Re: JLT 2018: Carlton vs St Kilda at Ikon on Wednesday
Reply #398 –
Big kid, picking on smaller kids. AFL level is a different kettle of fish.
When i say that i'm not talking simple about height and weight.
I don't think I need to debate that one, you've put it quite succinctly!
He's played forward and done ok a couple times....and gone completely missing other times.
He may well turn out to be better than Harry up forward, but he is not great on the lead, isn't as good of a contested mark and doesn't have the same kinda aggression as Harry does.
Firstly, that'll be a couple of more times than Harry so far, but I'm not going to get drawn into a debate about who is the best forward because that is just you trying to justify your comments that there is no spot for Weitering, which is just a completely ludicrous statement!
Claiming Weitering is not as good of a contested mark, that's just a sign of desperation or deflection!
I've got more question marks over Harry than i do over Weiters, but if both lived up to their potential as a forward, i can't see Weiters being better than Harry. Of course, living up to the potential is the key. Plenty don't.
We had first pick in the 2015 national draft, don't take offence Kruddler but I think I'll trust SOS and Bolts on this one they have a pretty reasonable track record going on as far as recruitment is concerned, and they took Weitering ahead of both Harry and Charlie. That's a hell of a tell!