Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle (Read 16181 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

- At least 3 players
- No more than 10 votes to any one player
- Votes have to add up to 15
- Remember to include a team rating

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #1 –
Team C

5 Scotland
4 Watson
3 Simpson
2 Tuohy
1 Henderson

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #2 –
 d
6.Simpson
5.Scotland
2.Tuohy
1.McLean
1.Judd

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #3 –
Team: C

3: Tuohy
3: Scotland
3: Henderson
2: Simpson
2: Watson
1: McLean
1: Armfield

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #4 –
C

5 Simpson
5 Scotland
5 Tuohy
2012 HAPPENED!!!!!!!

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #5 –
Team c

Touhy 5
Simmo 5
Kruezer 3
Judd 2

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #6 –
Team C
Simpson 6
Scotland 5
Tuohy 4
 

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #7 –
6  Scotland

5  Simpson

4  Tuohy

 
Ignorance is bliss.

ONWARDS AND UPWARDS!

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #8 –
Team C

Simpson - 5

2E  - 5

Scotland  - 3

Watson  - 2

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #9 –
Team . C

5 . Simpson
4 . Touhy
2 . Scotland
2 . Judd
1 . Kreuser
1 . Watson
I spent most of my money on Women and grog.
The rest I just wasted.

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #10 –
Quote from: Dirty Harry – on
Team C

Simpson - 5

2E  - 5

Scotland  - 3

Watson  - 2
Nailed it. Ditto.
Mens sana in corpore sano - A healthy mind in a healthy body.

Navy, it's not just a color, it's an attitude !!!

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #11 –
Team:   D
I was going to give the effort an 'E', but, but in the end, I relented. We weren't TOO bad for 3 quarters, but our last quarter was faecal in the extreme.
Unfortunately it looked like we weren't going to have a good day from very early in the game, but that is another issue altogether. That Freo, the most defensive team in the comp, kicked a lot of goals to beat us was very damning.

Votes:
[3]   Judd
2.5]   Tuohy
[2.5]   Scotland
[2.5]   Simpson
[2]   Robinson
[1]   Henderson
[0.5]   Armfield
[0.5]   Gibbs
[0.5]   Watson

Explanations:
I found this game very difficult to assign votes in. Basically, we didn't 'win' a single position, and although we had a few players who did well (Tuohy, Scotland, Simpson, Armfield, to mention most) and got a lot of the ball, they were also the guys (if you include Walker) who haemorrhaged goals. The small forwards for Freo kicked the goals and did a lot of damage. (Walters 4, Ballantyne 3, Hill 2, Neale 2, Suban 2)
Malthouse mentioned that at least 10 players had shockers: unfortunately he isn't far off the mark.
[3]   Judd:   Was one of our closest to winning his spot. Everything he did was class. 6 tackles and a some tough inside work shows just how important the guy still is to us.
[2.5]   Tuohy:   His 3 goals were rippers and the work he did in defence was great.
[2.5]   Scotland:   Probably his best game for the year, with 12 marks and a lot of effort.
[2.5]   Simpson:   Played well and gave some run from defence.
[2]   Robinson:   tried his guts out in the clinches and managed to get some good clearances. 7 tackles.
[1]   Henderson:   Had his man beaten if the ball got down there 1 on 1. Since that didn't happen....
[0.5]   Armfield:   Tried hard and gave some run.
[0.5]   Gibbs:   A fair bit of the ball, but he didn't have the touch today. Too many errors and was beaten when he shouldn't have been.
[0.5]   Watson:   Did better than most and lead much better than I've seen him do since the U18's.

Honourable Mentions:
Kreuzer:   tried hard, but he couldn't handle Sandilands at all and struggled to take a mark.
Garlett:   2 good goals and some run, but not enough.
Walker:   26 possessions, but got too carried away by Ballantyne and haemorrhaged goals.
Cachia:   9 tackles
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #12 –
Team = C

6 Simpson
5 Scotland
4 Tuohy

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #13 –
Team E

7: Simpson
5: Scotland
3: Touhy

Re: Votes: Rd 19 Carlton V Fremantle

Reply #14 –
Team D-

6 - Simpson
5 - Touhy
2 - Scotland
1 - Armfield
1 - Watson
This digital world is too much for us insects to understand.