Skip to main content
Topic: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda (Read 8385 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda

Reply #75
You take nothing out of the game  Not even the game plan. Look at Freo agai at the All Stars. Deliberately showed nothing of their game.o


Re: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda

Reply #77
Brisbane had some season ending injuries and poor start but managed to overcome all those hurdles and prevail so we have to have the next man up mentality. Maybe Ben Campo gets to play Smith's role and can rise to the occasion....
Maybe he could but he's also injured at the moment and the way we're travelling he'll be out for half a year

Re: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda

Reply #78
Very very frustrating! Anyway, onwards and upwards I suppose.🙁😤
Reality always wins in the end.


Re: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda

Reply #80
While it's never good to watch our team lose, I kept telling myself that the objective of the game was to get set minutes of game time into players and to work through scenarios.  Of course that doesn't make it any easier to deal with the season ending injury to Jagga Smith in what was really a meaningless game.

The conditions weren't ideal for footy and it's no wonder that some players seemed to be going at half rat power.  With those qualifications, I thought that there were some promising signs.

First of all, Adam Cerra was moving like he has full confidence in his hammies and I think we'll see him back to his best this season.  The passage of play that ended up with him kicking a goal was notable for his work in chains of possessions and going forward to create the inside 50 target.  Our ball use during that passage of play was superb and every player involved made good decisions and executed well.

Jesse Motlop's game was excellent in the circumstances.  He made the most of his opportunities, created opportunities for others, was active all over the ground, including a run in the midfield, and, best of all, completely shut his opponent out of the game.

Ollie Hollands seems to have taken to his new role like a duck to water and Matt Carroll showed why he was given a second chance.  Nick Haynes looks to have slotted in well and I thought Lewis Young was pretty good.  Mitch McGovern defended well but some of his decision making and ball use left a lot to be desired.  Hopefully, that was just some cobwebs being blown out. 

The last quarter cameos from Lij Hollands and Lucas Camporeale were promising, Skull looked like he was relishing his ruck contests but Harry Lemmey didn't get much of a go.  He should have had a shot from just outside the goal square but the umpires were having none of it. 

Has anyone mentioned that St Kilda got 28 free kicks to our 12.  I wonder if that was one of the scenarios we were practising  ::)

Although we had three genuine ruckmen in the squad, and not all were on the ground at the same time, we still used the two Harrys as second rucks.  Clearly', that is going to be a scenario throughout the season.  Pitto really struggled against Boyd but I guess Kreuzer hasn't had much of a chance to analyse his ruckwork.  I thought that De Koning probably allowed too many ruck contests to become tests of strength when he should have been jumping into him ... bit that's easy for me to say.

Apart from Jagga of course, and Corey Durdin's injury, one of the disappointing aspects of the game was how Jaxon Binns faded after a relatively bright start.  He needs to improve if he's going to be a genuine contender for a gig on the wing.
It's still the Gulf of Mexico, Don Old!

Re: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda

Reply #81
While it's never good to watch our team lose, I kept telling myself that the objective of the game was to get set minutes of game time into players and to work through scenarios.  Of course that doesn't make it any easier to deal with the season ending injury to Jagga Smith in what was really a meaningless game.

The conditions weren't ideal for footy and it's no wonder that some players seemed to be going at half rat power.  With those qualifications, I thought that there were some promising signs.

First of all, Adam Cerra was moving like he has full confidence in his hammies and I think we'll see him back to his best this season.  The passage of play that ended up with him kicking a goal was notable for his work in chains of possessions and going forward to create the inside 50 target.  Our ball use during that passage of play was superb and every player involved made good decisions and executed well.

Jesse Motlop's game was excellent in the circumstances.  He made the most of his opportunities, created opportunities for others, was active all over the ground, including a run in the midfield, and, best of all, completely shut his opponent out of the game.

Ollie Hollands seems to have taken to his new role like a duck to water and Matt Carroll showed why he was given a second chance.  Nick Haynes looks to have slotted in well and I thought Lewis Young was pretty good.  Mitch McGovern defended well but some of his decision making and ball use left a lot to be desired.  Hopefully, that was just some cobwebs being blown out. 

The last quarter cameos from Lij Hollands and Lucas Camporeale were promising, Skull looked like he was relishing his ruck contests but Harry Lemmey didn't get much of a go.  He should have had a shot from just outside the goal square but the umpires were having none of it. 

Has anyone mentioned that St Kilda got 28 free kicks to our 12.  I wonder if that was one of the scenarios we were practising  ::)

Although we had three genuine ruckmen in the squad, and not all were on the ground at the same time, we still used the two Harrys as second rucks.  Clearly', that is going to be a scenario throughout the season.  Pitto really struggled against Boyd but I guess Kreuzer hasn't had much of a chance to analyse his ruckwork.  I thought that De Koning probably allowed too many ruck contests to become tests of strength when he should have been jumping into him ... bit that's easy for me to say.

Apart from Jagga of course, and Corey Durdin's injury, one of the disappointing aspects of the game was how Jaxon Binns faded after a relatively bright start.  He needs to improve if he's going to be a genuine contender for a gig on the wing.
Boyd is no novice but isnt the tallest of rucks and if anyone has watched the SANFL over the last couple of years would have known he is probably the best ruckman outside of the AFL system and uses his strength and positioning in ruck duels and likes to wrestle.
Id find it amazing Kruezer wouldnt have done a scout on their only ruckman or hadnt watched some video of the Magarey medalist and known what to expect.
Disagree on Hollands who looked out of place down back imo and Id have him back on a wing, his kicking out of defense isnt great and that applies to Haynes as well who is a turn over merchant by foot highlighted by his first kick which was a loopy cross ground pass that got picked off for a goal.
I thought McGovern was our best defender and rebounder and will have a lot of work to do in Newmans absence, Matt Carroll is an ok kick but some of his defensive work found him out of position and playing catchup.
Motlop was one of our few positives I agree...Fantasia on the other hand was poor including a piece of play where he put the short steps in where he thought he was going to get contact and dropped an easy mark.
Evans and White with Durdin probably injured again would be thinking we might be in with a chance of a round 1 call up after watching Fantasia.
Lewis Young remains a mystery...dont remember him doing anything wrong or anything great either vs Saints and his status after being told to look around for another club is still at that fringe level and in competition with Jack Silvagni for that 2nd KP defensive post. Will he go hard and fight for a spot in the seniors or just be prepared to go through the motions knowing the club dont really rate him and he will more than likely be back on the trade or delist table unless something dramatic happens.

Re: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda

Reply #82
Thoughts on the game.

Thought the umpiring was ridiculously one-sided. Love to know the count



Has anyone mentioned that St Kilda got 28 free kicks to our 12.  I wonder if that was one of the scenarios we were practising  ::)


Thanks for that!

Re: 2025 Practice Match vs St. Kilda

Reply #83


Has anyone mentioned that St Kilda got 28 free kicks to our 12.  I wonder if that was one of the scenarios we were practising  ::)


Just like the last game in 2024 - I think it was 12-1 to them at one stage......
This is now the longest premiership drought in the history of the Carlton Football Club - more evidence of climate change?