Jim Park Analysis 2025

Topic: Jim Park Analysis 2025 (Read 28214 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #15 – July 17, 2025, 01:56:11 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 15:   Carlton vs North Melbourne
Another embarrassment, and we still almost won. Just goes to show how poor we were for so much of the game.

Trends:
[1]   There were 6 voters this round, a new low that I hope never to see again. Our performance was so bad that it almost justifies the lack of interest. Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2]   The rating was a 5.50, which represents a F+ or an E-. That is on par with the Richmond game.

[3]   14 players managed a mention this week, which isn't bad. Alas, none of them were in the range of the previous few week's results as even our best players were overshadowed by North players.

[4]   The average vote this week was 18. Our equal worst result since I've been doing this.

[5]   2 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which says so much about how we were dominated by North.

[6]   McGovern and Hewett were the only 2 to pass 100 votes, with McGovern getting his first BOG for the season. George was 2nd.

[7]   No player managed votes from everyone this week. Nobody really stood out.

[8]   Again, our youngsters made some contribution this week, led by Hollands.

[9]   This was a round where none of our lines stood out. Our mids did best, but that wasn't saying a lot.

Votes:
McGovern, Mitchell 193
Hewett, George   174
Hollands, Oliver 83
Acres, Blake 69
Saad, Adam 64
Docherty, Sam 64
Weitering, Jacob 55
Cerra, Adam 28
William, Zac 28
Fogarty, Lachlan 18
Haynes, Nick 18
Motlop, Jesse 14
Binns, Jaxon 9
Cripps, Patrick 9

Progressive Votes:
2743 George Hewett
1500 Tom de Koning
1434 Patrick Cripps
1386 Adam Cerra
1043   Sam Walsh
974 Jacob Weitering
930 Ollie Hollands
846 Jack Silvagni
668   Nick Haynes
627 Adam Saad
546 Harry McKay
279 Mitch McGovern
472 Charlie Curnow
298 Sam Docherty
294 Jesse Motlop
275 Brodie Kemp
215 Corey Durdin
191 Blake Acres
183 Zac Williams
176 Cooper Lord
137 Lachie Fogarty
127 Jaxon Binns
107 Lewis Young
105   Alex Cincotta
79   Matthew Cottrell
72   Elijah Holland
32   Will White
25 Matthew Carroll
21 Lucas Camporeale
14 Marc Pittonet
6   Harry O'Farrell
3   Lachie Cowan

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #16 – July 17, 2025, 02:35:30 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 16:   Carlton vs Port Adelaide
Another embarrassment. What more can I say?

Trends:
[1]   There were 9 voters this round, which is a 50% improvement over last week. Pity opur game wasn't the same. Our performance was so bad that it almost justifies the lack of interest. Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2]   The rating was a 4.96, which represents a F. A new and unwelcome low.

[3]   13 players managed a mention this week, which isn't bad. Alas, none of them were match winning.

[4]   The average vote this week was 16. A new low.

[5]   3 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is better than last week. Hewett, Hollands and Haynes managed it this week.

[6]   George Hewett managed yet another BOG for us, followed closely by Nick Haynes and Ollie Hollands.

[7]   2 players, Haynes and Hewett, managed votes from everyone this week. Ollie missed from one voter.

[8]   Again, our youngsters made some contribution this week, led by Hollands.

[9]   This was a round where none of our lines stood out. Our mids did best, but that wasn't saying a lot. I hate writing this!

Votes:
Hewett, George   201
Haynes, Nick   163
Hollands, Oliver 152
Docherty, Sam 66
Fantasia, Orazio 44
William, Zac 33
Lord, Cooper 22
Curnow, Charles 19
Cincotta, Alex 17
Young, Lewis 11
Cripps, Patrick 8
Fogarty, Lachlan 6
de Koning, Tom 3

Progressive Votes:
2944 George Hewett
1503 Tom de Koning
1442 Patrick Cripps
1386 Adam Cerra
1082 Ollie Hollands
1043   Sam Walsh
974 Jacob Weitering
846 Jack Silvagni
831   Nick Haynes
627 Adam Saad
546 Harry McKay
472 Mitch McGovern
365 Sam Docherty
341 Charlie Curnow
294 Jesse Motlop
275 Brodie Kemp
216 Zac Williams
215 Corey Durdin
198 Cooper Lord
191 Blake Acres
142 Lachie Fogarty
127 Jaxon Binns
119 Alex Cincotta
118 Lewis Young
79   Matthew Cottrell
72   Elijah Holland
45   Orazio Fantasia
32   Will White
25 Matthew Carroll
21 Lucas Camporeale
14 Marc Pittonet
6   Harry O'Farrell
3   Lachie Cowan

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #17 – July 17, 2025, 03:07:32 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 17:   Carlton vs Collingwood
Another embarrassment.

