Re: ELIMINATION FINAL : Ninth Beats Ninthmond (Ha Ha Ha Ending)
Reply #209 –
I'd prefer to have DOA around than not. He rarely provides us with too much insight, but the times that he does its worth its weight in gold.
I like Andrew, and love it when he is up and about and is playing well, but the game against Richmond yesterday was not one of his best.
Its fair enough for his dad to get defensive, but Walker has had a very good season, and DOA should be proud of him. Hopefully he is able to tighten up his defensive play a bit, as I dont see why he should get worse when playing closer to the goal square, but thats another story. I think our backline as a whole failed to keep the match ups to our advantage by allowing Jamo to run up the ground with Riewoldt. When he goes, we should be switching opponents accordingly, so Jamo is left on Edwards (win for us) and Walker up the ground with Riewoldt can only help us especially if Walker is able to get to the ball first.
I tend to agree Thry. However, I have a feeling that Malthouse knows full well that Walker, Simpson, Yarran, Tuohy, Armfield, Gibbs, etc are not dour defenders and will give away goals. I think it is more a calculated risk that the run they provide out of the backline will provide more scoring opportunities for us and will tempt the opposition to use more defensive forwards.
I also think that Edwards was a particularly difficult match-up for Tuohy, McInnes and Walker, and Simon White would have been better suited to matching his strength and marking.