fascinating piece of human history and achievement.

It used to be thought that intrepid Polynesian explorers set out on suicide missions to find new lands or perish.  It's now apparent that they had the knowledge and means to return home while they still could.  Archaeological evidence reveals the Polynesians visited Australia and established short-lived colonies on Norfolk and Pitcairn Islands before the first European navigators.

It's a fictional account of course, but James A Michener's Hawaii presents a well-researched and historically and archaeologically sound account of the colonisation of Hawaii by Polynesians from the Marquesas who crossed 4,000km of open ocean.

The famous cultural anthropologist, Margaret Mead, documented extreme responses to embarassment among Samoans; farting during a meeting could result in suicide (by sitting on a palm spike!) or a voyage of discovery.  How many islands were discovered as a result of a fart?
3
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Putting aside my evidence-based archaeological method, I'd like to think that it was curiosity and a sense of adventure, or perhaps even a dash of wanderlust, that motivated those ancient folk to head off into the unknown.
The old sins, greed, gluttony, desire all wrapped in hubris, the tale had to have deep social origins somewhere!

The apples are sweeter over the hill, and there is no more basic craving than to want something somebody else has already got!

There are incredibly strong motivations for staying put, as we know from families that have lived in the same village for generations.

In a hunter-gatherer society with a seasonal round of dwelling places rather than permanent homes, intimate knowledge of the home environment; resource locations, where the predators hang out, places to shelter, refuges when times are tough; would have been a powerful reason to stay put.  Then there's friendly neighbours to trade with and inter-marry, and not so friendly neighbours that are to be avoided, as well as places associated with creation stories, totemic sites, etc

Leaving home would generally require compelling reasons and I think that curiosity could be one such reason for some folk.
4
Ladies Lounge / Re: AFLW 2026 Semi Final Carlton vs Hawthorn at Ikon
One incident that stood out was when the ball was kicked to Poppy despite her having two opponents.  She managed to gather the ball on the bounce but turned back into her opponents.  She may have been able to break one tackle, but not two.

Ideally, that kick should have gone to another option or we should have had a crumber at the contest.

Hawthorn's ball use, decision-making, and ability to create uncontested marking opportunities for their forwards worked a lot better than "kick it to Poppy and hope she gets it".
5
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions


The mass migration of humans out of Africa circa 70,000 years ago is usually attributed to a combination of climate and environmental changes, cognitive and technological advances, following food sources like migrating herds, the discovery of coastal and marine resources, and population pressure.

It's interesting to ponder what motivated those earlier human forays out of Africa if the above factors weren't in play; strife, necessity, opportunity or curiosity?

All those things and also something much simpler… the carrying capacity of the land.

That would be a factor with the migration that took place 70,000 years ago, but the earlier excursions happened during favourable environmental conditions and when the human population was considerably fewer.  Putting aside my evidence-based archaeological method, I'd like to think that it was curiosity and a sense of adventure, or perhaps even a dash of wanderlust, that motivated those ancient folk to head off into the unknown.

Then there's the earlier departures from Africa by Homo erectus, Homo floresiensis, Denisovans and Neanderthals, with only the latter two having the cognitive and technological prowess to rival modern humans.

This is where a Tardis would be handy  :)    
6
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions

The mass migration of humans out of Africa circa 70,000 years ago is usually attributed to a combination of climate and environmental changes, cognitive and technological advances, following food sources like migrating herds, the discovery of coastal and marine resources, and population pressure.

It's interesting to ponder what motivated those earlier human forays out of Africa if the above factors weren't in play; strife, necessity, opportunity or curiosity?
7
Ladies Lounge / Re: AFLW 2026 Semi Final Carlton vs Hawthorn at Ikon
That really was an entertaining game but I would have preferred fewer lead changes once we hit the front 🙂

Hawthorn certainly played well early and were able to disrupt our game with their pressure … and some suspect umpiring decisions.  That we were able to come back and take control of the game is a real credit to the girls and Bucky.

Darcy was magnificent in her 100th game; one of the best of her illustrious career 👏

I think that Tara Bohanna’s inclusion was important and meant that our forward line retained its potency when Poppy Scholz went behind the ball.

Poppy looked proppy at the end of the game.  Hopefully it’s just a corky.
9
Ladies Lounge / Re: AFLW 2026 Semi Final Carlton vs Hawthorn at Ikon
Congratulations to Darcy Vescio for reaching 100 games, the first Blue to do so.
Congratulations to Harriet Cordner, who reaches 50 games in Navy Blue.

Yes, congratulations to both on their milestone games - hasn't Harriet Cordner been a great recruit!

That looks to be a very strong lineup ... on paper!

I think that a lot will depend on Tara Bohanna.  If she is back to near her best, it should make life a lot easier for Poppy Scholz.

Go Blues!
10
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
I’m not sure what the public servant was thinking, but apparently even the unredacted version of his diary doesn’t make a lot of sense.
The problem with a diary is that there are no demand on syntax or language, it can be as cryptic, vague or specific as the notetaker likes but it doesn't need to be consistent.

