Carlton Supporters Club

Kennedy( 4 more games) has kicked the same amount of goals as Williams this season, has more Goal Assists and double the disposals and Id suggest at half the money...I reckon the Bulldogs would be very happy with their cheap freebie pickup.

Quote from: Thryleon – on August 21, 2025, 06:01:34 pm

@Djc jack martin wasn't a player for us anyway.  Cunningham was varying degrees of the same and if anyone is mounting an argument for afl capable mids then weve effectively only lost one from last season based on games played (kennedy).  Jack Carroll played mainly forward pocket/high half forward and has zero defensive side to his game.  Weve discarded a lot of players lately but Kennedy aside none have fired a shot at afl level until martin at Geelong and even he's been a small sample size.

That also kyboshes the forwards playing midfield argument

Yes, they were listed as midfielders even though they rarely got on the park. 

In terms of ability and durability, it's Kennedy out (Martin has been played mostly as a defender by Geelong), Lord in, and three others with potential.

Zac Williams stints in the midfield have been very effective this season, more so than when he was tried as a full time mid.  He probably spends more time as a forward than Kennedy does at the Bulldogs, but I would argue that he has been more important to us than Kennedy has for the Doggies.

Moir is another forward who will probably be used more as a midfielder if his cameos to date are any indication.

Quote from: DJC – on August 21, 2025, 06:24:28 pm

Yes, they were listed as midfielders even though they rarely got on the park. 

In terms of ability and durability, it's Kennedy out (Martin has been played mostly as a defender by Geelong), Lord in, and three others with potential.

Zac Williams stints in the midfield have been very effective this season, more so than when he was tried as a full time mid.  He probably spends more time as a forward than Kennedy does at the Bulldogs, but I would argue that he has been more important to us than Kennedy has for the Doggies.

Moir is another forward who will probably be used more as a midfielder if his cameos to date are any indication.

Twice i've seen 'list changes - Lord: in'.

He was on our list already. Its not an in.

Quote from: kruddler – on August 21, 2025, 07:38:07 pm

Twice i've seen 'list changes - Lord: in'.

He was on our list already. Its not an in.

Lord was added to our list in 2024, Kennedy left in 2024.

Lord wasn’t on our list in 2023.  He is an in!

Quote from: DJC – on August 21, 2025, 10:24:47 pm

Lord was added to our list in 2024, Kennedy left in 2024.

Lord wasn’t on our list in 2023.  He is an in!

He and Kennedy played in the same team so one cant be an out and one an in at the same time.