Where Warner got it right last Test he just played straight down the line and if it swung he missed it. Went back to being hesitant last night and nicked it.
He was simply lucky it was doing so much. He struggles in England. Can't deny that
Warner's looking lost against Broad. Doesn't know whether to play or leave. His 61 last Test saved him and the only way he'll play the next Test is if he has a good 2nd innings. Right now prefer a Khawaja 20 than a Warner duck.
To be fair he Warner did average 46 with 5 half centuries on the last tour to England but he is right out of form now.
To be fair he has never made a hundred in England either. He never looked “in” on that last tour because his technique doesn’t stack up on moving decks. That’s why he’s shot now, doesn’t have any plan against the moving ball.
Oh, I see that - just and admittedly I an no Warner fan.
They have all been terrible really, Smith aside.
Warner could have been out 20 times in that innings. Admittedly, it was pretty tough batting, the ball was doing plenty, which, oddly, is probably what saved him.
Other than Smith, Labuschagne is the other to do very well.
Dangerfield will probably torch us but his ball use and field kicking is horrible. Could have iced last weeks game but missed from 35, which happens more than occasionally. He does so much right but gees he gets away with some schizenhausen play at times because of who he is.
Get ready for him to gob off and whinge all day to the umpires - we're going to get deadest raped in this game.
Let’s hope Cripps and Kreuzer have blinders Geelong mids only run one way Their rucks are terrible They won’t want to risk injury before finals
Khawaa, Bancroft, Waner. Heck, Wade bar one innings has been schizen.
The catch - unfathomable that a third umpire would give that out....
Agree on the catch. How does that bloke officiate in any position after a dozen errors in the first test. Surely after this, they replace him. No, I actually think he is back on field in the next test.
Labuschagne ... great knock. Root, you're a lying cheat
I think Warner might go first. Technically suspect and really struggling to survive Khawaja also in trouble though Harris, labuschagne and Pattinson in?
It was great to get out of that with a win, particularly with an undermanned defence. Levi was excellent (and Teague clearly wants him as a forward option in 2020), Plowman was undersized but stood up well and Newman, Thomas, Setterfield, Samo and Simmo were all instrumental in denying St Kilda.
I was pleased with Dow and O'Brien. Both showed poise and commitment and I think that they will continue to develop and improve and have big seasons next year.
Only human to relax 1/2 a % with the surety of what happened this week... likewise the players. It will take terrific discipline to get the players and coaches 100+% focussed.
A significant test for DT and others. And the Aints will be very aware of all this and will no doubt hit hard from the get go.