Yes, when I was a public servant we were told that our diaries weren’t subject to Freedom of Information because they could be in the owner’s version of shorthand and couldn’t be reliably interpreted by someone else.  However, FoI is not a Royal Commission and the diarist can be compelled to explain their diary entries.
11
The Sports Desk / Re: God help me - the Cricket thread
If I remember correctly, several cases of ball tampering have been detected by the umpires noticing a change in the condition of the ball.

Cummins was pretty staunch in his rejection of Khawaja’s allegation and was somewhat Dan Andrews like in his willingness to stay and answer all questions put to him.

I’m none the wiser but I can’t help but think that those involved were incredibly naive to think that they wouldn’t get caught 🙄
12
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
The unredacted diary was provided to the Commission as soon as it was requested, with an apology for originally providing the redacted copy.

I’m not sure what the public servant was thinking, but apparently even the unredacted version of his diary doesn’t make a lot of sense.

The journalists covering the Commission get to see the documents to be tabled and are told who will be called on the following day but are under an embargo and can’t reveal any information until the documents are tabled and/or witnesses are called.
13
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments


You really need to think before you post nonsense Shawny ... and you need to stop trying to deflect with continual references to Taco in this thread and continual references to Australian governments in the Taco thread.  They're completely separate issues ... and threads. 

It is the Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects in Victoria.  It was called by the State Labor Government "to inquire into and report on matters relating to corruption, criminal conduct and serious misconduct on or in relation to major construction projects in Victoria."  The allegations that prompted the Royal Commission concerned corruption and criminal conduct by the CFMEU and construction companies and poor oversight by government agencies and, potentially, the Government.  The Commission is in the first week of its first block of public hearings and, to be perfectly honest, it hasn't even begun to warm up.

Your spinning responses actually remind me of Andrews with his covid responses when pressed. Avoid any part that may show you up and go off on a tangent raising different points to move the narrative. 

I will try one more time: Why is a royal commission needed if our polices (cheques and balances) are set up to prevent corruption.

I think you mean checks and balances - cheques are last century now.

A Royal Commission is the ultimate in checks and balances.
14
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments


Public hearings started in the same month as the election and will erode any support that the ALP may still have.  The report should be handed down well into the first year of the new government who will be able to use it to their advantage.  Damage control would have been calling the commission far earlier and retaining management of the report.

I’d say that it’s more like self-inflicted, terminal damage.



Sorry DJC, I respectfully disagree. 

This was part of the Jacinta Allen knifing and Ben Carroll handover to attempt to save face leading up to the election race.  Just like the pothole fixing that they are doing.

The spectre of it, was hanging over the Labor government.

Strategically they knew she would lose, and offed her to bring in Ben Carroll.  Would the Royal Commission have occurred had that not happened?  Its a way to attempt to distance Ben Carroll from Jacinta Allen, and save face, and blame the outgoing leader for all the woes.

Nothing more, nothing less.

I cannot fault the strategy, but to think this is noble thinking or "falling on ones sword" is naive, and Ben is actively spruiking it on advertisements as him trying to fix things. 

Even if they had a point, the labor government at state level has ruled the roost for a very long time.  You would be better off mounting an argument that Federal government is more culpable as the Libs have dictated that component for longer.

There's no doubt that Carroll called the Royal Commission in an attempt to distance himself from Allan and Andrews, but the timing couldn't have been worse for the ALP.  We're in the final fortnight of the election campaign and every day there's going to be headlines from the Commission driving another nail in the coffin just like yesterday's scolding from the senior counsel over the redacted diary.  Jess Wilson should be instructing her candidates to keep their mouths shut and let the Commission do their work for them.

I suppose that Carroll really had no option but the unwritten rules of Royal Commissions are never call one if you don't know the outcomes and can't control the timing of the report.  Allan should really have called it when she took over, but it would probably still be just moving deck chairs on the Titanic.
15
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments


You really need to think before you post nonsense Shawny ... and you need to stop trying to deflect with continual references to Taco in this thread and continual references to Australian governments in the Taco thread.  They're completely separate issues ... and threads. 

It is the Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects in Victoria.  It was called by the State Labor Government "to inquire into and report on matters relating to corruption, criminal conduct and serious misconduct on or in relation to major construction projects in Victoria."  The allegations that prompted the Royal Commission concerned corruption and criminal conduct by the CFMEU and construction companies and poor oversight by government agencies and, potentially, the Government.  The Commission is in the first week of its first block of public hearings and, to be perfectly honest, it hasn't even begun to warm up.
this happened on Labor watch, and its an exercise in damage control 6 months out from an election.

Public hearings started in the same month as the election and will erode any support that the ALP may still have.  The report should be handed down well into the first year of the new government who will be able to use it to their advantage.  Damage control would have been calling the commission far earlier and retaining management of the report.

I’d say that it’s more like self-inflicted, terminal damage.