Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Messages

This section allows you to view all Messages made by this member. Note that you can only see Messages made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - tex

157
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Chris Yarran has gone backwards.
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Quote from: tex on
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Who's at fault is debatable.
lol.
Seen the light have we?

What that I get a negative karma every time you log in? Yeah.

With regards to Yarran I blame MM without a doubt, I just CBF arguing the point over and over again to a bunch of people that see MM as some sort of messiah that can do no wrong. :P
Try spending less time being paranoid Chris. :)
159
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: RD 19 : Blues Lose To Frockers (Aftermatch Angst)
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Quote from: tex on
I also point towards Kane Lucas, Cachia, McLean, Henderson as players who have come on under MM.

Lucas has shown a little for sure. Cachia wasn't on our list I dont see how he comes into that equation. Mclean played better last year than this year. Henderson was injured all through last year and you can pout his improvement down to natural progression. The rest of the list is going backwards. What happened to them Tex? You seem to think all is fine so what's your explanation?

Quote from: Tex
Re 5: Well fme Carrots, atleast I dont go changing my opinion after every week. ::)

Proof please. I have said for quite some time Malthouse concerns me, my opinion hasn't changed. You're not just throwing that BS comment in to fill in the space because you have no reply are you? You seem to be favouring the cop outs quite a lot of late.
No, I'm referring to the Sack Ratts thread last year, which from you has continued on into this year.

I dont think the list is going backwards. I'd be surprised if anyone else thinks that. The team is in a transitioning phase, but I dont think our development has stalled.

Lucas has shown enough to suggest he'll be there in 100 games time.

McLean had some good performances last year - later on. But he had never cemented himself in the midfield group like he has this year.

Also Andy Walks has - finally - developed into a fine running HBF, despite 4 years of mediocrity under Ratten.

Re Cachia: He was drafted in 2010 and spent two years on our list, not playing a singe game. Ratten was the coach at this time.


People need to go back and read the post-match threads from 2012. Its all very well to say 'It has never been this bad before.' Actually, it has, and only 12 months ago we were at one of the lowest ebbs.
161
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: RD 19 : Blues Lose To Frockers (Aftermatch Angst)
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Quote from: tex on
I watched the whole game. For 3/4's of that game we withstood and held our own against a Top 3 side imposing enormous pressure despite us being one man down and having several passengers.

They were down their two best key position players (some may argue their two best players)

Quote from: Tex
I'm not sure where people expect us to be at?

The same place you expected us to be at last year.

Quote from: Tex
The writing was on the wall when Sandilands lined up against Kreuzer who has wrecked himself over the last fortnight.

This comment means nothing. How did Kreuzer wreck himself? By playing two decent games? What a fkn joke, that doesn't even rate as a cop out.

Quote from: Tex
Yes, certain parts of the game showed our soft underbelly. But this has been part of our club for many years now. It will take take to overcome that. Fortunately we have the right coach for the job now.

Our underbelly is softer and we have in fact gone backwards with the new coach. Many players way down on form. Once again, your comments make little to no sense.

Quote from: Tex
Again: it was a fair effort for where we are at as a club.

Again, you must be delusional. I think you're the only person on here who thinks that. I think you should just face up to the realisation that Ratts was not that bad and the appointment of MM is another c0ck up from the very board you no doubt criticise.
Re 1: yep, they were. And despite this they played with enormous intensity. If we played a full team Freo and they played at 95% people here would be cheering about how we're a certainty for a Preliminary final. They are the ones who need a reality check. You can only beat what is dished up on the night, and Freo dished up some pretty bloody good footy last night. It is irrelevant who was not named in their best 22.

Re 2: I think I said Top 4/6 last year, and Top 8 this year. Last year we didnt develop as we should have. Effectively Ratten had taken the group as far as he could. This year I altered my position simply on the fact that it takes half a season or more to work out a gameplan and 'buy in' to that plan. Much like Fremantle last year (who finished 7th or 8th?).

Re 3: I disagree. I think it was a poor decision to play a lone ruck against a superhuman in Sandilands. I also think expecting Krezuer to perform the way he has over the last few weeks against Sandilands was unrealistic.

Re 4: The games against Hawthorn and Fremantle suggest otherwise. We were in both of them against relentless pressure. Its still soft, but I think we're a lot harder team than where we were last year. Interestingly, MM in his PC says 'we weren't hard at all' - I'd hate to know what he thought of us the last few years. I also point towards Kane Lucas, Cachia, McLean, Henderson as players who have come on under MM. Once again our gameplan takes time adjusting to and this may be a reason for certain players lack of form.

Re 5: Well fme Carrots, atleast I dont go changing my opinion after every week. ::)
162
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Chris Yarran has gone backwards.
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Quote from: tex on
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Wow brilliant move by Malthouse to drop him, certainly got the best out of him didn't it? He's firing on all cylinders now. He's not in our best 22 and our best 22 is a pretty weak outfit. What a fall from grace from Yarran, TBH I can't even watch him any more it's just too painful.
Poor Chris. He got dropped for not performing and how refuses to perform at all. Defs the fault of the coach. :))

Of course it's not up to the coach to get the best out of the players is it Tex? Have you visited the old Sack Ratts thread lately? Are you a hypocrite? Much? Oh yeah right I forgot it was a fair effort from us last night.  ::)
A big flaw of Rattens was his inability to find a plan B / punish the players. I believe this has been resolved under MM.


Anyway, Carrots, what you are calling for is Chris Yarran to never be dropped. I dont need to explain myself as to how stupid such a proposition is.
The sooner Yarran realises its not all about him the better.
163
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Chris Yarran has gone backwards.
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Wow brilliant move by Malthouse to drop him, certainly got the best out of him didn't it? He's firing on all cylinders now. He's not in our best 22 and our best 22 is a pretty weak outfit. What a fall from grace from Yarran, TBH I can't even watch him any more it's just too painful.
Poor Chris. He got dropped for not performing and how refuses to perform at all. Defs the fault of the coach. :))

fwiw I dont reckon Rich or Zeibell need any motivation from their coach. They just get the job done. Week in. Week out. Funny thing is we knew this when they were 18. ;)
164
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: RD 19 : Blues Lose To Frockers (Aftermatch Angst)
Quote from: Brettie on
Quote from: PassIt2Carrots on
Quote from: tex on
pretty fair effort tbh.

Wow just saw this.

I know - makes you shake your head......tex, seriously, did you just fast-forward through the game watching our goals only, 'cos unless that's what you did, that opinion has no place in this forum....
I watched the whole game. For 3/4's of that game we withstood and held our own against a Top 3 side imposing enormous pressure despite us being one man down and having several passengers.

I'm not sure where people expect us to be at? Did they think we would win this? We are bordering as a Top 8 side. I dont think Port, North or West Coast would have fared any better last night. Perhaps they wouldnt have been blown out of the water in the last, but thats it.

The writing was on the wall when Sandilands lined up against Kreuzer who has wrecked himself over the last fortnight.

Yes, certain parts of the game showed our soft underbelly. But this has been part of our club for many years now. It will take take to overcome that. Fortunately we have the right coach for the job now.

Again: it was a fair effort for where we are at as a club.
165
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: RD 19 : Blues Lose To Frockers (Aftermatch Angst)
Quote from: TheSheik on
Quote from: madbluboy on
Yarran put up one of the weakest contests I've ever seen and then when he didn't win the ball he just stopped and watched. We just need to cut our losses and trade this guy.

I have been copping an almighty bashing for a few years now because I have been saying that exact thing.
right next to me.