Carlton Supporters Club

So we push him up after one game with managed time on the field, he plays an ordinary game because he’s still trying to find the pace at VFL level let alone AFL, and we all start calling him a dud, spud, underdone, useless etc.  Let him build up match fitness in the 2s to give him a chance to succeed.

So we push him up after one game with managed time on the field, he plays an ordinary game because he’s still trying to find the pace at VFL level let alone AFL, and we all start calling him a dud, spud, underdone, useless etc.  Let him build up match fitness in the 2s to give him a chance to succeed.

Sadly I think this true. He is becoming a liability in the backline with his poor disposal, turns it over more often than not. His endeavour, putting his body on the line and commitment remains elite, perhaps a fwd role would better suit him?

Geez I can't believe with all the other spuds we have currently running around in the side Simmo's place is being questioned. F ME.

Weitering and Kreuzer should be good to go, logic says that Phillips and O'Shea will make way.
No one really put their hand up in the VFL as far as I know so they would probably be the only changes, especially as Cunningham has copped an injury.
I've got a feeling that we'll be beaten but not humiliated.

Simmo won't be dropped IMO. He's part of the heart and soul of our club.

Yes Cookie, but you have to admit he is butchering it a little more than usual. I also realise its very hard to dump nearly 300 games of experience at this point in time so we must cut him a little slack I suppose. What else can we do?

Yes he has made a few blues but his presence is very important to us atm GTC, along with Daisy, Ed, Sam Rowe and even Levi. The kids need them present for them for the time being imho as the  mature influencers. That's more important than a few mistakes.

Phillips is underrated IMO. Lets see what he's got. His leaping advantage could very much help us against Sauce Jacobs who will outdo Kreuzer in most ruck contests.

Simmo won't be dropped IMO. He's part of the heart and soul of our club.

Is there a worse left foot kick in the comp?
We all love his commitment but wow he can turn it over.

Is there a worse left foot kick in the comp?
We all love his commitment but wow he can turn it over.