Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Recent Posts
11
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
Last post by Lods -
They're not the same...

But here's the thing.
Elections aren't won on the 'extreme' left or the 'extreme' right.
They're decided in the centre.
In a space of about 10%

As both sides move to 'capture' that middle ground around election time, they move closer to each other and at that point may seem similar in many respects.
After the election it may be a bit of a different story...especially if they've been out of power for some time.

But the middle is still the key.
Lose that, and you lose.

Many folks will tell you (though not completely correctly) that the best 'Liberal' government was the Hawke one. ;)  :D
12
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Last post by Thryleon -
You know, the body being disposed of in this fashion, doesnt necessarily reflect its treatment in real life.

Personally, a body is a body.  If this was the cheapest outcome, then is it really that big a deal?

13
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
Last post by Thryleon -
Tend to agree.

You can only manage with incompetence for so long before everyone gets sick of you.

The labor government has shot itself in the foot a lot, and you know when it all swung away from them? 

The indigenous voice to parliament vote.  That costly referendum is when I noted the momentum shift.  It was an expensive exercise, to institute a nothing result with no real defined benefit for indigenous and just was an attempt to get another pig feeding at the trough.

  On the back of that, rampant inflation, and significant stupidity like the Machete bin fiasco, the Commonwealth games flip flop, the big build escalation.  You have a look at the last 4 years objectively and you start to realise, that like any decadent leader, they got ahead of themselves. 

The Iran war was the death knell.  Up until that started, I think things werent great, but then you get a massive fiscal budget policy shift on top which effectively has caused a lot of people around me financial grief, and situations where even a big company like David Jones is falling into receivership.

Jim Chalmers personally caused me a bit of grief in the stock market, blocking a merger and acquisition, which the US company (Cossette) had second thoughts about and used a threat to close a plant in SA down as a reason to back out of a higher takeover bid for MYX (is the stock code).  Thankfully, they are being sold to a Belgium based company instead, which eventuated yesterday, so Ill get less of a windfall as a result, and had to wait an additional year and half for, but thats the way it goes, and they have explicitly put a clause in which will stop that rubbish.  He argued he was saving jobs, which is garbage because Cosette didnt come up with that, until they were trying to back out of the deal, and didnt have grounds for it after they got the chance to look under the hood and manipulated politics to achieve its result.

Will Liberals be any better?  Probably not.  I dont think we are going to get anything revolutionary occur out of a change of government, but sometimes change is necessary to send a message of, we will not stand for your mismanagement any longer.  Who comes out with such fiscal mismanagement like the Labor budget on the back of the geopolitical tensions we were seeing in Iran and Israel?  Who actually thinks that was a good idea?  The answer?  People who sit in circles so out of touch with the world, that they dont truly understand the impact of the rules they were instituting.  The lack of consultation about changing the bank fees, and how it resulted in an inflationary mechanism.  Its just appalling.  They consulted nobody who had run a business to "abolish" the fee.  All they did was move it from transparent to hidden.  If the banks jack these fees up, we wont know.  The businesses absorb those costs, and pass it on to EVERYONE in pricing, whether they pay with cash or not now.  Well done idiots.

14
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
Last post by DJC -
If you try to evaluate the policies as objectively as possible, you wouldn't vote for any of the parties.

None have outlined a vision for the future and there's a common theme in turning the clock back to failed policies of the past.

Perhaps the emergence of GRON as a party capable of winning some seats will shake the major parties out of their malaise ... but I doubt it.
17
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
Last post by kruddler -


So change for changes sake.....and things got worse.

Why does that sound familiar??


Do you have any idea the situation this state is in?

If you do HTF can you argue to continue down the current path?

Seriously mate you sound like your just arguing for arguing sake.

There is no sense at all in what your saying with this one but i know you will just keep doubling down anyway

Mate, i've said it a million times, maybe one last time will help it sink in.

THEY ARE ALL THE SAME.

I'm not saying stick with Labor.

I'm saying thinking any party (labor included) can fix the issues based on the nonsense they are spouting is BS.
They are all 'all talk'.

The bearded bloke who spoke up at the recent gathering nailed it.
"Nobody believes any of you guys"
Doesn't matter what colour they have behind their mugshot photo.....nobody believes them.
19
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
Last post by dodge -
Shawny - yes Victoria ain't great - but I don't see it getting better under any of the choices.

Take potholes.  Libs - $5b to fix 1m potholes - $5k each pothole.  How many potholes are there in Victoria?  How many are State Gov v Local Council responsibility?  What if there are 750k potholes only - do we still spend $5b?  What if there are more than 1m - which ones are chosen not to be fixed?  Lab I think has promised to fix 500k.  same questions apply.

Take police #s - Lib will recruit 3k.  Current targets are 1,500 by mid 2028 to replace the shortfall.  So we are then over policed if Libs get in?  Adding reservists as admin staff - already happening.

Where are staff cuts coming from - they can't be from not replacing staff that are leaving - what is going to give?  Americanisation of health?

Glad that ON and Libs are going to have a graphic showing how much gov is spending - really?  WGAF - it is meaningless and a cost that they gov doesn't need to bear - every fortnight when wages for public servants, including teachers, ambos, firies, cops get paid there is a spike - what a waste of time and resource in updating and maintaining this - and who confirms its' accuracy?

Teachers got their payrise - at what cost?  A lot of aides roles are going to be cut, as schools can't afford them anymore - those that help the more vulnerable learn.

ON are now targeting migrants and NDIS and gov benefits - but until they are citizens or permanent residents, they can't access these services - these take years to achieve, with a pretty significant cost.  Can we start having a discussion with facts?

ON are cutting a heap of duties/taxes - afforded by cancelling SRL.

SRL - go ahead, pause and assess, or cancel.  There won't be an option addressed by an independent body, so whatever floats your boat - there will be massive job losses if it is cancelled - how will these jobs be replaced? It is different to EW link - that hadn't started yet.  If only there was a business case for SRL...

Energy - Libs say whatever is the cheapest will be pursued, ON wants to revive assets that are at End of Life (and stop subsidies, which Hanson disagrees with, but took advantage of), while Net Zero is a Lab target.

This leaves the dilemma - we are not happy with the situation Vic is in, but, can't see it getting better under alternatives.  What role has Murdoch and Rinehardt played with its influence in telling us how we should feel about the state of play, along with the split of Federal v State issues (NDIS, Immigration, Interest Rates).

I just did a 'Build Your Ballot' and the top four within 10% of each other were (in no order) Lab, Lib, Greens, Socialist.  ON were 20%+ behind.
20
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments
Last post by shawny -


They got in because the Libs didn't do anything much at all - they were largely inert but didn't stuff the state up.

So change for changes sake.....and things got worse.

Why does that sound familiar??


Do you have any idea the situation this state is in?

If you do HTF can you argue to continue down the current path?

Seriously mate you sound like your just arguing for arguing sake.

There is no sense at all in what your saying with this one but i know you will just keep doubling down anyway