Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest (Read 5537 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

So the B+F was on tonight (i forgot)  :-[

But as expected Maddie Prespakis wins.

Chloe Dalton came in 2nd place
Georgie Gee finished 3rd.


Votes were....
Prespakis (74)
Dalton (56)
Gee (43)
Egan (41)
McEvoy (39)

From our CSC B+F results we had
Quote
14. Prespakis
6. Harrington
4. Gee
4. Dalton
3. Egan
2. Laloifi
2. Moody
2. Vescio
1. Harris
1. Stevens
1. McEvoy
1. J. Hosking
1. S. Hosking

From our consistency leaderboard (all votes included)
Quote
1. Prespakis  (10.96)
2. Harrington  (5.14)
3. Dalton  (4.3)
4. Gee  (4.24)
5. Egan  (3.51)
6. Harris  (2.34)
7. Laloifi  (2.03)
8. McEvoy  (1.88)
9. Vescio  (1.29)
10. S. Hosking  (1.19)
11. Moody  (1.13)
12. Wilson  (1.01)
13. Stevens  (0.97)
14. J. Hosking  (0.67)
15. Loynes  (0.63)
16. Brazzale  (0.43)
17. Pound  (0.17)
18. Plane  (0.14)


The question remains....were was our runner-up Harrington??
Overlooked!

Other awards.....
Best first year player - Grace Egan
The Carlton Way award - Jess Edwards
Rising Star - Georgie Gee
Fans MVP - Maddy Prespakis

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #1 –
It should be mentioned too that Maddie Prespakis was runner up in the AFLW MVP award to Jazzie Garner.....a great effort.

Maddie was also named Vice captain of the AFLW best 22 under 22 team.
Georgie Gee and Charlotte Wilson also made the 22 under 22 team.

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #2 –
Not surprising, she is a superstar.
2021-Pi$$ or get off the pot
2022- Real Deal or more of the same? 0.6%
2023- "Raise the Standard" - M. Voss Another year wasted Bar Set
2024-Back to the drawing boardNo excuses, its time
2025-Carlton can win the 2025 AFL Premiership

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #3 –
Champ. Destined to be a CFC great. What heart and tenacity. You're a ripper, Maddy. Keep up the great work and great example you set for the entire club.
Only our ruthless best, from Board to bootstudders will get us no. 17

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #4 –
Congratulations Maddy, well-deserved win indeed! 👏

I reckon she will continue to improve, particularly with her mentor’s help.

Funny about Harrington not polling well - it seems that defenders aren’t noticed, except by hard-nosed supporters 🤔
"Negative waves are not helpful. Try saying something righteous and hopeful instead." Oddball

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #5 –
Quote from: DJC – on
Congratulations Maddy, well-deserved win indeed! 👏

I reckon she will continue to improve, particularly with her mentor’s help.

Funny about Harrington not polling well - it seems that defenders aren’t noticed, except by hard-nosed supporters 🤔
Well Harrington just got named AA, along with Prespakis and Harris. So at least thats some recognition.

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #6 –
Quote from: kruddler – on
Well Harrington just got named AA, along with Prespakis and Harris. So at least thats some recognition.
Yes, for me Harrington was clearly in our top two, if not actually our equal best given she had missed some quarters.

I love our girls and the AFLW, but it's still throws up some puzzling moments.

Of course we do not know the roles they were given, but I'd have had Harrington, Stevens and maybe even Egan ahead of Dalton. Dalton had a couple of very good games at the end of the season, but I would have said she was influential in the early rounds.

I thought McEvoy played good quarters, but wasn't anywhere near as consistent as the others, not sure who she ended up 5th.

I think Hosking and Katie Loynes are a bit stiff not to be in the votes, and either of our rucks could have figured as well.

I suppose overall our season was pretty even which is a tell, for those who haven't seen it yet.
"Extremists on either side will always meet in the Middle!"

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #7 –
Just on the above, from our votes, Dalton polled in 4 games. The last 3 and R2 vs the pies (she was 2nd BOG.) There was 3 where she didn't poll.

For the record....(polled in)
1: Prespakis - 5 games
2: Dalton - 4 games
3: Gee - 4
4: Egan - 3
5: McEvoy - 3
6: Vescio - 1
7: Laloifi - 3
8: Harrington - 3
9: Harris - 3
10: Stevens - 2

??: Wilson - 3
??: S. Hosking - 2
??: J. Hosking - 1
??: Moody - 1
??: Pound - 1
??: Loynes - 1
??: Brazzale - 1
??: Plane - 1
??: Moody - 0
??: Edwards - 0

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #8 –
Quote from: DJC – on
Congratulations Maddy, well-deserved win indeed! 👏

I reckon she will continue to improve, particularly with her mentor’s help.

Funny about Harrington not polling well - it seems that defenders aren’t noticed, except by hard-nosed supporters 🤔

Mistakes are always more costly in the backline and it artificially deflates your performance.

How many times has Liam Jones, and Weitering worn the ire of fans because their opponents get a run on and kick a few in a quarter, but for 3/4 they were top with a weight of numbers of entries costing them dearly.
"everything you know is wrong"

Paul Hewson
 

Re: 2020 AFLW - Best and Fairest

Reply #9 –
Quote from: Thryleon – on
How many times has Liam Jones, and Weitering worn the ire of fans because their opponents get a run on and kick a few in a quarter, but for 3/4 they were top with a weight of numbers of entries costing them dearly.
That says more about fans and human perceptions than it does the players.

Fans nearly always vote the goal kicker / finisher, and ignore the people who created the opportunity much earlier in the chain of play.

I realise they are not infallible, but I expect professional voters(coaches and match officials) to be above this sort of shallow perception.
"Extremists on either side will always meet in the Middle!"