Trends:
[1]   There were 8 voters this round, which is still far from ideal. Unfortunately, our performance was so bad that it almost justifies the lack of interest. Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2]   The rating was a 5.71, which represents a E-. It isn't good, but it wasn't as bad as last week.

[3]   17 players managed a mention this week, which is actually very good, but most were bit votes for guys who showed something, rather than for clear winners.

[4]   The average vote this week was 19, which is merely poor. We weren't that embarrassing in the bad old days of a few years back.

[5]   2 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is one worse than last week. Williams and Ollie Hollands managed it this time.

[6]   Zac Williams managed his 1st BOG for us with 264 votes and he didn't even manage 4 quarters of football, followed by Ollie Hollands.

[7]   1 players, Zac Williams, managed votes from everyone this week. Ollie missed from one voter.

[8]   Again, our youngsters made some contribution this week, led by Hollands and Cowan.

[9]   This was a round where none of our lines stood out. Our mids did best, but that wasn't saying a lot. I hate writing this!

Votes:
William, Zac   264
Hollands, Oliver   150
Cowan, Lachlan 93
Cripps, Patrick   64
Docherty, Sam 61
Pittonet, Marc 50
Motlop, Jesse 43
Weitering, Jacob 29
Cerra, Adam 29
Hewett, George 14
Haynes, Nick 14
Moir Ashton 14
Curnow, Charles 11
Acres, Blake 7
Carroll, Matthew   7
Lord, Cooper   4
Young, Flynn   4

Progressive Votes:
2959 George Hewett
1503 Tom de Koning
1506 Patrick Cripps
1415 Adam Cerra
1231 Ollie Hollands
1043   Sam Walsh
1003 Jacob Weitering
846 Jack Silvagni
845   Nick Haynes
627 Adam Saad
546 Harry McKay
480 Zac Williams
472 Mitch McGovern
425 Sam Docherty
351 Charlie Curnow
337 Jesse Motlop
275 Brodie Kemp
215 Corey Durdin
201 Cooper Lord
199 Blake Acres
142 Lachie Fogarty
127 Jaxon Binns
119 Alex Cincotta
118 Lewis Young
96   Lachie Cowan
79   Matthew Cottrell
72   Elijah Holland
64 Marc Pittonet
45   Orazio Fantasia
33 Matthew Carroll
32   Will White
21 Lucas Camporeale
15 Ashton Moir
6   Harry O'Farrell
4   Flynn Young

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #18 – August 08, 2025, 08:25:39 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 18: Carlton vs Brisbae
Another shocker.

Trends:
[1] There were 9 voters this round, which is still far from ideal. Unfortunately, our performance was still uninspiring. Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2] The rating was a 6.04, which represents a E. It isn't good, but it wasn't as bad as some of our efforts this year.

[3]   13 players managed a mention this week, which is not too bad, but it was a case of rewarding decent effort rather than clear winners.

[4]   The average vote this week was 20, which is merely ordinary.

[5]   3 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is one better than last week. Cripps, Haynes and Hewett broke 100 votes.

[6]   George Hewett managed his 6th BOG for us with 245 votes, followed closely by Patrick Cripps (231).

[7]   2 players, Hewett & Cripps, managed votes from everyone this week. Lachie Cowan missed from one voter.

[8]   Again, our youngsters made some contribution this week, led by Hollands and Cowan.

[9]   This was a round where none of our lines stood out. Our mids did best, but that wasn't saying a lot. I hate writing this, but it has been quite common this season!

Votes:
Hewett, George   245
Cripps, Patrick   231
Haynes, Nick 127
Cowan, Lachlan   94
Pittonet, Marc   80
Hollands, Oliver   54
Docherty, Sam   30
Cerra, Adam   13
O'Farrell, Harry   13
William, Zac 7
Motlop, Jesse 3
Curnow, Charles 3
Fantasia, Orazio 3

There won't be a Progressive Votes for this week, as I stuffed up and already included the next round in the spreadsheet.

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #19 – August 08, 2025, 08:56:31 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 19:   Carlton vs Melbourne
Our best effort for quite some time, especially since we have so many good players unavailable,

Trends:
[1]   There were 9 voters this round, which is the same as last weekl. Unfortunately, our performance was still uninspiring enough not to attract more voters. Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2]   The rating was a 8.93, which represents a B. Not what we want, against a fellow struggler, but much better than we've been producing of late.

