Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Recent Posts
2
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 23 2026 Pre Game Predictions Carlton vs Bulldogs at Marvel
Last post by Thryleon -
IMHO, weitering was hardly as dominant as made out.


He had two very poor efforts too which resulted in goals to the saints on Sunday.

1.  He assumed a ball was going to carry over for a throw in, just to have a saints player shark it from behind him.

2.  Another one where he turned it over in defense. 

There was another one where he went the short option to ollie hollands who got caught holding the ball and it was more ollie being indecisive on the next kick than anything else.

Even so, i didnt think he played particularly well against a saints team that wasn't flushed with tall talent.



The Doggies arent overly tall, and our balance is as good as ever.  Not sure we need weiters back this week, and would rather play charleson than weiters. 
5
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 23 2026 Pre Game Predictions Carlton vs Bulldogs at Marvel
Last post by Lods -
Quote from: RiverRat – on
Quote from: Lods – on
Think it will be Weitering for Young.


Most likely although Young doesn't deserve to be dropped.

No, he doesn't.
I'm not sure anybody does.
"Unchanged" seemed to work pretty well for us.

I guess the thing is that if we do make it to the wildcard round we would want Weitering there, so best get him back in sooner rather than later.
10
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: AFL Rd 20 2026 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St. Kilda at Marvel
Last post by DJC -
It seems to me that we have become one with the Force again and things are as they should be; beating up on St Kilda and letting them have our castoffs  ;D

So much went right for us and it’s hard to single out players when everyone made a solid contribution.

Pitto does deserve a mention and his Golden Fist award was appropriate recognition of probably the best game I have seen him play.  With a little help from Young, Harry and Crippa, we dominated the ruck contests and Pitto physically dominated De Koning and Marshall.  SOS clearly targeted the wrong ruckman and Geelong can have Marshall.  It really was an excellent all-round performance from Pitto and he was almost Gawn-like with his impact on the game.

After Frankie’s first seven or eight games in navy blue, I was starting to think, “What was Nic Austin smoking when he rookied this banana?”  Now it seems that Nic is a genius as Frankie continues to play the small forward and high half-forward roles very well, and he took it up another level last night. 

Our kicking has improved out of sight and the players are willing to be far more creative and aggressive with their kicking.  Crippa’s kick across his body to find Hayward on the wing was superbly executed and I think that it was Dean who did the opposite and kicked across his body on the boundary to a teammate in the corridor.  And, speaking of Hayward, hasn’t he, Florent and Ainsworth added some grunt and polish to the team.  Charlie might be headed towards another Coleman and De Koning and Jack are getting better coin but the addition of those three seasoned players and our youngsters in Dean, Smith, Byrner, as well as Derksen, has given us an edge.

Smith was quiet and I suspect that learning how to deal with a hard tag will be his homework this week.  Of course, he wasn’t shut down completely and our other mids more than covered his reduced output.

It was disappointing to see Nas limp off.  Apart from his entertainment value, I was interested to see how Lord would go running with him.  Lord started OK but it was a difficult task ahead of him.

Finally, a shout out to Liam Stocker on playing his hundredth game.  I never thought he’d get there but it was the best game I’ve seen him play and quite fitting that it was Spud’s Game.