Skip to main content

Messages

This section allows you to view all Messages made by this member. Note that you can only see Messages made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - chalkybill

76
The Sports Desk / Re: Muhammad Ali-RIP
Ali was truly "The Greatest".  There will never be another anywhere near like him.  RIP.

One small note is that Ali (then Cassius Clay) defeated an Australian in the Olympic semi-final and went on to win the gold medal.  That Aussie was Tony Madigan and some people disputed the decision. Tony got the bronze.  Ali/Clay threw his medal away - into a river I think.
77
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Rd 10: Post Game Paradise!: Carlton vs Geelong
That is the silliest post I have ever read.  'Worried about the lad"?  You are kidding me aren't you.  He's an 18 year old kid, playing like a 5 year defender.

I am worried that being thrust into the seniors at a very young age and coming up against some very much stronger bodies that he MAY not be looking only for the ball.  Other posters agree with me and he is certainly not playing like a 5 year defender.  If he was playing like you say he would be breaking packs apart as he clears downfield not merely dodge and dance around in the clear (or nearly clear).  He certainly looks like he will make it but he requires more muscle on those bones of his.

Remember Watts being greeted by Collingwood playeys in his debut.  They monstered him when he came off the bench and set him back many years.  I worry for the same happening to Dettering before he reaches his potential.
78
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Rd 10: Post Game Paradise!: Carlton vs Geelong
He finished the game OK, seemed to get better as it progressed, so I hope it's nothing more than a corky or bruise.

He's in the background of one of the post match videos, walking freely, even jogging around, no ice, no bandages.
I am worried about the lad.  He ducked his head a couple of times today.  Perhaps when he builds up more this part of his game will fade, let's hope so.
81
The Sports Desk / Re: Princes Park and the '56 Olympics
You need to remember that both Cains, Snr. and Jnr. were/are staunch Collingwood supporters.  There was no way John Snr. was going to allow Carlton to have a stadium 3 times the size of that of his team and the supporter advantages that it would create.  Also I think John Jnr. was Premier when Collingwood were allowed to take over the Olympic swomming venue and provided state momey to assost the project. >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D
83
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Rd 1 Carlton vs Richmond Post Game Prognostications
Just as a thought, everyone saw just how composed and talented Weitering is (needs a nickname, maybe Legend) what about swinging him forward occasionally.
I know it is a big ask for a new player but he is far from your 'normal' new player.
I feel he could be very useful thrown forward in tight situations and could become known as The General.
As a leading, marking forward and his kicking has got to be straighter than anyone else in our team.

Perhaps 'Bix' as in Weet Bix ??????????
87
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Carlton V North in game thread
I DO NOT WANT BARKER AS A COACH!  HE IS FAR TO SOFT. WHEN YOU TEAM IS BEING ACCLAIMED AS BEING SOFT, WHY WOULD YOU ALLOW THIS ONE-FINGER CELEBRATION?  IT CLEARLY LOOKS EFFEMINATE.  WE NEED TO SHOW A MUCH TOUGHER ATTITUDE.  A SMALL THING BUT VERY INDICATIVE.
89
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Round 9: Carlton vs. Sydney Post Game Pain
Being O/S I am just catching up with this incident and the debate.

Firstly the argument that it is part of his heritage is false.  Heritage has to go back further than a handful of years to when a few kids made the whole thing up.  I believe such a silly 'jig" was insulting to the cause of Aboriginal Heritage

Secondly the comparison to the Haka is ridiculous as well.  The Haka is done to intimidate the opposition players as a whole - not a few spectators.

Thirdly -and I hesitate to say this for fear of being called racist - but at my first glance on a laptop my first impression reminded me of a chimp charge.  Now please do not accuse me of racism.  Find an appropriate clip and compare before you judge.
90
Robert Heatley Stand / Re: Carlton pasted by Pies (Post Game)
Everyone seems to be calling for Mick to go but at the same time are naming at least half the team as spuds! No coach can make class players from spuds.  Improve them a little, but not make them champions.  Reverse the coaches for this game and Mick would win as easily and Bucks lose as badly.  What we would give to give to have their top 10?   And them our bottom 10.  It is our damn recruiting that is to blame.