51
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by ratlice -Will Dean get rubbed out for that push? Hes young he should t have done it, but gee he plays with some vigour 💪🏼
52
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by kruddler -
In the meantime, we just gotta find 23 blokes who are team oriented and disciplined enough to not ruin it for the rest of them.
It highlights why an out of sorts elijah can cause havoc for the whole team too.
What! That's the ticket, guilt-trip the kid. Nice work.
What I saw was Elijah's situation galvanize the playing group and club (as it should) into universal and overwhelming care, love and support. A positive net effect for all concerned.
When he reads this ill apologise to him, until then I'm standing by it.
1 man down in a team defense will bring the while thing down. It cant happen.
Whether its a legitimate reason, elijah, or whether it's someone who simply CBF, the result is the same.
53
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by Gointocarlton -If you haven't read this article it's a good read.
The ABC boys often offer something different to 95% of the AFL media and that's some actual analysis
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-04-02/explaining-carlton-infamous-second-half-fade-outs/106525364
I am not one to blame the Coach, however the MC has to take some responsibility for a side that has no problem developing and executing a game plan that puts them in a position to win the game.
The same group of players with the same ability can't execute in the 2nd half. Fitness? Taxing game style may all play a part, but the coaching team has to be right up there.
It seems to me they're being asked to play a style of game that they are not capable of sustaining.
And when it goes bad, there is no alternative.
That must be terribly frustrating for the playing group.
Do you try to fit the group into the plan, or do you fit the plan to the group?
I'm no dill, its a win loss business and Carlton will do Carlton things and the coach always gets it in the neck so given where we are at, a change will be made. But there are underlying problems that need addressing once and for all which if they arent, we will have having these same threads and discussions in 1,2,3 years time. Nothing surer.
54
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by Lods -If you haven't read this article it's a good read.
The ABC boys often offer something different to 95% of the AFL media and that's some actual analysis
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-04-02/explaining-carlton-infamous-second-half-fade-outs/106525364
I am not one to blame the Coach, however the MC has to take some responsibility for a side that has no problem developing and executing a game plan that puts them in a position to win the game.
The same group of players with the same ability can't execute in the 2nd half. Fitness? Taxing game style may all play a part, but the coaching team has to be right up there.
It seems to me they're being asked to play a style of game that they are not capable of sustaining.
And when it goes bad, there is no alternative.
That must be terribly frustrating for the playing group.
Do you try to fit the group into the plan, or do you fit the plan to the group?
55
The Sports Desk / Re: Track and Field
Last post by Lods -Lachlan Kennedy, Joshua Azzopardi , Christopher Ius, Rohan Browning took 4th place in the 4x 100 final in 38.00 sec.
Earlier the team had run a 37.87 sec to equal the national record.
With the possible addition of either Eddie Nketia and Gout that looks promising,
Going one better was the men's 4x 400 team who smashed the national record to finish third in 2.55.20
Splits were..
Luke Van Ratingen 44.86
Reece Holder 43.12
Thomas Reynolds 43.43
Aidan Murphy 43.79
Our mixed relay 4 x 400 team finished 7th in the final in 3:13.07
Cooper Sherman 45.08
Mia Gross 50.83
Matthew Hunt 44.83
Alexia Loizou 52.33
56
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by Baggers -If you haven't read this article it's a good read.In the meantime, we just gotta find 23 blokes who are team oriented and disciplined enough to not ruin it for the rest of them.
The ABC boys often offer something different to 95% of the AFL media and that's some actual analysis
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-04-02/explaining-carlton-infamous-second-half-fade-outs/106525364
I am not one to blame the Coach, however the MC has to take some responsibility for a side that has no problem developing and executing a game plan that puts them in a position to win the game.
The same group of players with the same ability can't execute in the 2nd half. Fitness? Taxing game style may all play a part, but the coaching team has to be right up there.
It highlights why an out of sorts elijah can cause havoc for the whole team too.
What! That's the ticket, guilt-trip the kid. Nice work.
What I saw was Elijah's situation galvanize the playing group and club (as it should) into universal and overwhelming care, love and support. A positive net effect for all concerned.
57
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by Baggers -Jack Reiwoldt scathing of Harry and also suggesting Cody Walker will be considering Richmond and planting a seed of doubt by talking about it on Fox.
I thought Jack's comments on H were valid.
I laughed when he suggested the Tiggers should have another crack at Cody. None of his co-commentators took the bait... we all saw it for what it was... mischievous, and... silly. But, hey, if the shoe was on the other foot, we'd give it a try as well! Nice try, Jack, you little scallywag, you
58
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by Bluesers -In the third qtr, 6 players laid 1 tackle each. 17 players didnt lay a tackle. EOS.
Begs the question... Why?
Because someone just mentioned the reason earlier in this thread......... the players don't want the coach there......
I bought this up in a post about a year ago, and so far this year it just reinforces what I said then - there is a definite disconnect between MV and the playing group. Also, I don't know if the entire playing group are connected too, that may be a separate issue. We have some talent in the developing list, we've seen them competitive almost weekly, but they too easily become dispirited, disinterested and destabilised. They are not playing for this coach, it's pretty obvious. MV should not take all the blame, there seems to be things going on behind the scenes we don't know about - is my guess. The silence from GW and CFC is deafening - MV will fall first, rightly or wrongly - I'm certain they are working on this currently and will move when the time is right - if there is such a thing.... IF some senior players are rocking the boat, then GW hopefully sorts that out also...
CHANGE is needed.
59
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by laj -If you haven't read this article it's a good read.
The ABC boys often offer something different to 95% of the AFL media and that's some actual analysis
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-04-02/explaining-carlton-infamous-second-half-fade-outs/106525364
I am not one to blame the Coach, however the MC has to take some responsibility for a side that has no problem developing and executing a game plan that puts them in a position to win the game.
The same group of players with the same ability can't execute in the 2nd half. Fitness? Taxing game style may all play a part, but the coaching team has to be right up there.
Nice shakin, albeit a month too late.
I'm buoyed by some of the analysis coming out. Anyone who looks deeper than the win/loss record seems to be coming to the same conclusion, thats its not voss who is to blame.
Game these days is more run and transition. Hence we are getting so many scores over 100. We go nowhere near 100. We still base our game on contested, crash and bash. We fatigue and sides run over us. As EB says, we play a neanderthal game plan while others have moved on. Once sides start running over us we often give up. Now, if we had a coach who could coach the modern game we might not be 11 wins from 40, and 1-7 this year. Win/losses are everything. We played finals 31 games ago. Must've done a good job getting there with no talent....lol. we sat 2nd 8 weeks before that with no talent. That was one of those 29 losses in the 40. But to the spinners that's ok though. Brisbane away, should be 11 wins from 41.
Nice try at spin though
60
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 8 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda
Last post by madbluboy -1. He was exhausted
2. It was a waste of an interchange.