[3]   13 players managed a mention this week, which is the same as last week. However, the votes are far more significant, as more of our players had good games. We really took our moments, which we haven't recently.

[4]   The average vote this week was 29, which is much improved on recent weeks.

[5]   6 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is nothing short of brilliant. We have rarely had numbers this impressive.

[6]   Jacob Weitering managed his 1st BOG for us this season with 327 votes, followed closely by Patrick Cripps (307).

[7]   4 players, Weitering, Cowan, Curnow & Cripps, managed votes from everyone this week. Ashton Moir missed from one voter.

[8]   Our youngsters weren't just contributors this week, they were significant reasons as to why we won. Cowan, Carroll and Moir stood out and got good votes as a result.

[9]   This was a round where all of our lines stood out. Our mids did best, but it was close.

Votes:
Weitering, Jacob   327
Cripps, Patrick   307
Cowan, Lachlan   238
Moir Ashton   129
Carroll, Matthew   119
Curnow, Charles   109
Cerra, Adam   30
Docherty, Sam   30
Lord, Cooper   25
Pittonet, Marc 15
Hewett, George   5
William, Zac   5
Saad, Adam   5

Progressive Voting:
3208 George Hewett
2045 Patrick Cripps
1503 Tom de Koning
1458 Adam Cerra
1330 Jacob Weitering
1285 Ollie Hollands
1043   Sam Walsh
973   Nick Haynes
846 Jack Silvagni
632 Adam Saad
546 Harry McKay
492 Zac Williams
480 Sam Docherty
472 Mitch McGovern
464 Charlie Curnow
428   Lachie Cowan
341 Jesse Motlop
275 Brodie Kemp
226 Cooper Lord
215 Corey Durdin
199 Blake Acres
159 Marc Pittonet
152 Matthew Carroll
144 Ashton Moir
142 Lachie Fogarty
127 Jaxon Binns
119 Alex Cincotta
118 Lewis Young
79   Matthew Cottrell
72   Elijah Holland
48   Orazio Fantasia
32   Will White
21 Lucas Camporeale
19   Harry O'Farrell
4   Flynn Young

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #20 – August 14, 2025, 09:24:09 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 20: Carlton vs Hawthorn
Not good enough, although we did outscore them for 3 quarters. However, the damage was done.

Trends:
[1] There were 8 voters this round, which is one less than last weekl.

Unfortunately, our performance was still uninspiring enough not to attract more voters. Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2]   The rating was a 6.29, which represents a E+. Not what we want.

[3]   13 players managed a mention this week, which is the same as last week. But many got votes for being trier rather than real winners.

[4]   The average vote this week was 21, which is dreadful.

[5]   3 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is down on recent times.

[6]   George Hewett managed his 7th BOG for us this season with 279 votes, followed not so closely by Harry O'Farrell and Will White. Their 1st top 3 finishes!

[7]   1 player managed votes from everyone this week. No guesses as to who it was.

[8]   Our youngsters were big contributors this round, with O'Farrell and White being 2nd and 3rd respectively. Hollands and Cowen weren't far behind.

[9]   This was a round where no line really stood out.

Votes:
Hewett, George   279
O'Farrell, Harry   161
White, Will   102
Cowan, Lachlan   94
Hollands, Oliver   83
Weitering, Jacob   75
Docherty, Sam 67
Cripps, Patrick   35
Curnow, Charles   24
Cerra, Adam 8
Haynes, Nick   8
William, Zac 4
Acres, Blake   4

Progressive Votes:
3488 George Hewett
2081 Patrick Cripps
1503 Tom de Koning
1466 Adam Cerra
1405 Jacob Weitering
1388 Ollie Hollands
1043   Sam Walsh
981   Nick Haynes
846 Jack Silvagni
632 Adam Saad
547 Sam Docherty
546 Harry McKay
522   Lachie Cowan
496 Zac Williams
487 Charlie Curnow
472 Mitch McGovern
341 Jesse Motlop
275 Brodie Kemp
226 Cooper Lord
215 Corey Durdin
203 Blake Acres
181   Harry O'Farrell
159 Marc Pittonet
152 Matthew Carroll
144 Ashton Moir
142 Lachie Fogarty
134   Will White
127 Jaxon Binns
119 Alex Cincotta
118 Lewis Young
79   Matthew Cottrell
72   Elijah Holland
48   Orazio Fantasia
21 Lucas Camporeale
4   Flynn Young

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #21 – August 15, 2025, 07:47:38 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 21: Carlton vs Fremantle
We were in front with five minutes to go, and lost by almost 5 goals. That flatters Freo hugely. Unfortunately, we couldn't provide the effort for 4 quarters, a common tale in 2025.

