Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting (Read 20512 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

With a workman like win on the board and a bit more spirit on display, this week should be a tad easier to vote on.
Remember, no more than 10 votes to any one player.
Votes have to add up to 15.
Include a rating on team performance.
At least 3 players need to get a mention.

Enjoy!
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #1 –
Team C

Judd 5
Hendo 4
Simmo 3
Rowe 2
Betts 1 (controversial maybe, but he gave instant impact form the time he came on to the ground)
Too little and Way too late. Pull your fingers out boys!!

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #2 –
Team C

4 Judd
3 Hendersen
3 Simpson
2 Kreuzer
1 Rowe
1 Cachia

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #3 –
Team B-
Judd 8
Henderson 4
Simpson 3

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #4 –
Team C:

5. Judd
4. Simpson
3. Henderson
2. McLean
1. Cachia
"We are a club in a hurry"

#united #reset

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #5 –
Team: A  - Gave 4 quarters of effort for the first time this year.

4: Henderson
2: Simpson
2: Judd
1.5: Rowe
1.5: Jamison
1: Lucas
1: Cachia
1: Kreuzer
.5: Walker
.5: Tuohy

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #6 –
Team B

Simpson 5
Henderson 4
Judd 3
Kreuzer 2
Rowe 1

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #7 –
Team B

4 Judd
3 Henderson
2 Simpson
1 Walker
1 Jamison
1 Rowe
1 Kreuzer
1 Gibbs
1 Cachia

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #8 –
Team B-

Judd 9
Hendo 3
Simmo 3

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #9 –
Team = B

3: Henderson
3: Simpson
3: Judd
2: Kreuzer
1: Rowe
1: Lucas
1: Cachia
1: Tuohy

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #10 –
4. Judd
4. Hendo
3. Simpson
2. Kruezer
1. Cachia
1. Lucas

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #11 –
Team:   B
A much better effort than last week, with improvements just about everywhere. However, we are still way below what we show be producing.

Votes:
[3]   Judd
[3]   Henderson
[2.5]   Simpson
[1.5]   Kreuzer
[1]   Rowe
[1]   Tuohy
[1]   Cachia
[0.5]   McLean
[0.5]   Lucas
[0.5]   Walker
[0.5]   Gibbs

Explanations:
[3]   Judd   : Excellent, especially at the centre clearances.
[3]   Henderson:   Probably his best 4 quarter effort for the year. he dominated his position and beat 4 opponents on the night and gave an excellent target.
[2.5]   Simpson:   Fine game, especially early when St. Kilda were at their best. His marking and kicking were excellent.
[1.5]   Kreuzer:   Good effort in the ruck and around the ground.
[1]   Rowe:   Probably his best game for Carlton: he marked well, he kicked well and he was a good target.
[1]   Tuohy:   Took Milne apart and looked very composed and hard in defence. His goal was a beauty.
[1]   Cachia:   A good, solid job on the St. Kilda mids.
[0.5]   McLean:   Not as prolific as has been, but good value on his least favourite surface.
[0.5]   Lucas:   Good early with his run and marking.
[0.5]   Walker:   Good all night at keeping the St. Kilda small and medium forward quiet.
[0.5]   Gibbs: 20 odd possessions and did a job well. He really showed some desperation in the last quarter that you don't often see.

Honourable Mentions:
Watson:   Considering that he was a last minute call up, he did pretty well. I was disappointed with his attack on the ball sometimes and his willingness to give up when the ball was still fairly close, but he did get on top of his opponents and he only had a handful of marks against him. His kicking, but for one clanger, was excellent.
McInnes:   Andrew looked a little slow at times, but he worked hard and had the better of his man after quarter time.
Garlett:   Almost got a vote for his 3 goals. He didn't do a lot other than that, and he appears to be some way off his best yet. However, this effort was much better than for most of last week.
Murphy:   Considerably better than last week, even with some hamstring soreness. 20 odd possessions and put his body in better.
Betts:   1 quarter and a half for 11 possessions was a considerable improvement over recent weeks. Hopefully he can get his mojo back soon.
Jamison:   Outpaced early by Riewoldt, he kept at it and got on top, pushing Riewoldt further up the ground and away from the scoring zone.
Scotland:   Far from his best, but he was good when the game was needed to be won. On the way back to form.
Yarran:   200% better than last week, he ran and chased and marked with a lot more endeavour. Also on the way back.
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #12 –
B

6 Judd
4 Henderson
2 Simpson
2 Rowe
1 Kreuzer
2012 HAPPENED!!!!!!!

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #13 –
Team: C+

4 - Hendo
4 - Judd
3 - Cachia
2 - Simpson
1 - Tuohy
1 - Murphy

Re: Carlton vs St Kilda Voting

Reply #14 –
Team B

4: Henderson
4: Simpson
3: Judd
2: Rowe
1: Touhy
1: Kruezer