Carlton Supporters Club

Put your crystal ball into action (Carlton only)....

Finishing Position: 9th
Carlton B&F: Marc Murphy
Runner up B&F: Lachie Henderson
Highest Goal Scorer: Lachie Henderson
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 9
Retirees: Scotland, Waite, Judd

Finishing Position: 5th
Carlton B&F: Bryce Gibbs
Runner up B&F: Lachie Henderson
Highest Goal Scorer: Jeff Garlett
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 17
Retirees: Scotland
Delistees: Buckley, Temay

Added "Delistees".

Finishing Position: 9th
Carlton B&F: Henderson
Runner up B&F: Thomas
Highest Goal Scorer: Lachie Henderson
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 11
Retirees: Scotland, Waite, Judd

Finishing Position: 3rd
Carlton B&F: Thomas
Runner up B&F: Bell
Highest Goal Scorer: Casboult
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 16

Finishing Position: 8th
Carlton B&F: Simpson
Runner up B&F: Gibbs
Highest Goal Scorer: Waite
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 13

Finishing Position: 4th
Carlton B&F: Murphy
Runner up B&F: Thomas
Highest Goal Scorer: Casboult
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 14
Retirees: Scotland
Delistees: Temay
Traded:: Gibbs (forced), Bootsma, Lucas, McInnes, White, Ellard.

Finishing Position: 6th
Carlton B&F: Marc Murphy
Runner up B&F: Lachie Henderson
Highest Goal Scorer: Jeff Garlett
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 12
Retirees: Scotland, Waite

Finishing Position: Premiers
Carlton B&F: Lachie Henderson
Runner Up B&F: Murphy, Gibbs, Thomas
Highest Goal Scorer: Walker
Games Jarrad Waite Plays: 20
Retirees: Scotland
Delistees: Temay, Ellard, White

Finishing Position: Premiers

PFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFT.  ;D

I'm just taking a big WAG, have not applied any science!

Finishing Position: 6th
Carlton B&F: Murphy
Runner up B&F: Simpson
Highest Goal Scorer: Henderson
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 16
Retirees: Scotland, Duigan, maybe Carrazzo
Delistees: Rowe, Ellard, Buckley, White and/or McInnes
Traded:: Bootsma, Lucas,

Quote from: nathbear on January 14, 2014, 11:22:30 am

Finishing Position: Premiers

PFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFT.  ;D

I heard that... go outside with your crazy cat!  ;)

Hey, when we win, I'll be able to come out with a Hotcox-esque 'you heard it here first' haha.

Only one number out of 18 can be right, so why not first? ;)

Quick guess only:

Finishing Position: 9th
Carlton B&F: Gibbs (because I keep hoping every year)
Runner up B&F: Curnow
Highest Goal Scorer: Garlett
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 9
Retirees: Scotland, Carrazzo,
Delistees: Rowe, Ellard, Buckley, Casboult, Cachia
Traded: Bootsma, Lucas, Yarran

Finishing Position: 7th
Carlton B&F: Walker
Runner up B&F: Henderson
Highest Goal Scorer: Garlett
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 11
Retirees: Scotland, Waite, Judd

I've only put 10 seconds of thought into this!

Finishing Position: 4th
Carlton B&F: Gibbs
Runner up B&F: Murphy
Highest Goal Scorer: Garlett
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 15
Retirees: Scotland, Carrazzo,
Delistees: Ellard, White, Buckley(hope not)
Traded: Bootsma

Finishing Position: 1st/Premiers
Carlton B&F: Murphy
Runner up B&F: Thomas
Highest Goal Scorer: Casboult
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 27
Retirees: Scotland, Carrazzo, Judd, Waite
Delistees: Ellard, White, Duigan,

If the first one is going to happen, the next 4 pretty much have to as well.  More pie in the sky than anything else, but nothing wrong with that.

