List needs to be semi nuked. Cripps to WCE - too many slow players in the midfield and WCE will pay up McKay to Melbourne/Sydney/Brisbane - is becoming more blatant by the day Motlop and Kemp trade TDK - trade Docherty, Evans, White, Fantasia, McGovern, Cincotta - delist
Need as many future picks (2026) as possible before Tasmania
four years under Voss to balance the list with small forward class. There is only one trade that makes sense - TDK pick if he goes + McKay to North Melbourne for Paul Curtis + 2nd round pick.
Don't give up your day job mate.
You are essentially saying TDK + Harry for Curtis and a 2nd rounder.
I wouldn't do that deal if it was just one of them. No way in hell its both of them.
So what will you do? TDK's pick as it stands is Pick 8 and Melbourne want three first rounders for Pickett.
What will you do to make our forward line more unpredictable?... or just kick the can down the road as Voss has done.
four years under Voss to balance the list with small forward class. There is only one trade that makes sense - TDK pick if he goes + McKay to North Melbourne for Paul Curtis + 2nd round pick.
A brownlow medalist 2 x coleman medalist 6 x All Australians
Its not the list.
That covers, what, 6 players. What about the other 40 on the list? Forget that, what about the other 14 in the team? Lets not go overboard, lets simply look at the other 4 forwards. Out of them, how many get a game in another team?
Parts of the list are strong......very strong.....parts of the list are not. We've pulled a few rabbits out of hats to somewhat potentially solve our CHB issue which was IMO our biggest need. Our next biggest need IMO is elite ball users from HB to HF. This is where we are getting let down. How many from your list above fit that category?
Just can't close out games - efficiency inside 50 was really poor again. It is now 43% efficiency which is bottom four. Inside 50s continue to be good....cant depend on Harry + Charlie kicking 5-6 goals between them .. need goals from smalls as well Ah Chee and Cameron kicked 7 goals between them. If we don't clean up that efficiency inside 50 then no finals for this year.