Trends:
[1]   Last week there were 8 voters, which was a very low. But this week eclipses that easily. A mere 6 people voted. 6! That is a new low I hope never to see repeated.
Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2]   The rating was a 7.39, which represents a D+. It is an improvement over recent times, but is still not good enough.

[3]   9 players managed a mention this week, which is the lowest of the year. Two players dominated.

[4]   The average vote this week was 24, which is better than last week.

[5]   3 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is the same as last week. And 1 player got 99.

[6]   George Hewett managed his 8th BOG for us this season with 363 votes, followed closely by Patrick Cripps, who was more even (314 votes).

[7]   2 players managed votes from everyone this week, Cripps and Hewett.

[8]   Our youngsters were decent contributors this round, with Ollie Hollands, Francis Evans and Lachie Cowan featuring.

[9]   This was a round 2 of our mids dominated while few others won over 4 quarters.

Votes:
Hewett, George   363
Cripps, Patrick 314
Haynes, Nick   166
Evans, Francis   99
Cowan, Lachlan   74
de Koning, Tom   37
Hollands, Oliver   25
Lord, Cooper   18
William, Zac   12

Progressive Voting:
3851 George Hewett
2395 Patrick Cripps
1540 Tom de Koning
1466 Adam Cerra
1405 Jacob Weitering
1392 Ollie Hollands
1147   Nick Haynes
1043   Sam Walsh
846 Jack Silvagni
632 Adam Saad
596   Lachie Cowan
547 Sam Docherty
546 Harry McKay
508 Zac Williams
487 Charlie Curnow
472 Mitch McGovern
341 Jesse Motlop
275 Brodie Kemp
245 Cooper Lord
215 Corey Durdin
203 Blake Acres
181   Harry O'Farrell
159 Marc Pittonet
152 Matthew Carroll
144 Ashton Moir
142 Lachie Fogarty
134   Will White
127 Jaxon Binns
119 Alex Cincotta
118 Lewis Young
99   Francis Evans
79   Matthew Cottrell
72   Elijah Holland
48   Orazio Fantasia
21 Lucas Camporeale
4   Flynn Young

Re: Jim Park Analysis 2025

Reply #22 – August 15, 2025, 08:17:50 pm

AFL 2025 Rd 22:   Carlton vs Gold Coast
We finished well, but were ordinary otherwise.

Trends:
[1]   Last week there were 6 voters, which was the equal lowest I've ever seen. This week, we managed 7.
Still,please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate and it makes our statistics a lot more reliable, especially as I've got the spreadsheet behaving again..

[2]   The rating was a 7.71, which represents a C-. It is an improvement over recent times, but is still not good enough.

[3]   11 players managed a mention this week, which is heading in the right direction.

[4]   The average vote this week was 25, which is better than last week.

[5]   5 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is much improved. We don't often lose with 5 top contributors like this round.

[6]   Francis Evans managed his 1st BOG for us this season with 303 votes. Having seen him early in the season, I didn't think this was possible. Kudos to the guy for improving so much. Ollie Hollands and 2nd, Cooper Lord was 3rd.

[7]   2 players managed votes from everyone this week, Evans and Hollands.

[8]   Our youngsters were our best contributors this round, with Ollie Hollands, Francis Evans and Cooper Lord taking the top 3 positions.

[9]   This was another performance where no area dominated.

Votes:
Evans, Francis   303
Hollands, Oliver   204
Lord, Cooper   198
Cripps, Patrick   143
McKay, Harrison   110
Hewett, George   66
Cowan, Lachlan   61
Saad, Adam   39
Acres, Blake   17
Haynes, Nick   11
William, Zac   6

Progressive Voting:
3917 George Hewett
2535 Patrick Cripps
1596 Ollie Hollands
1540 Tom de Koning
1466 Adam Cerra
1405 Jacob Weitering
1158   Nick Haynes
1043   Sam Walsh
846 Jack Silvagni
656 Harry McKay
656   Lachie Cowan
632 Adam Saad
547 Sam Docherty
514 Zac Williams
487 Charlie Curnow
472 Mitch McGovern
443 Cooper Lord
402   Francis Evans
341 Jesse Motlop
275 Brodie Kemp
219 Blake Acres
215 Corey Durdin
181   Harry O'Farrell
159 Marc Pittonet
152 Matthew Carroll
144 Ashton Moir
142 Lachie Fogarty
134   Will White
127 Jaxon Binns
119 Alex Cincotta
118 Lewis Young
79   Matthew Cottrell
72   Elijah Holland
48   Orazio Fantasia
21 Lucas Camporeale
4   Flynn Young