Finishing Position: 2nd (runners up)
Carlton B&F: Yarran
Runner up B&F: Thomas
Highest Goal Scorer: Rowe
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 20 (incl. 3 finals)
Retirees: Scotland, Waite
Delistees: White

You need to lose one to win four! 

I reckon Judd and possably others would go around  again if we go that close in 2014.

Finishing position: 4th
Carlton B&F: Thomas and runner up Simspon.
Highest goal Scorer: Betts, Ooops Waite.
Games Waite plays: 18
Retirees: Scotland
Delistees: White and Ellard.

What gives people the idea that we will finish top four?

What gives people the idea that we will finish top four?

Natural progression ;) :D

Goz you've been a bit dismissive of our chances this year. You've even suggested we won't make the 8.
Why the pessimism?

My own thoughts were that Malthouse would take a year to get things under (his) control and that the coming season would be one for definite ladder improvement.
If we don't make the eight there will be some serious questions asked.


Finishing Position: 3rd
Carlton B&F: Henderson
Runner up B&F: Murphy
Highest Goal Scorer: Lachie Henderson
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 11
Retirees: Scotland, Waite

I suppose the amount of times I've heard in the pre season over the years thatthe blues will finish top four is a little like the boy who cried wolf....eventually people arent going to take it seriously if it never happens.

I suppose the amount of times I've heard in the pre season over the years thatthe blues will finish top four is a little like the boy who cried wolf....eventually people arent going to take it seriously if it never happens.

I see where you're coming from...but to miss the eight we'd have to go backwards or sides below us would have to improve dramatically.
I just can't see that happening.
I don't think Malthouse can afford to see that happening.

Quote from: Gozza on January 15, 2014, 08:41:21 am

I suppose the amount of times I've heard in the pre season over the years thatthe blues will finish top four is a little like the boy who cried wolf....eventually people arent going to take it seriously if it never happens.

I see where you're coming from...but to miss the eight we'd have to go backwards or sides below us would have to improve dramatically.
I just can't see that happening.
I don't think Malthouse can afford to see that happening.

We missed the eight in 2013. It was only through extraordinary circumstances that we got in. So technically speaking we have missed the eight two years running after finishing 5th in 2011. Hopefully with the list having a clean out that was long overdue we can go forward. Based on what I've seen the last two years I'm not sold on us...but with a few list changes we're an unknown quantity.

Finishing Position: 7th
Carlton B&F: Bryce Gibbs
Runner up B&F: Kade Simpson
Highest Goal Scorer: Jeff Garlett
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 13
Retirees: Scotland, Mclean
Delistees: Rowe, Ellard, Buckley, Casboult, Cachia, White, Temay
Traded: Lucas, Bootsma

Major Injuries: Thomas(ankle), Menzel(knee)

I reckon Judd and possably others would go around  again if we go that close in 2014.

Pretty much Amers, we basically have to be a top four team by the end of the year for Judd to hang around one more. Otherwise if we are still battling just for a finals spot then I don't think the great man will hang for another 2-3 years and sadly it will be the end of an unbelievable career.

Finishing Position: 6-4
Carlton B&F: Marc Murphy
Runner up B&F: Andrew Walker
Highest Goal Scorer: Levi Casboult
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 15
Retirees: Scotland, Judd
Delistees: Rowe, Ellard, White, Temay

Traded: Yarran

Finishing Position:  10th
Carlton B&F: Dale Thomas
Runner up B&F:  Zac Tuohy
Highest Goal Scorer: Jeff Garlett
Games Jarrad Waite plays: 5
Retirees:  Scotland, Carrazzo, Waite, Rowe

Finishing Position:  10th

Out comes the Guillotine

Goodbye Board.
Goodbye Admin
Goodbye Coach

Vive la Revolution :D

Quote from: TheSheik on January 15, 2014, 03:39:59 pm

Finishing Position:  10th

Out comes the Guillotine

Goodbye Board.
Goodbye Admin
Goodbye Coach

Vive la Revolution :D

Yes that really would usher in Sheik's longed for scorched earth at the club!  :))